Transcript 0:00 So someone like Bennett knows how to go through those moments. Someone like Creasy knows how to hire the right people I would think that the best explorations right now, I think it's Greenland I think so, too. 0:12 A- and I actually think it's by a long, long way. [rock music] We, we were talking just then, mate, um, that 0:24 discovering something, finding something, like a pure, genuine discovery, exploring a, a, a significant deposit, you know, like being part of a team that does that or having a significant role, that is the most like glorified thing you can do in this industry through a combination of, of serendipity and capability, minting literal economic value into existence for the benefit of, of everyone. 0:47 That is, that's the penultimate kind of glor- glory in our industry. Yeah, you're spot on, mate. It, it takes something special, right? It takes driving forces, it takes human ingenuity. 0:56 It takes a whole lot, and, um, we wanted to explore that, and the perfect people- Pun. Good pun. Explore it. Yeah... 1:02 the perfect people to explore that with are our guests today, mate, Ahmad and Steve, who taught us also a bunch about podcasting. Th- they are... Yeah. 1:12 A- Ahmad Salim and, um, and Steve Beresford are, as, you know, first and foremost, students of exploration history, but they're explorationists themselves and have, have, um, have, have made significant contributions to, you know, their, their various interests in the industry. 1:26 We're gonna... We're just- Let's just get to it because it's, um, this was a, a wicked combo. 1:30 We- Can start talking about podcasting because they were the co-hosts of Exploration Radio, which is a phenomenal old podcast if you ever get a spare 70 hours to listen to all the episodes. [laughs] It's, it's worth it. 1:39 And you can feel their fantastic passion for this beautiful industry. So here we go, mate. Let's share the conversation. So- Yeah. Yeah. And some people have to just socialize with you. They need to 1:49 get into the conversation. They, they're nervous when they start because they've treated it like a, a public presentation or something. That's why in person- And once they chill-... in person is so much better... 1:58 Oh, it's that vibe It's, it's harder to build that rapport if you're just Zooming someone in. Completely. Completely. So like this- Yeah... we've already spoken for 20 minutes before. Yeah, yeah. 2:04 That's a- If you haven't... If you're, if you're someone you've never met on the other side of the world, it's harder to build that because you're like, "All right, you ready to start filming?" 2:11 [laughs] Like what- That's right. Yeah, exactly... you kind of do. So- The, the other one is in a modern corporate world, people wanna be very careful what they say, and it takes a while to remove that. Mm. 2:21 Just that little comfort level of, you know, "I've prepa- pa- I've preplanned 10 things that I must say. I must make sure they go in this order." 2:29 It's like giving a presentation and turning up and finding a slide that you don't know what it is. 2:33 Everyone goes, "That's the worst thing you could ever do in giving a talk, is be so procedural that when something goes wrong, you freak out." Yeah. And you fall apart. 2:43 You fall apart because your procedure has just fallen apart on the stage- Yeah, yeah... right in front of everybody. 2:49 Whereas if you actually put together the talk logically and you know your own material, and if the slide turns up and it's not what it's supposed to be, you just keep going. Mm-hmm. You are unfazed. 3:01 And, and I think also like, yeah, things like, you know, like the preplan. Like, yeah, like when we, when we did it... Yeah, like you gotta remember, like, you know, we started podcasting 10 years ago, right? 3:10 Like that's when we first started. So yeah, so it's a completely different landscape than what it is now. Like, yeah, like p- people understand podcasts. And like we had to explain to people, like... 3:19 I mean, I hope you use this content in the thing, but, you know, like we had to go to people and explain to them what a podcast was. People are like, "Pod what?" And you're like- [laughs]... 3:27 "Well, it's, you know, it's a, it's a radio show." And they're like, "Oh, you wanted me to do a presentation?" "No, no, no, no. We just want you to talk." And you know, "But why is that interesting?" 3:32 And you're like, "Well, it could be interesting." You're like, "Who's gonna make it interesting?" "Well, I'm hoping you will." [laughs] And they're like, "But I don't- I'm not interesting." 3:39 We're like, "Well, we think you are. Like you just- just give..." [laughs] Like, and so like, yeah, so this is like a lot of... And then when... Even then we would do all this prep and tell people. 3:47 Like some of the early days, like I think we must have done like three or four pre-interview conversations to kinda like, like, you know, gear them up to be like, "Yeah, you gotta come," and you know, like, "Do not do a presentation." 3:59 You know, next call, "Remember, do not do a presentation." Third call. "Remember, do not do a presentation." 4:04 [laughs] And when they showed up, they would come and be like, "So do you want me to talk about my, this thing?" And they would just talk for like 15, 20 minutes like a presentation. And you're like, "You know what? 4:12 Let's just let them get this shit out of their, like the thing, and then we'll start recording." Like, that's where the kind of the material will come from. 4:19 And yeah, so the other things like, you know, like I, like I, I watch Rogan episodes a lot- Mm... and I kind of realized that he used to have this like structure where in the first hour he talked, he rarely talked. 4:28 Like if you actually count, he might talk like 10, 20%. And in the middle hour he would talk slightly more. And in the end he would talk a lot and kind of own the person. 4:37 And so I kind of figured out like, you know, that's one of the reasons why we wanted long form was like, you know what? Let's just let the person talk for 30 minutes. 4:43 You know, if they're really well trained, they might talk for 40 minutes in that presentation mode. 4:47 But at some point they're gonna have to switch over to start talking normally, and that's when the interview will kind of start. Yeah. Yeah. 4:52 And then we would burn the first whatever minutes where they were just in presentation mode, and then we would just get rid of that. 4:58 And that, that's why it's so good to have politicians come and, and do that as well because, like, h- how much, like, pre-scripted stuff can you possibly get through? 5:05 If you're gonna go up there and do a three-hour conversation, you have to be kind of a normal human to be able to just- Yeah, yeah, yeah... have a conversation and- That's right. Keep going. 5:11 I mean, like, yeah, like, I mean, I'll be genuinely curious in like when you have guests on, like how many guests ask you whether you have a script for the interview? Like, as a percentage, I, I'd say it's close to zero. 5:22 Nev- never been asked if you have a script for an interview. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The, the, the, the one thing is sometimes people will say, "Can you give us a list of questions?" Yeah. People want to prep. And we will say, 5:31 "We haven't even prepped for this yet." [laughs] That's right. There is no list of questions, you know? So that was interesting, right? Because when we started, everyone asked for a, a script. 5:40 So we had to write scripts and say, "Hey, this is gonna be the flow of the episode." Really? Word for word. Yeah. Word for word. Yeah. And then- A script? Yeah. 5:46 And then, [laughs] and then, you know, like what we realized, I don't know, like, uh, after the first season was that, you know, we could totally screw people over by just jumping around on the script- Mm... 5:56 because then they would get more honest, kinda. Yeah. 5:58 You know, 'cause they had, they would al- obviously pre-trained a certain way to talk, and then you would go, and then like, you know, they would say something, you go, "Well, actually, let's just jump here," and then jump back. 6:07 And then, and in that-I think they will get confused and start talking kind of normally. Yeah. Yeah, so, so that's what I mean. I think it's like, it's like- A lot's changed in 10 years. 6:15 Yeah, I think it's changed now because the, the, the- People get it, yeah... the, the guest side I think understands what, what they're, what they're bringing a lot more than us having to coach them. 6:26 Where I feel like we had to coach a lot of people on [laughs] like what a podcast was, what are we trying to do. Like, you know, why a general conversation is interesting. 6:36 You know, most people are like, "Surely that's not interesting," because I built my career doing 100 presentations a year. 6:43 Like, people want presentations, and we were kind of like, "Actually, we don't want presentations, we want the exact opposite." We want human beings. Yeah. So- We actually want the... 6:51 I mean, a classic, the conversation we did with John, John Van, these were high-end individuals in our industry, and it's like these are friends. Would you like to listen in to my coffee conversation with these guys? 7:06 I'm privileged, I've done these things. Is that something that other people would, would love to participate in? Most of the world doesn't get that opportunity. 7:14 And you're like, and when you do these informal con- This is what normal day is like for me having a conversation with John or, or, or the like. And you're like, actually, that's what people want. 7:25 They don't want to hear the formality. They want to hear the real-life interactions, which is, you know, the classic is the one I did with John by myself, John Van. 7:34 And at the end of it we're, we're going through it and I said to John, "You and I sound like tossers." [laughs] And then he goes, "Mm-hmm." And I went, "You know we are." 7:43 [laughs] There's, there's two dudes up in each other just as if we were having a coffee. Mm-hmm. And it's like this is a conversation. It's what it's like having a conversation with John. Yeah. Mm. Yeah. 7:54 This is what I... This is how I interact when I'm talking with John. The beauty about the medium is, is, is anyone listening feels like they're a part of that conversation, and if it- Yeah. 8:04 Authenticity's kind of the key ingredient. Yeah. No, no. You said you started 10 years ago. And that, like, voyeuristic concept, I think that's really- Yeah... 8:10 that's the part that I like podcasts is like, you know, I feel like I'm a voyeur to other people having a conversation. Mm. You know, like I don't know them. 8:17 You know, like it's unlikely my social circle is gonna overlap with theirs, but I get to be a voyeur on, on- Yeah... like listening to them. Yeah. 8:23 And then- You- And especially nice if they then put as much of their self in there, 'cause you kind of feel like you walked away with a little part of that person in, in that conversation. Yeah. 8:32 And getting those differences of opinion is just fantastic. You know? It, it might be, like you say, outside your group of friends, out- outside of the people you associate with and, and how they think. 8:41 People from completely different walks. Yeah. And being able to just listen in, be a fly on the wall. And also, like, yeah, I mean, this is like... 8:47 I mean, I hope you can cut all of this thing in at some point, but, um, yeah, like one of the reasons- It's already started. This is it. [laughs] Um, yeah. Yeah, what are you talking about? Yeah. 8:55 [laughs] This is all we're gonna do. [laughs] Yeah, this is it. 8:57 Um, I mean, one of the aspects of, um, yeah, like around, yeah, like y- you, you know, in the preamble you kind of told me, like why we got to, like the podcast. 9:05 And one of the points for Steve was this, like, you know, if I'm a 23-year-old in the industry, like what are the chances that I'm gonna be able to talk to someone like John Aronski or John Van or some of the other people that we had on the show? 9:15 Pretty low, right? So why don't we be that conduit where we have that conversation, and then they get to be a part of it, right? And they can consume 10% of it or they can consume 100% of it. 9:26 They may understand 10%, they may understand 100%, but at least they're better off by at least getting that 10% of the conversation. All right? 9:33 So that was one of the, the, the guiding principles of doing a podcast early. 9:37 The other one was really around that I always felt that, you know, like people, people write down what they do, but people speak what they think, or they, or they talk about what they think. 9:48 And sometimes it was al- I was always more interested in like, you know, like w- like what were you thinking when you did this stuff? Like why did you do it this way? 9:55 You know, like I, I have your written, I have your presentation. I saw, you know, you said, "We did A, then we did B, then we did C," and then whatever, right? 10:02 But then I'm always interested in like why did you start with A? Like, you know, you could have started at D as well, 'cause you could have jumped or, you know, like why, why did you not do it that way? Right? 10:10 And then people were a lot more honest about things like, you know, like, "Well, actually, I didn't know, so I just started with A." Right? And you're like, "Ah." 10:19 So, you know, so someone like John Van, you could like, like push him. You know, one of the, like the moments in the John Van interview was when he talked about the, like do- donut of neglect, right? 10:27 And it was almost like he was kind of formulating that idea in his head as we were kind of talking, right? Which is essentially that 10:34 on some assets, you know, people focus on the mine, and some assets people focus on really far away from the mine, but there's this area in the middle which often gets overlooked and, and is where, you know, like there's quite a lot of value to be achieved. 10:44 You know, and then as he was talking, you know, you could kind of figure out that he didn't quite get the concept completely himself, but he was willing to put it out there to say, "Hey, I'm working on this idea." 10:53 He's not gonna go and give a presentation on the donut of neg- neglect, because he has to have analytics to show, you know, like this many opportunities were missed in, in Anglo at the time, and this blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. 11:02 Like, you know, this is how the budget was a proportion this way. He's never gonna put that in a presentation, but he was happy to put that in a, in a podcast interview. All right? And that's kind of what I mean. 11:11 Like, you know, people talk about what they think rather than what they did, and that was, that was kind of what we were trying to get out of, out of those interviews. I'm gonna, I'm gonna fact check you. Mm-hmm. 11:19 You just listed two reasons why you started Exploration Radio. I happen to have a, a clip where you articulate very ear- Oh, really? I don't know how long it's been since you've listened to this. 11:28 [upbeat music] I remember that music. Hi, I'm Amad. And hi, I'm Steve. And welcome to Exploration Radio- [laughs]... a podcast focusing on the past, present, and the future of mineral exploration. 11:42 Now, some of you out there might be asking, "What is mineral exploration and why does it matter to me?" 11:47 Well, there's no denying that we now all live in a society that increasingly relies on technology on an everyday basis. 11:54 And as our reliance on technology grows, so does our reliance on the raw materials, like metals, that make a lot of that technology possible. 12:01 So the challenge is that we have to be constantly searching for new mineral deposits to replace the ones that we're exhausting and using up. 12:08 This is where mineral exploration comes in, and it's the science and practice of finding these new mineral deposits.As explorers, both Steve and I have spent most of our careers searching for new mineral deposits. 12:18 And to be honest, we haven't been very successful. [laughs] And that's not just us. Overall, the industry itself hasn't had a great track record for the last couple of decades. 12:27 This lack of success has led to a number of people questioning whether our current practices are adequate for the challenges we are facing now and will likely face in the future. 12:36 The idea for this podcast arose out of a frustration that both Ahmed and I had about a lack of media to have these conversations. So we aim to bring you a look into the past. 12:47 We're gonna deconstruct the successful explorers of the past. What makes a good explorer? What makes a good discoverer? And we're gonna hear in their words their stories about discovery. 12:59 We're gonna look at this painful transition that we're in the middle of. What are we doing, and how are we looking towards the future? Are we ready for the challenges that we face? 13:08 Are we having the right conversations, asking the right questions? We hope these stories will inspire you, 'cause first and foremost, these are the stories that we wanted to hear. 13:20 We've searched for these stories because this is what we want to hear about the future of mineral exploration. Cool. How does it feel listening back to that? So prescriptive. 13:34 [laughs] [laughs] You know, I'm, I'm gonna point this straight out. Yeah. No, no, I'm going to interrupt you right here. 13:39 [laughs] When we first started, I used to write these really long scripts, and it was me who did this. Yeah. And I know this. But that one, you wrote that yourself entirely. Yeah. 13:48 And then it was me who went the path of going, "You know what? We need to be way less..." And you disagreed with me. You were like- Yeah, yeah... "No, I like... It needs to be organized and everything like that." 13:56 I went, "No, let's just talk rubbish." [laughs] [laughs] But I, I know that I was the dude. I wrote my part of that. 14:05 I know I was the guy who started us off on the whole, you know, writing it out formality, flowery language. Yeah. Yeah. Everything. Everything. 14:14 I mean, before that, I mean, I think that, like, I don't, I don't know how long that script took, but, like, yeah, it was, like, weeks in the making, right? Oh, yeah. Like, you know, we antagonized over every word. 14:22 Mm-hmm. Like, all, all of this type of stuff. And then, yeah, like Steve says, slowly we unwound a lot of that because, um... 14:29 Yeah, like, I mean, like, you know, like, I think we also have to talk about the, the fact that, you know, like, I made this comment that we started 10 years ago, right? 14:35 And at that time, you know, like the, the leading podcasts were really, you know, like, like serial or, like, you know- Mm... things that were, like, very well-researched and scripted. They were great. 14:44 High production, high production value, too. Yeah. Like- There were radio people going into- Correct... podcasts. Yeah. And so I... And yeah, like that was really the, the soup du jour at that time, right? 14:53 Like, the, like out of the top whatever 20 podcasts, you know, aside from Rogan, like, you know, maybe... I'm not sure where he was in that ranking. He probably would've been high. 15:01 Uh, but most of them were all of these kind of like highly serialized kind of podcasts. 15:05 And so, so when we would, like, tell people we were doing a podcast, you know, like you'd have to kinda create an environment that, that fitted the, uh, the, the zeitgeist at that time, right? In podcasts. So, so yeah. 15:17 So that's why we started, I think, like very, very scripted and- And, and heavily edited even though we were early on and the technology- Yeah... was nothing like what you've got. 15:26 You know, if you take some of the, like, this, the hours that went into editing them, and you were like, "We can't keep up. We are... The fundamental limiter is our editing time." 15:37 [laughs] I mean, the editing was hard because we were just so shit at it at the start, right? [laughs] Like, I mean, I, like... Yeah. Like, when I listen to that again, like, I can... 15:44 Um, you know how you cer- hear certain audio and you know exactly where you were in that time? Mm-hmm. Like, that is all recorded. 15:49 I think that's like number, I don't know, whatever take of me sitting in my car in a Kohl's parking lot with towels around recording that, right? Yeah. [laughs] And so that would've been like- Wow... 15:57 I don't know, a couple of hours of me just recording the same thing over and over and over to try to get the sense of how the audio worked. And even, like, yeah, like your clunky background kind of audio. You can tell. 16:06 Like, I can tell he's definitely sitting- Mm... in his car somewhere or some parking lot because of the echo that comes in the background. Like, all of that stuff, right? Like, you know that that's where we were. 16:15 I reckon he's in a little room. Cars have phenomenal acoustics. Yeah. So I reckon you're in, like, a teeny little room somewhere. So occasionally I would do it in my office. Yeah. 16:22 But, um, I've got a, a glass screen, and I was, uh- And a glass wall as well... a- and a glass wall. Mm. And, uh, so everybody can see me. Yeah. Um, and, you know, as- Yeah... 16:34 a senior person in, in the, in, in the company, it's a bad look. Mm-hmm. You know, just sitting there- Yeah... at lunchtime or whatever just- Yeah. Either you've lost your marbles- [laughs]... 16:42 or you're just talking to yourself, or people think, like, you know, you just completely checked out, or you're just recording scripts that we were, like, writing up. 16:48 As soon as we got a studio, the whole world changed because- Yeah... we, we were serious about acoustics, and that was you. You were 100% driven on making sure that we were serious about, uh, changing that. 17:00 Uh, and that was a big step for us, eh? And also, like, things like, I mean, like, you know, like now you guys have this capacity, right? 17:06 Like, a lot of the tech that you probably have in this room probably didn't exist for podcasting 10 years ago either, right? So we... 17:13 You know, so the, the, the podcasting studios we had to go to, you know, like we were really in a, uh, like a music school, in a back room in a music school that we paid to basically have the desk and the mics and everything put into place so we could actually use it as a podcast studio, right? 17:29 Because we could find nothing outside of renting a professional radio studio, which is like thousands of dollars, whatever it was a day, right? 17:37 So, so it was very, like, bootstrapped in, in that, in that time, not just from the fact that, you know, like, we were a podcast about mining and exploration, but also the fact that we were a podcast in Perth. 17:48 You know, like, there just weren't a lot of places that we can kinda, kinda go. Now you have things like h- like the, what is it? The Hen House? 17:53 Like, you know, where they have these excellent podcasting studios that are custom-built. More and more popping up. Yeah. Yeah. Like, you know, walk in, you know, like turn it on, and then bang, you're done. 18:02 You know, like that didn't exist. Like, you know, we would, like we would have to, like... 18:05 You know, in the early days, I would have to show up with our producer, Dan, at that time, and we would have to take the table, you know, like, uh, put it in this location, you know, move all the chairs in, set up all the mics, make sure all the cables ran into the, the control room, all of that stuff. 18:19 And then it all had to get packed away at the end.Because I'm not sure what it was used for. I think it was a storage room or something. I can't remember. 18:25 We'd have to take all the shit out of the storage room, put it in the hallway, set up the room, and then pack it up away. Like, you know, so that, that's kind of how, how we started. Yep. 18:32 Mate, in the exact same way that building out a podcast studio, much more easier to do today than it is 10 years ago. Things have gotten better, better technology. 18:42 The exact same is true for building a mine today, mate, because one of the biggest limitations, power. Power. Power's come a long way. 18:50 In 10 years, mate, the ability to get a, um, a hybrid power station to service all of your power needs on site in tricky, tricky locations where your power reliability might be a concern, sources of power might be a concern. 19:02 Cross Boundary Energy, mate, they have solved this problem for the industry. 19:05 You're spot on, mate, and it's not just the sources of power, whether you want hybrid, you know, you want your solar, your wind, and all these sort of types of power. It's the financing. 19:14 They can look after the financing for you, whether you need to be more high on the, the OPEX and dial down the CAPEX or vice versa. They'll look after you, Cross Boundary Energy. Zero CAPEX power. 19:25 That is, um, that is a, a huge, a huge huge way to get your mine up and running fast as possible. I wish we had zero CAPEX podcasting, mate. That would, um, that would've saved us a dollar. 19:33 [laughs] Tim Taylor is the man for all your needs in power. Give Cross Boundary Energy a call. Go Cross Boundary. 19:39 [whoosh] You had hundreds of, hundreds of conversations with the, you know, the industry's most prolific explorationists, and as self-confessed unsuccessful explorationist at that point in your career, 19:50 did you figure out why the industry has [laughs]... You know, the... Did you answer the question that you kind of, you were, you were compelled to start a podcast about? 19:57 You know- I, I, I don't think so, but I think it's a never-ending journey. If we go back to the actual words that were written in the part you showed, they... I still stand by those. Um, 20:07 two different people, Ahmed and I. 20:09 Ahmed went the direction of very much commercially, more like you during the podcast, and fascinated in just because his own self-development was about building things, the technology, moving into that part of the business. 20:24 Me, I've always been obsessed with the concept of why we're so poor at exploration as a royal we, and it's so I'm really heavily down the psych side, the behavioral side, and everything like that. 20:35 But both of us wanted to learn for ourselves. It was about, "Hey, look, this is my journey and development. Do you wanna listen in to my, to my journey?" So did I learn a lot from that period of time? Yeah. 20:51 Actually more than working for a company, so that's a big call. If, if, if we invert what, what Trav just said there, you guys also interviewed a lot of people that were super successful. 21:03 What, what are the characteristics that stuck out from those people? Like Mark Bennett is an example that really sticks in my mind of people that did it, and they did it multiple times. 21:12 Um, I think it's, it's interesting. Y- you know, like I, I'll frame your question, both of your questions in the sense that, you know, the ultimate goal of exploration is I think to get to a discovery, right? 21:22 To discover something new, and the thing that I kind of took away from was that I think I had a very immature view of what discovery was prior to, prior to going through the whole concept of Exploration Radio. 21:34 What was that? Um, is that discovery was really, you know, like a, a, like a moment in time, uh, with an individual, right? And I think both of those aren't true. I don't think discovery is a moment in time. 21:47 I think it's more like a movie that has many moving parts and takes a while to, uh, to unravel, and I do- don't think it's ever an individual. I think it's... 21:57 The, the role the individual plays is, uh, how they interact with certain moments in time or certain, let's call them decisions, right? 'Cause that's I think a much more easier way to understand. 22:08 How they interact with certain decisions at that moment in time, but I don't think it's ever, uh... Like, yeah, that was my view, right? Like, and it's like, you know, like... 22:17 And also like, you know, like kind of like I think some of the, um, uh, the, the, the constructs around, like, you know, like the WMC kind of way of discovering. 22:24 You know, it was always like, you know, there was a, you know, this Doug Haines is the guy that discovered this, and as you unravel it, you realize actually, you know, like, he played a part. Like, you know. 22:33 Uh, but, but it was a movie. He was one starring character in it. There were other people that in the first act of the movie were actually massively important, but they had faded by the time the final act came around. 22:44 And, and so I think that's what I kind of got out of it, was that, you know, like, when you look at successful people, they, you know, like, yeah, they were important, but, but they were in an environment that I think allowed them to, to be successful because of the people they had or the way they interacted with moments and all of those type of things. 23:03 And now when I look at discoveries, that's the lens I take. I, I don't, I, I don't take that lens that, you know, it was, you know, person X, and they were, you know, and they did it on a Monday. 23:14 Like, you know, that, that... I don't think that's how, how those stories work. I think they are much more evolved in that sense, and that's the lesson I got out of it. 23:21 When you talk to them, like, you know, like Bennett, you talk to him. Like, I'll give you an example, like the, the discovery of Sirius doesn't happen if Bennett was not in Apex, right? 23:31 And Apex was a corporate disaster like, you know, we talk about on the, on the show. So it's because Apex happened, then, you know, there was a link with Creasy. 23:40 Um, there was this relationship built between Mark and Creasy at the time where, you know, like Mark had a favorable relationship with Creasy. 23:47 There was someone else who didn't have a favorable relationship with Creasy, was the other executive in the company at the time, and Mark had a falling out with him, but he got along with Creasy. 23:55 And so, yeah, so all of that relationship, like, you know, that was the act, act one of the Sirius discovery, right? Sirius was act three. That doesn't happen unless that, that, that doesn't occur. 24:06 Now, if Bennett hadn't- It could even go back all the way to, to Thunderbox and probably before that. Correct. Like- Yeah. Yeah, exactly. So yeah, like, so Mark's own movie in that sense has to be that, 24:16 you know, like he acted a certain way to find Thunderbox and Waterloo and, and the other discoveries he'd made, um, which ostracized him to a large degree in, in the organizations that he was in, but it allowed him to go out and do his own thing in, in, in that sense.And so, you know, so that's what I mean. 24:31 I think, like, you know, like, that's the thing that I got away. 24:34 And, and I was-- I'd seen Mark probably talk about Sirius, I don't know, five or six times during that time, and I don't think I ever got that part of the story out of him until he came on the show and he kind of like, he u-unraveled it all, and maybe he unraveled it in real time with us. 24:49 Um- I, I think so. I think I can remember back to the second interview or the second part of the first interview we did with him where I think we got him to a space where he was saying things for the first time. 25:00 So everybody- [coughs]... and one of the things that, uh, uh, is a mistake about discoveries is they're told retrospectively, and all the warts are ironed out- Mm... retrospectively. 25:13 And it isn't just corporate speak, it's just human nature. 25:16 So if exploration discovery happens under such high uncertainty, nothing like the rest of the mining chain, that when we look back on it, like, orders of magnitude higher uncertainty. 25:27 It's what we do, we solve for uncertainty, but what people don't realize is it's just full of moments of absolute indecision. Decision paralysis is the norm in this business, and so it's easy to not act. 25:42 So someone like Bennett knows how to go through those moments. Someone like Creasy knows how to hire the right people who go through those moments. Yeah. 25:51 And, and w- I learned, you know, and I actually learned this from Ahmed during the podcast, 'cause we've spent a lot of time together over the years. Ahmed has a tendency to act before I do. Mm. 26:03 We've had this conversation many times. Oh, we can tell some stories about this, of course. And, and he solves for these problems, and it's taught me. So now I spend a bit of time probably over- overly talking the talk. 26:14 Nowadays I walk the talk way more than talking the talk. Um- Does this, does this speak to a, a fundamental differing of philosophy that, that came out of the WMC camps, by the way? 26:25 Like, when we've, we've had a conversation about this, the, the camp that was the, the, the doers and the camp that was the, the thinkers. Uh, do, do you think it's related? 26:34 Yeah- I, I mean, we, we've had this conversation before- Yeah... 26:36 around, like, yeah, like, I think, like, I mean, I, like, a- again, like, you know, this is also, I think, you know, j- before you kind of jump in, like, you asked about, like, what, what also changed is I also, 26:47 you know, like, uh, I also had a pretty immature view about, like, you know, the culture, I say, like, in WMC, like the exploration culture in WMC, right? 26:54 Like, I had a pretty immature view about how, like, what made that culture work, and also talking to someone like Bennett, you know, like, he gave us a lot more, uh, about what that culture looked like, you know? 27:06 Like, because he wasn't, you know, like, even though I think he desperately probably wanted to be, he wasn't part of the, like, the technical kind of group in that sense, you know. He was more the doer. 27:15 And so, and then that, I think, you know, I think that worked in his favor, but it also irritated other people inside the organization, which is why he didn't kind of fit right. So, so yeah. 27:25 So I think in a nutshell, yeah, that, that, that difference between the thinker and the doer, like, you know, like I got, I got completely different lessons out of what Bennett did in the sense that Bennett just did shit, right? 27:34 And you go, "Okay, well, you know, like, you can sit around and think as much as you can, but at some point you just gotta go do things, right?" 27:41 So, so, you know, so, and in that process, yeah, you're gonna get things wrong but, you know, like, on the whole you, like, yeah. 27:48 It's, like, you know, like I always ask this question, like, you know, in order to find islands, you know, you gotta get wet first, right? 27:53 Like, you gotta go into the ocean at some point, and that's kind of the idea that I, I kind of got out of it. So we, we actually talked about this in, with John Van, about the concept of building things as you go. 28:04 But it's very easy to say those words and way more difficult to actually do it, to commit to something that you don't fully know how it's gonna turn out, and that's the kind of world that we live in. 28:16 And one of the beauties of, uh, let's go with Julian Malnik, we'll go with Bennett from the start, is that comfort to start the process when you don't know where you're going. 28:27 Now, this is what makes it really hard in the corporate world or even with the investor world is if I phrased it like that, that sounds nonsense, but it is in fact the problem. 28:39 The problem is some of the most meaningful things that happen require you to turn 50/50 decisions into 51/49. They require a level of optimism and uncertainty that is nothing like the rest of the mining value chain. 28:56 And one of the things that I think I learned through the podcast is we have lost the ability to treat mineral exploration as a completely discrete and separate challenge to the rest of the mining value chain because we've lumped it all in. 29:11 Because we are, they are the client, because it is one process, because we are funded by them, and we have allowed ourselves to not be brave enough to stand up and say, "Hey, wait a minute. 29:25 We are nothing like this in terms of personality styles and drivers. 29:30 What's the special sauce that makes us drive is X, and we should be in a world where we can live inside the both organizations with vastly different diversity, cognitive diversity." 29:43 Now, it's all well and good to say that. Try doing that inside a corporation. 29:47 It's actually quite challenging, but that is the challenge, and part of the reason we're getting our ass kicked by, let's call it autocratic countries, is because the more and more people you involve in the decision-making process, the harder everything's gonna get. 30:02 And we have to solve for that question. We have to solve for that because if you want a democratic way of doing all this, why are you asking why Freeland and Bennett and, and Creasy and you name it are more successful? 30:17 They're making those really, really hard decisions and you're not. 30:22 Y- you also wrote not too long ago, I think you posted on, on LinkedIn about this, about a sort of decline in exploration across the, the Western world, and that's not limited to mineral resource exploration. 30:32 Why, why do you think that is? 30:34 So, um, I think-One of the things that I've learnt across this process, and, and the podcast helped because you got to talk to a lot of other people and bounce ideas about this, is that most of our issues on a daily basis are what I would broadly call behavioral. 30:51 And I'll actually challenge anybody who's listening to this who's in exploration. Um, as scientists, we tend to solve problems with science. Um, we tend to look at it through a scientific lens. 31:02 As investors, we tend to solve things through our finance. But actually, what are the problems you are dealing with on a day-to-day basis? 31:10 I would say nearly 100% of mine, and I'll challenge anyone else, these problems are behavioral. That is, why are people doing things like this? So let's give a concrete example. 31:23 Why do people believe that advanced projects are low risk? Because they have more information. I know John's mentioned this, but it's absolutely ridiculous. It's just not the case in 99.99% of the situations. 31:37 This is a really, really poor way to run a business. I don't think-- I think it's that people aren't thinking this through. They're just doing what everyone else says. 31:47 That might be offensive to some, but it doesn't make any sense to me. The words you're saying are, "This is low risk." It's like, no, no, this is highest risk thing I can think of to do in the industry. 31:59 We are clearly talking past each other here. We are clearly not talking the same language. Maybe it's semantics. Whatever it is, we are not communicating 'cause I don't understand what you're talking about. 32:12 I really don't understand. Yeah, and I think this is, um, yeah, it's a good point. 32:16 Like, you know, this is another thing that we often talked about, and this is, like, one of the things that we wanted to get out of certain interviews often was this, um, 32:27 you know, like, this fuzziness about why people couldn't go and kinda do something, right? That they, you know, like, what, like, what was the barrier why it kinda, kinda got to that. 32:36 And when you look at, you know, like certain successful people, like, you know, we've had, like, Chuck Fipke, I think was the same. You know, like you, Bennett would obviously be the same. 32:44 You know, like all, all of these individuals, you kinda-- Like Malnic was a classic one, right? 32:47 Like Julian Malnic, you know, like he developed a company because he'd read the story of the Glomar Explorer, you know, like the, this, this ship that went out and explored the, you know, the bottom of the ocean, right? 32:59 Um, and so he-- like that, that's all it took for him to go and start a company about deep sea mining because he'd read a book when he was, I think he was 14 or something. I don't know when. He was a teenager, right? 33:10 And you go, "Man, like his threshold was pretty low," right? 33:14 And so-- And then-- And obviously, you know, like we have sat in, you know, you and I, you and I have sat in the same organizations, and we would go and sometimes look at, you know, like how come we didn't do that? 33:24 And it's, uh, and it's because, yeah, somewhere along the line, someone had set a threshold that was so artificially high that we were never gonna do it because it was easier to say no to not doing it than to actually go do it. 33:35 Yeah. Malnic started a deep sea mining company because he had a, a, a childhood kind of dream about the Glomar Explorer. That's fascinating. So that sounds romantic, and that's, to answer your question properly, um, 33:49 e-exploration is actually a universal biological trait. 33:53 We don't really think about it like this because we work in mineral exploration, and all I've been trying to do is get people to realize that this is a universal trait for all biology, and I can give you hundreds of examples. 34:06 And as a result, there are many things that we know and learn, and so it's very clear that the world is backing away from this. 34:16 We could go into why, 'cause it's fair- one of it's fairly logical, so let's throw one example up. If I give you access to absolutely everything you've ever wanted, every piece of information you think you wanted, 34:28 then you are going to react to that information. You're gonna maybe try and curate that information, but you're gonna be swamped. Let me phrase it another way. You are distracted. 34:39 You are distracted by volume of data, not necessarily volume of knowledge. Let me tell you that most of the things you need in mineral exploration are not written down. They're 100% tacit. 34:51 So when we see people going AI route, we see people with a, an obsession with Cha- GPT, you're like, you are philosophically and biologically not aligned with what needs to be done. 35:03 You have gone down a path, and I understand why. It's like my phone. My phone just gives me the content that I kn- it knows I want to, to see. That's happening to all of us, and it's getting worse and worse. 35:15 Now, everybody at this table knows this is the case. The real challenge is not what I've just said. It's actually how you deal with it. But the reality is we're avoiding. So why would we avoid something? 35:27 So let's make it a, a honeybee. Let's make something a little bit more concrete. You're a honeybee, and you wanna go off and find some, uh, some resources. 35:34 The honeybee part is the more concrete part for people, Steve [laughing]. You wait. I, I never said it wasn't abstract. Yeah [laughing]. 35:40 So actually, just to detour on that, a lot of people go- This is like, uh, that, uh, one of the mo- Modern Family, like famous quote. Yeah. 35:45 It's like, uh, she's like standing in a meadow with a ladder, and it's like, "And how big was the mouse?" Yeah. She's like, "Well, it was as big as a car." And he's like, "How can a mouse be as big as a car?" 35:53 He's like, "You're standing in the middle, uh, on a, in a meadow on a ladder with a mouse." You're like, "That's when you wanna play logic police?" Yeah. [laughing] You know, like, this is not the time. 36:00 So people-- I am an abstract kind of guy, and, uh, and Mikhail, who's a friend of ours, who is actually an abstract kind of guy, who's always going, "Steve, you're way too abstract on it." 36:09 That's not good coming from Mikhail. [laughing] That's-- What-- So why would you go abstract? It's to either illustrate a point, uh, using language that's bigger than my expertise or my niche. 36:23 It's to try and make it a common language. And the other one is because the problem might be higher level. 36:29 So we sit-- The, this conversation about why is exploration declining, it-- the easy way to answer is to g- talk about financing, and these things are real. But you know what? 36:38 There's several levels below the actual problem.I'll give you an illustration. If the problem was strictly financing, why is exploration declining all the way through the value chain from majors to juniors? 36:51 It's many things that are broken. It's many elements that are not going right. It's actually a lot higher level problems, and the financing is a derivative problem. 37:02 And if you wanna solve these problems, sometimes you've got to get them up there. 37:06 And so when people say, "Oh, you're being too abstract," it's like, that's why I'm not gonna apologize because I know that I need to somehow, uh, 37:16 get people to listen to these more abstract concepts, concepts like the honeybee. So the honeybee, if the honeybee doesn't go off and find new resources, um, he's gonna die, okay? There is nothing that can be done. 37:29 It's a biological need to explore. Now, that seems rather a serious way to take this conversation to imply that mineral explorers are gonna die, but it's clearly true. 37:39 Exploration is a need, and it has to be balanced against exploitation, which in this case we could call the actual mining. They're different. So there's only a scout bee that heads off. 37:49 The scout bee heads off and does all the uncertainty of finding the next series of resources, comes back, does a little waggle dance, tells everyone else, and then in come the resource drones. 38:00 That's actually how the whole process works. That's the same as glial cells in your brain. Every biological life form, um, I mean it, every one of them. If you stop exploring, you don't find new things. 38:13 If I keep telling you you've got a source of honey, and I keep supplying it on your phone all the time, you will never leave for the new resource si- site. You will never save the hive, and that is what's going on. 38:28 We don't need to, and it's always been a biological need. Exploration is a biological need. 38:36 And I think, y- y- you know, and so now you get a window into the conversations we used to have before we did, um, uh, you know, like Steve would go on these abstract things and like I would walk out going, "I don't know what the hell we were talking about." 38:46 [laughs] But yeah, you know, like, how's that even-- Like, how can I condense that into a podcast episode out of that? You know, like, can we go interview a honeybee out of that? 38:53 Um, but yeah, like, I mean, one of the things that we, like, you know, like it's, it's always interesting when, when people always ask me like, you know, like, like why is exploration so bad now, right? 39:02 And I think, you know, so like what we wanted to do, and I don't know how successfully we did it, right? But we wanted to go through the gears, right? 39:09 To say that, you know, the obvious thing is that, um, there's, uh, like a capability and a finance problem, right? 39:17 It's like, you know, like we don't, we probably don't have the right amount of capability inside companies to, to prope- properly explore. Uh, and we don't have the finances to kind of do it, right? 39:26 Like that, that's I think the immediate thing. 39:28 Then you can go, I think all the way to the other end of the abstract and go, well, you know, like are, are we like culturally or, or like socially in a, in a, in an abstract way, are we culturally and socially in a point where we just not value exploration the same way as we value exploitation, right? 39:43 Because that, that could be the other thing. 39:46 And so when we like, you know, we would like dissect these kind of, uh, like these topics on our podcast, we were like, "Well, how can we go-- how can we condense something really big into something small? 39:56 And how can we have something small and show how it impacts on something greater," right? And, and I think like exploration kind of sits in this sense. 40:04 I'm not sure, like I, like my personal belief is I don't think it's there's one or the other. 40:09 I think the, the finance problem I think, you know, is a small thing, but I think it leads to a bigger thing where, you know, like you're-- if you're someone that wants to go explore, you're probably not incentivized to kind of start an exploration company because you're more incentivized to start a exploitation company. 40:25 So you yourself change your skill set to go down that path, right? Like, you know, like there's no like... And you see this in like, and it's not just exploration. 40:33 Like, you know, like I play around in the startup space and you're finding it in startups as well, right? That they, like they, you know, like there's now a completely different shift in... Like I'll give you an example. 40:42 Like, you know, there was a pretty well-known rule that in order to get to a, like a unicorn, a billion-dollar company, it would take you X number of years, and that X was a large number, like seven to ten years, right? 40:53 To get to it. And then there's now this belief that spread out because of the exsuce- like the success of some large software companies early on, that you can get to a unicorn in, um, two to three years, right? 41:06 You can get a billion-dollar company, right? So now when you go to investors, obviously investors will wanna invest into a billion-dollar company, right? 41:13 So they have now actively chosen to believe the part that it can be done in two to three years, when in fact it's actually gonna take seven to ten years to get, get to that level, right? 41:23 Like for example, Amazon, you know, like lost money for seventeen, eighteen years before it got to a point where it actually turned, turned a profit, right? So, so all of these kind of things. 41:31 So when I look at exploration, you know, like one of the narratives I think that we have misled people on is that I, I think we have sold it as a short-term endeavor, and it never was. It was always a long-term endeavor. 41:44 It always takes a while, whether that's technically, whether that's commercially, whe- like however you wanna look at it, it was always a long-term endeavor. And we have sold it as a short-term endeavor. 41:55 And so now we have created this malaise where everyone thinks that, "Oh, it's only gonna take like three years to go find a greenfields discovery." Well, that's never gonna be the case, right? Yeah. 42:05 To, to say what you've said in different words, which is something I think you've spoken about, Steve, and Amad, we've touched on previously. Steve, you spoke about Norilsk being discovered over a, a space of decades. 42:17 It's bit by bit by bit.Ahmad, we've spoken about Escondida. The, the Escondida we know, 40-plus years later, is not what they, they first discovered when they, they put those holes- Yeah. 42:27 It's gone through, like, 18 expansions or whatever it is- Yeah... to get to the size that it is now, right? 42:31 So you need to see something like a, a Vicuna or whatever the, you know, what Philo did and similar type projects and have the sort of vision in a sense and the, the patience, to your point, that acknowledge that this takes time. 42:43 Yeah. I just, I just think it's... 42:45 You know, like when I, I-- Like I, I, I've obviously sat inside companies, I've sat on the investor side and, and, you know, like I think this is the, the, the, the message that I find that we have misled people on really grossly is, um, that, you know, like even technical people kind of do it. 43:01 You know, like you look at, like the Russians, like, you know, like the Russians did, uh, like as part of this like Norilsk talk that I'll do, I'll, I'll talk about how many expeditions they did, right? 43:10 They, like between the time that they first found coal in the Taymyr Peninsula to the point where they found, uh, Talnakh, which is the big deposit now, you know, they were somewhere on the order of 112 different expeditions, right? 43:24 Over years. And so, so 100... So let's transfer that into an exploration program, right? They had 112 exploration programs to get to, to that discovery over a period of 42 years, I think it was, right? So, 43:39 so why do we have this perception that you can go find Talnakh or something like that in a new area in three years? I mean, what lunatic has come up with this concept, right? 43:49 Uh, and so and now like, and I, and I get it that, you know, like and you... 43:54 Or if I'm in a company, and I was in a junior exploration company, we sell the dream that, you know, like, "Oh man, next program, it's gonna tell us exactly what we need to know," right? It's not. It's, it's not gonna... 44:05 Like maybe it might, right? There's a small percentage it might, but- It's the instant gratification from all that swiping. Yeah. Yeah. I, I think so. I mean, like I don't know. 44:14 Like yeah, maybe that's a good way to put it, right? Like we're, we're doing the instant grati-gratification or swipe left, swipe right, uh, on exploration programs now. I don't know. 44:22 Let, let's turn this around, because this is where I've been going in the last few years outside of the podcast is time. I actually think it's the issue. 44:33 Uh, and it- as you've pointed out, I think technical people don't even fully appreciate how long it takes to do these things. So I don't think you can do meaningful exploration as a result 44:45 it- when there are retail investors involved. Okay? Be cool. 44:50 As soon as you've got people, uh, with that sort of mentality, things have to be way more concrete, and that's causing people to go this advanced project route because they think that means concrete or closer to being a mine. 45:03 Of course it doesn't. Most of them are further away. That's the, that's the misleading part that I don't know how, that I don't understand. So people think greenfields exploration will take too long. 45:15 So let's turn this around and go, well, why as in a community don't we accept that the world is what it is? It's changed, and the w- we all have phones and we all have social media and we are all on the ADHD spectrum. 45:30 So why don't we all accept this and now turn back towards us and say, "How do we change mineral exploration to do this faster? How do we find..." Let's go for a really radical one. 45:42 "How do we find Norilsk in three years?" And the standard answer to that should be, "Can't be done." Welcome to the challenge. Welcome-- Why should we? We talk about we aren't recruiting the best and the brightest. 45:55 Well, one of them is an image problem, but I actually still think that isn't even the high enough level. If you want the best and brightest, show me the challenge. Show us the challenge for why this it is. 46:08 Put something in front of them. 46:11 If the critical minerals, critical metals theme is correct and we aren't going to find enough copper, and we can have that argument, but say we need to find these really big new deposits that'll lead us into the next, uh, century, 46:26 then we are not gonna make it by working business as usual. We need a transition into a fundamentally different style of mineral exploration. 46:36 If y- and A- Ahmad's looking at me like, "Do you really think you can do this in three years?" No. But I do- Well-... think that's the direction we should be going. 46:45 I mean, the, the, yeah, that's, this is an important question, right? Like if, if, um, if the question is that we need to find Norilsk in three years, then the way we operate is not how we should be operating. Correct. 46:57 Right? So like, like you gotta change like, you know, the, the way. It's like, you know me saying, "I want a six-pack, but I'm never gonna go to the gym." 47:03 Like, you know, like the, the, like at some point I'm gonna have to change the way that I operate to- in order to get the, the fitness level that I need. 47:10 And that, and, and that I think is like, I think we talk about the fact that people say like, "Yeah, like we're gonna find Norilsk in, in, in three years, and we're gonna do it by drilling one hole a year." Exactly. 47:20 You know, like that's just, like that's insane. Like that's not gonna like... You know, like, so on one hand you're telling me the story, but your behavior is actually eliciting a completely different outcome out of it. 47:28 There's that word again, behavior. So I think this is the problem. There's just a disconnect from what we're capable of doing and what we end up doing. 47:37 So actually, if you listen to someone like John, you listen to, there's just so many words of wisdom in what he talked about, and you're like, is that translating on the ground? 47:47 And the question, that's a rhetorical question, the question is why is it not? Why is it not translating? And the answer is we've evolved from prospecting. 47:57 It's a real, uh, evolution, but we're transitioning into like another world, and that world is a massive lift in expectations, technologies, and capability. And- I mean-... that's quite scary... 48:11 and even on an organizational level, I think that there's just never this understa- like, you know, like I think it's easy to say that, you know, this message is out there and you can choose which one you wanna like, um-Which one you want to digest and which ones you don't wanna digest. 48:25 But yeah, even in an organization, I find like there's this like the right hand not talking to the, the left hand kind of thing, where like yeah, like I remember, like you know, we were both in an organization. 48:33 You can go check out which organization it was in our LinkedIn profile. But yeah, like where we would be like, we wanna find a world-class, uh, porphyry deposit. Yeah. 48:41 And our own internal like, yeah, analysis show that it would cost somewhere between like a hundred to two hundred million dollars to find one. Yeah. 48:48 And then our greenfields exploration budget to find a world-class porphyry deposit was four million dollars. 48:54 You're like, well, like I mean, clearly the guy that sits on the other end of the, the dog bone that I sit on on the desk is telling me that it's gonna cost us two hundred million dollars to get there, and you are giving me four. 49:05 I mean, that, that, like that's just-- I mean, that's a strategy built on just luck. Hope. Like yeah. It's built on hope. So yeah, back to your point, which is really, um, you know, we wanna find these special deposits. 49:17 So you mentioned filo or we could go back to the Norilsk and stuff. Not all-- So let's rephrase this. Uh, it's an axiom, 49:28 so in other words it's a fundamental b-belief that I have that's different to a lot of other people. 49:32 Those deposits are not bigger versions of smaller deposits, and as a result they require different mindsets and fundamentally different approaches. 49:40 So you can't just turn up to any random deposit and turn it into the next Norilsk or turn it into the next Escondida. It requires a dedicated act. A lot of people think that's just too hard to do. 49:54 Well, I'll tell you what's really hard to do. It's really hard to find something like that without doing it. That's the biggest problem that we've got. 50:03 So if you don't, and this is another one of my abstract moments, if Columbus doesn't leave Lisbon, he's got no chance of finding America or whatever he finds. It just isn't possible. 50:15 That's what we learned from the podcast as well from Bennett and these people. A lot of people are saying they're doing something, and they're never leaving the port because maybe they don't know how to, 50:27 or maybe they disagree with that axiom that I started with, which is that these are different. Maybe they're going, "No, no, maybe mine could be different." Sure. Serendipity is a genuine, real thing in discovery. 50:42 But if you keep turning up to the same, uh, abused flower beds and hoping for a Norilsk discovery to drive the hive, you are driving-- you're making this really, really hard on yourself from a business perspective. 50:59 You are actually strategically dropping down the probability of success and the ROI. You are-- And you don't know it, but you are making this so much harder for a return than you need to. Yeah, to get to the same goal. 51:14 Yeah. And I mean, like I think this is where like, you know, like I think your question like, you know, like what's kind of the like the ailments in, in exploration. 51:21 So I think, I think that's kind of the, the part, is that maybe we just don't walk the walk anymore, right? 51:27 Like we're not really, you know, like we're-- Like because maybe we've been lulled into this short-term malaise of like trying to do things in, in a short-term period. Um, I mean, one of the other things that I, I... 51:39 Now when I look back at, um, all the content that we created, you know, like one of the things I would do a lot-- Something I would do differently is really work on like what, uh, were some of the environmental kinda aspects that, that created certain, um, exploration success as opposed to not, right? 51:58 Um, I mean, I think like, you know, we, uh, like, you know, you posted this thing about the ex-- like the explorers gene, and I think, you know, like I think there, there is that component in there that maybe we're, we're not-- 52:09 You, you can look at that view in two ways, right? 52:11 Like I always think about it this way, uh, in that I think we are far more governed by our en-environment that we work in than any intrinsic kinda motivation at t- at times, right? 52:24 Like I think there, there are very few people, and maybe that's what separates the really successful people like Elon Musk and these guys, where their intrinsic motivation always overrides the environment they're in. 52:34 Always. You know, like if they wanna do something, they're just gonna do it. Um, and that's also a trait that a lot of psychopaths have, right? 52:41 [laughs] Because, you know, like because they will not be bound by the environment that they're in. Um, so hence the, the fine line between, you know, is Elon a psychopath or not? 52:50 Like anyway, that's why I think that exists. So when it's garnered, I think, to a positive outcome, you get the wonderful things that Elon's done, and you create, you know, like wonderful thing. 52:59 And that's, I think, what that Explorers Gene kinda book was talking about. I think that family had that, you know, like intrinsic kinda thing, where they will override whatever environment they're in, they'll get there. 53:10 Whereas I think a lot of the other times, it's the environment that kinda dictates how people behave and, and, and, and curbs their behavior a lot. And I see this a lot in the startup world. 53:19 Like, you know, like a lot of entrepreneurs wanna be, you know, they want to be the Elon Musk, [clears throat] where they have that intrinsic, you know, override to the environment. 53:29 But a lot of them are actually dictated by the environment they kinda sit in. 53:34 And, and I always like look back now in exploration, like, you know, like the stuff content that we created and how would I look at exploration. 53:39 And one of the things that I often kind of feel is that I think the environment that we've created in a lot of groups, exploration groups, is this fear of failure kinda, kind of environment, in that-- And I, and express this and I will define it clearly in the fact that fear-- like failure is, uh, equal to incompetence. 54:00 And I don't think that's the case. Not, not when you're dealing with uncertainty. Correct. 54:04 And I think that's what, like the, I think that's the-- From an environmental point of view, like if I go to like organizations now and they ask me, "How come we're not-- Like how come we're struggling as a, 54:15 uh, as a, as an organization to find things?" I always think about the environment you've created, and often I find the environment they've created is that failure equals incompetence. 54:25 And so hence nobody wants to-To, to risk that, right? 54:30 In, in so many different sectors, we are very scared that the Chinese or the, the East, if you like, will, will do these things before us, and, you know, metals and mining is no different when it comes to the downstream- Mm-hmm... 54:43 parts of it. And I, I ask this question knowing you've both worked at Chinese business. 54:47 But do you fear that that part of the world will-- has that sort of motivation or will make these big discoveries, and that becomes a, a geopolitical issue? 54:56 Yeah, I mean, I guess the one thing that, you know, like, like we found in our time in MMG, I mean, y- I'd be interested in your perspective because you obviously started much, much higher than me in the organizational structure. 55:05 But what I found was that, you know, we, uh, we had a lens that we, we could do things longer term, you know. Like so we weren't, yeah, like we weren't very... 55:17 Like, you know, we would come up with a strategy and I, I clearly remember like, you know, in MMG we had a strategy and like the, like min metals was that, you know, you'll have seven years to execute on this, and after seven years we'll come back and talk to you, right? 55:30 So it wasn't that, you know, like on a Monday you have a seven-year strategy. You know, Thursday, "Hey, how's our seven-year strategy going?" Right? 55:37 Like, um, whereas I find when I as, as I, when I work as a consultant for a lot of companies, it's like, you know, we, like we spend all this time coming up with a strategy, and then it feels like they're like, "Well, let's review that strategy a month later." 55:48 And you're like, you know, like, like the ink hasn't even dried on the strategy yet. Like, you know, like I don't think we need to review it. I think we need to let some, some water run under the bridge. 55:58 And so, so I think that's one of the things I found when I kind of dealt with people that was like, "You know, we have a seven-year strategy." 56:05 And I, I, I don't think it was-- I mean, I think they tempered with it closer to the seven-year period, but I think for the large part, you know, they kind of let us do whatever we wanted to do, uh, for, for a while. 56:17 S- so I've worked for a few foreign companies and, and this is a common conversation. Let's, let's just be abrupt to start with. In terms of building big things, the West is getting its ass kicked, 56:30 and e- we have to solve this problem without moving towards ideology because it's actually not really ideology. 56:38 So it's not just that they've got longer term plans, it's actually they've got an element of autocracy, which just means they've just got a refined decision-making process. 56:47 And one of the reasons why this is relevant to mineral exploration is the earlier you go in the value chain, the higher the uncertainty, the harder the decision-making process is. 56:57 Now, a lot of people who are at the other end are gonna be offended by this, but I'm afraid it's orders of magnitude harder to make earlier exploration decisions. Remember, we start from nothing. 57:07 There is nothing more uncertain than nothing. Um, I've had-- it's not uncommon for me to get good geos who come and work with me who are not capable of dealing with this. 57:18 So- And, and so sorry to interrupt, but one thing I think is really important to know is that, you know, like you start with nothing and then the, the incoming information, uh, can look the same, but the payoff it could have could be phenomenal. 57:32 Yeah. Right? Like, and, and, and, and I think that's always a challenge, right? Like, you know, like you look at an early stage project, and you guys always ask me this stuff, you know, previously when I've been on here. 57:41 You talk about like, you know, like what project is, is gonna be the next big project, right? And, and sometimes like, you know, they look the same, right? Like there, there's something- Oh, yeah... 57:50 like, you know, like, and then, then I think that's hard. Like I think that's hard to communicate out to go, "Well, why would you believe in this and not this?" Right? 57:58 And, and that, and it really it comes down to really belief, right? Like you have some tacit knowledge or some like intrinsic kind of thing that says, "You know what? I'm gonna back this one over this one." Right? 58:10 And then that's-- I, I don't think that's the easiest thing to write in a memo to someone and say, "I believe in this." Right? 58:16 N- no, I, uh, when we're trying to translate this from the abstract through to, say, investment community- Well, it's like, yeah, like, like WMC probably did this where like Roy Woodall would have the, like the, I guess the relationship with the people that were in certain things where they would go- Yeah... 58:30 you know, like, "I'm gonna go and talk to Steve, and if Steve says it, I'm gonna back him." So you know what that is? That's trust. 58:36 And the problem with bigger, more democratic organizations is scale just doesn't-- trust doesn't scale. And that's actually what we're solving for. 58:44 So the Chinese, as you mentioned, have solved that element by taking it away. And- Yeah... and so we're, we're offended. 58:53 We're offended, or the Russians, we're offended by that comment, but actually it is a way of getting stuff done. Actually, Elon Musk has taken that as way as well. 59:00 The reason why he's successful is because he solved that problem. Let's, let's, let's come closer to home. Why is Mark Creasy or Robert Friedland successful? 59:11 I honestly want everybody to have a go at that because Robert Friedland has found multiple world-class true tier one ore bodies. You cannot ignore that there's some secret sauce going on there. 59:25 And so if you're inside a big corporation that's doing nothing, look over the, the fence and ask yourself what's going on there. 59:32 Well, one ele- one element is that Robert, and l- and this is probably sounding abrupt, has the ability to make these decisions. It is entirely about the ability to make decisions under very high uncertainty. 59:44 So what do we need to do there? Well, the first one is own that. Own the fact that not everybody is capable, and that it isn't actually even a critique of your capability. 59:56 So actually, let's use a real material example inside geology. The difference between an early stage exploration geologist and a mine geologist is more than where they work. It's actually their comfort with uncertainty. 1:00:11 Let's, let's put, make the word uncertainty a little bit more abstract. Uncertainty phrased in common parlance is anxiety. The two are synonymous. If you're under high uncertainty, you are under high anxiety. 1:00:25 So you can now see why it's not normal to deal with this kind of level of uncertainty. It's not normal that everybody wouldn't... It's, I'm sorry, it is normal that everyone will want to avoid it. 1:00:35 So why is everyone avoiding it?'Cause it's human nature. So what kind of special circumstances are required to solve it? Well, autocracy is actually one way. Let's try and think outside the box. 1:00:47 Let's assume that the world doesn't want us to go down an ideological-based solving mechanism. Let's say it just wants to improve something. So why is it taking too long to build, like, Sydney's airport? 1:01:00 So why is it-- why are these big things taking so long? Why are they running over budget? It's the same problem. We're running into high uncertainty, and we're getting more people involved to make the decision. 1:01:12 More and more people who are uncomfortable with the uncertainty of making decisions. So what's the s- what's special about Chuck Fripke? Maybe he goes straight through the uncertainty without even considering it. 1:01:27 That might even be insulting, but that is one way to deal with it. That's no different to the Chinese going, "I'll solve it. Ten-year plan, autocracy, problem solved." Solve the problem that you've got, 1:01:42 but don't complain about that you can't solve the problem, because that is actually the problem, that we're choosing not to solve what seems like an intractable problem. I've got five layers of management to go through. 1:01:57 Well, that is my challenge. Five layers of management. You know what happens? 1:02:02 If I've got a good idea for the next Norilsk with a massive discovery, if it has to go through five lev- five layers of management without regressing to the mean, that's a hell of a talking. 1:02:14 Somebody has talked their ass off to get through five layers of management. The only way you get through five layers of management is if the idea is obvious. Or they just end up doing, doing it without any kinda- Yeah... 1:02:26 the consequence, right? And that's the, I mean, I think that's the autocratic way, right? Where they just go, they take that, that, uh, decision out of other people's hands and take it upon themselves to do it. 1:02:38 Yeah, like, and I think that... I mean, like, when I met, again, when, when I met and interviewed Chuck, like, yeah, every time you asked him a question, like, you know, like, "Why did you do this?" 1:02:46 He's like, "Oh, yeah, I thought it was something I needed to solve." And so he just did it, right? 1:02:52 And he's like, I'm like, "Oh," you know, like, yeah, like, like, not many people know, but, like, I don't know how many people know, I should phrase it that way, in that Chuck runs a really quite, like, leading-edge kinda mineral analysis lab, right? 1:03:04 That he's largely built, I think largely by himself, you know? We- In his garage. Yeah. Like, yeah, like, yeah, like, as a entity. 1:03:10 And you, like, ask him, you're like, "Why did you build a, like a mineral processing lab, analytical lab?" He's like, "Well, it was the one thing I knew how to do and I could make money on." 1:03:19 And then so he just started, right? Like, he just started in his garage. He processed other people's samples. 1:03:23 And then he, obviously along the way, he figured out that there were issues in, in this way, and so he just kept building these things along the way. I mean, I went and toured his lab. 1:03:31 Like, you know, like he has, uh, probably world-renowned PhDs. He probably holds, holds more patents, I think, than, than most, uh, like ALS or anything like that, right? Because he, he invests in it. 1:03:42 They have their own software. They have their own algorithms that they run, all of this type of stuff. He does it because he wants to do it. 1:03:49 He takes a decision out of, out of, like, other people's hands about why, like, you know, should he do it? Should he not do it? You know? 1:03:57 And, and so to, I think to go back to your question about the East and West, I think, like [chuckles] what the, what the East does is the, the, the general level manager, you know, the five layers of middle management that most people in the West have to go through, they just to- tell these guys, "You don't have to think. 1:04:13 Here you go. This is what we're gonna do. Just make sure that you do them all the way till the end." Right? And then that's what they do. Now, there is a consequence to, to that. Like, it's probably not the most, 1:04:24 uh, efficient way of operating, right? 1:04:26 But, but I think that efficiency, you know, maybe if you translate it into a, a certain level of failure rate, I think they accept that they're just gonna have a certain level of failure rate as they go, and they're happy to wear that during the process. 1:04:39 True. Whereas I think we are paranoid about that level of, of failure because we have to justify- Mm... like, how we wasted the money. We're gonna waste the money anyways. 1:04:47 Why don't we waste it and learn something along the way rather than having endless meetings and five levels of management and wasting the money anyways? 1:04:54 Let's, um, let's talk about a new emerging country in this space, which is Saudi Arabia. So Saudi to me is in the same situation as China has been. 1:05:05 They're, they're starting from near zero in terms of mineral exploration, but they're heavily committed, and they bring in the best and brightest, um, and they're gonna do it differently, and they've committed so heavily to this process. 1:05:18 Mm-hmm. And so let's, you know, I'll ask you the question: Who's gonna be the world's leading mineral explorer in, inside five years? I know it's a loaded rhetorical question. That is what's required. 1:05:32 And they have huge amounts of bureaucracy. So this is going to be fascinating to see how they develop this, 'cause they don't have the same autocratic development. They're capable of it, but they don't at the moment. 1:05:45 But, but you know they have, like, I mean, you know, I used to live in Melbourne. You know, like, one of the joke I was told in Melbourne is there's a West Gate, like, you know, Bridge. 1:05:53 You know, like, it's taken twenty years for that bridge to add two lanes to it, you know, in that time. In that same time, the whole city of Dubai was built. 1:06:00 You know, like, so an eight million person city has been built in the same time that we, like in Melbourne or Victoria- That's an Australian success. It actually got done [laughs]. Yeah, that's right. 1:06:10 [coughs] That is true. That is the, the, the positive spin that actually... But as someone that used to travel across the bridge, did my life meaningfully change after the, the upgrade? I don't, I don't think so, right? 1:06:21 So, and so I think, like, you know, like, the, like the, the Middle East or some of the countries, you know, they have taken somewhat of a, 1:06:29 like, Chinese approach or Eastern approach and gone, "You know, we're, we're gonna do this," right? Like, "We're gonna build an island. It's gonna look like a palm. We're gonna do it," right? 1:06:36 And people are gonna be like, "That's insane. You haven't sold any land." Yeah, but that, that'll happen, right? Because we'll build it. 1:06:41 It's, it's extra fascinating as well because you think about your resources and your scarcity that you might have, and they have an abundance of capital right now. 1:06:49 But on the scarcity side of things, they sort of know that their economy is gonna change over time. Yeah. 1:06:53 So they are desperate to diversify that-But that is like a longer dated thing, so to pull, pull the idea back to having long-term goals and sticking to it, there are need- A need. Yeah. So they, they need. 1:07:04 So back to that biological abstract concept, you know? There is a need. Mm. And it's very clear, but the f- the impressive thing is that they understand that the timeline isn't push of a button. Yeah. 1:07:16 It's not going to be like... 1:07:18 That's the mistake I think that China made, and they have solved that, as they always do, by instead of discovering resources and paying, they made a lot of it m- bad mistakes early, they've solved the problem downstream, and they've completely caught us all, uh, with our pants down because it's turned out to be in certain, uh, resources, certain metals, the right call. 1:07:40 Absolutely. You know, I've been to places in China, I've worked, uh, for a few times in China, I've been to places where there's capital infrastructure and no mine. 1:07:49 So they built the capital infrastructure when there's not even resources present. And here we are scrapping and saving and trying to find, uh, capital. They have capital first before resources. 1:08:02 [laughs] That's, it's extreme. Yeah. [coughs] And it can be like, uh, to the extreme where... You know, like I remember working on a project where we had intersected, like, sulfides, yeah? 1:08:11 And I went out on my swing, on my, like, three-week swing out. By the time I came back, there was, um, mining equipment that had been brought on site. And I'm like, "Well, like, well, what's that?" 1:08:23 And they're like, "Oh, that's a processing plant that, that has been shipped down from wherever it was shipped down." I'm like, "What are you talking about, a processing plant?" They're like, "Oh, you hit sulfides." 1:08:30 [coughs] I'm like, "Yeah, we've hit sulfides in, like, early stage drilling. Like, what, like, what are you talking about?" And they're like, "Yeah, well, we've got it. 1:08:37 Like, you know, you found something, it's gonna get processed." Mm. Right? Like they... So like, you know, so they like, you know, like... Now, that's maybe not the most efficient way to operate, right? 1:08:47 But, but someone is taking the bet, right? Someone's taking the bet that, hey, you have something. It, like, essentially it's a bimodal dec- like, decision, right? Like, it's either a yes or a no. 1:08:56 Either we're gonna mine this or we're not gonna mine it. Well, we have the equipment. If the equipment's here, we'll mine it, right? And then they've already kinda made that, that decision go forward. 1:09:05 Whereas, you know, like, I don't know how many engineering studies do we do, like, yeah, to try to decide should it be mined, should it not be mined, should it be mined, should it not be mined? 1:09:12 You know, like I'm not sure that improves the odds in whether things get mined profitably or not. There, there's one other aspect I can't help but think of. 1:09:18 And Trav and I were, were lucky to, lucky enough to travel to Africa earlier in the year, and, and chatting with some people at, at various operations, certainly not Western operations, and, 1:09:30 you know, the, the, the swings were five and a half months on and, and three weeks off. Yeah. 1:09:35 It, uh, it, like, that is not necessarily something we wanna aspire to here in the West, but it's something that needs to be noted. So just the point- Yeah... 1:09:43 you, you, just your point is so important, which is people are solving problems in the way they can, and our immediate reaction, of course, is, "We don't like that." 1:09:52 Well, the message is actually try and find another way to solve the problem, not just solve it using the same tools that you've got. Maybe we can't solve this problem. 1:10:02 If I go back to my time in First Quantum, we had everybody on, uh, four and two rosters. Uh, and they would mature to two week on and one, and everyone goes, "That's outrageous. Try hiring Australian." 1:10:15 One of my favorite peop- people, I won't mention her name just to, um, stop embarrassing her, was an Australian who came to work for us. But we put people all over the world. They got real greenfields opportunity. 1:10:27 They got a chance to live the life. And pound for pound, they are better geoscientists, better explorers, but they did some hard yards. But they lived the life. 1:10:38 We promised them opportunities in the middle of Africa, or chances to work in Spain. Remarkable things. But all you had to do was come and live by the roster that we needed for the locations that we wanted to work on. 1:10:53 And anybody who didn't wanna come, like, well, you don't really wanna do this. 1:10:58 And of course, that is unacceptable, but we never lost anybody because in the end, and this is why I talk about motivation, in the end, mineral explorers are very simple creatures, you know? We are driven by the chase. 1:11:15 And if we're not, we're not mineral explorers, we're a different form of geologists, and that's okay as well. There is no judgment, but those who want to do this will. Five months is pretty extreme, 1:11:29 but just adapt it to what you think is appropriate. What you can't do is explore properly on a roster that's close to one week on and one week off. Like, that isn't gonna work. 1:11:42 I, I worked for a company who remain unnamed a few years ago, and they said, "We wanna move to greenfields exploration." And everybody said, "We want to still live on the mine or still live in Perth." 1:11:52 And I went, "Well, that's cool." And they went, "What's your words of wisdom?" I went, "Can't be done." And they went, "What?" I went, "No, no, think about it. It just can't be done." 1:12:03 You, you know, and I gave them various other pieces of advice on how to do this. But if people don't wanna do this, it's a self-selecting criteria. Mineral exploration is not on a mine, mostly. 1:12:15 Mineral exploration is this lifestyle. If you don't want it, that's fine, but there are people who want this. 1:12:22 Yeah, I mean, and one of the comments I'll make, uh, like around your, like, yeah, like five months on, you know, as someone that, like, grew up in Pakistan, like, you know, like I have a different view on, on, on that as well, in that, um, you know, like when I grew up, 1:12:36 you know, like there was the concept where, uh, someone in your family would go away for a large time. Like, you know, a lot of people in my family would go to the Middle East to work, yeah? 1:12:45 And then they would, and they would largely sacrifice a large percentage of their time with their family. 1:12:51 Uh, but the, the, the fact that they did it, the sacrifice they made would actually make not just their immediate family, but the wider family much better off, you know? 1:13:00 So, so culturally-Yeah, like I, like obviously now growing up in, in the Western world, I see both sides, right? 1:13:08 Like I see, like you know, like I probably wouldn't do a five, five-month roster, uh, but I also accept why certain people would. 1:13:15 Yeah, like I, I understand the sacrifice they make on the whole actually improves lives of many people. Circumstances are completely different. Yeah. 1:13:23 And so, you know, so I always think that, you know, like if I take, um, uh, if I take the lens that I live in, in Perth and apply it there, yeah, it seems unreasonable to expect someone to work five months of the year. 1:13:35 But if I take the lens that that person sacrificing, you know, a certain part of their, their family life or working five months improves their, their family life drastically enough where their kids have a better opportunity and their, you know, like their other family members have a better opportunity. 1:13:51 I, I, I don't, like I don't necessarily look at it as a negative. 1:13:54 I think, I think that's actually o- like I think it's commendable for them to kind of do that aspect to kind of improve other people's lives in-- at the expense of not improving their own in that sense, right? 1:14:06 So- To, turn that around, instead of saying, "Let's not go for the five months 'cause I think that's extreme. Let's go for something like two weeks," which would still be took- longer than most of the industry. 1:14:15 What's it-- What would it take, instead of being defeated by the norm, what would it take to move people onto two-week rosters, two-week and one rosters as a global explorers? And everyone goes, "More money." Really? 1:14:30 I don't think so. My- Just it's the environmental thing. Yeah. So I actually- Yeah... think it's the th- it's the, the reward and the thrill of the chase. If I'm -- And that I know people disagree with me. 1:14:42 I get yelled at for this viewpoint. People are like, "You're being naive. You're being romantic. Whatever you're trying to do." I'm like, "No, no. You know what? I've mentored r- a lot of GOs, and I talk to a lot of GOs. 1:14:54 I'm right. I know I'm right a-about this." People want more. We're not providing it. If you provide no thrill, no, uh, no real expression and want to move people onto longer rosters, you're gonna fail, of course. 1:15:11 You've got to provide, uh, this is your word, and this is one of the things I learned from Ahmad: currency. You've got to provide something to someone to motivate them to wanna do something. 1:15:22 So come here, and let's try and find the next Nareels. Now, there are a bunch of people going, "Well, no, I'm gonna go to the Pilbara and make more money." Fine. No judgment again, dude. But you know what? 1:15:33 Yeah, it's their choices, right? I'm actually-- It's, it's-- There is no judgment. It might sound [laughs] like there is, but there is no judgment. 1:15:38 It really is a case of going, um, like people who wanna do this, you know, let's go. Let's do this. But hey, you know, there's a few limitations. 1:15:48 You know, I love my lattes and, and my, and my Long Macs, but w- you know, we're gonna have to be making some, some shittier coffee for a little while, and we're gonna have to do this. 1:15:57 Now, if you don't like that, well, you know, let me show you some of my world, what, where the, some of the places I work and stuff. And I b-- And then there'll be people going, "Man, I really wanna do that." I know. 1:16:08 And I know that there are people who don't want to do that as well. Good. You stay here. We're going. Yeah. 1:16:15 And I think that, I mean, again, like the more, the more nuanced conversation in here would be is how do you keep the people that have that, um, that inten-intrinsic drive to, to explore, uh, when they go through, you know, changing personal or, um, um, cultural id- Like, you know, like when they're going through a part where they wanna have kids or they wanna have... 1:16:39 you know, like how do we create the world? 1:16:42 Like how do we create the environment that still kinda keeps those people engaged and, and not give them a job where, you know, like they, they maybe get to a point where they're so jaded that they actually go and do something completely different, right? 1:16:56 I... You know, like I, like I'll, I'll explain it like in my terms, right? 1:16:59 Like I, like at a point in m- in my career, I was working a job where I traveled three hundred and thirty days on the road, average between, somewhere between three hundred to three hundred and thirty days of the year. 1:17:08 So ten to eleven months I was on the road, right? Now, now that is a hugely unsustainable lifestyle to keep if you wanna do other things in, in your, in your career, right? Or in your life, uh, not career. 1:17:20 Like per- like personally, if I want to do other things, if I want to have a family, kids, anything like that, that is hugely un-unsustainable. And so, and so at one point, you know, like I, like I left the industry. 1:17:32 I, I stopped doing those roles, and I kind of feed that desire by doing other things like, you know, starting companies or, or going and learning something new or exploring some-something new cognitively rather than, than physically in that sense. 1:17:45 But, but what I find is that I think they, you know, like there comes a point where I think companies are maybe not thinking hard enough to create an environment where they can kind of keep people during that, that part of their life, because they will come back. 1:17:58 Like, you know, they will go back. Like if I had the opportunity when, when my kids are a certain age, like I would love to go traveling again, right? You can tell he has young kids, can't you? [laughs] Right? 1:18:07 Like, you know, go, go, go to, go do that. Because, because this is the part that I value now. There will be a part where I'll value something else at, at some point. 1:18:15 But I, I think this is where, you know, like going back to, I think, one of the ailments that we have, and, and this is why I think companies like WMC and, you know, some of the previous kind of companies did very well, is that they created an environment where they could keep people like this, right? 1:18:30 I remember when I first joined WMC, I worked with eight people, and the, the shortest time span any of them had spent inside the company was twenty-two years, which I found fascinating, right? 1:18:40 That everyone that I work with had been there at least two decades. Like that's, that's pretty unusual. I mean, I, like I don't think you would ever find that now, like that a whole group had been there for two decades. 1:18:51 They all started as graduates. You know, they all went through the process. They all went and did further study funded by the company, came back, you know, went through that whole process. 1:19:00 Right down to the, the lady that did our accounting, you know, like she started as a graduate and worked all the way through in the accounting department, right? 1:19:08 So how did they create that environment which has allowed people to stay for that long?They must have done something. 'Cause people don't spend two decades in the same place unless it's good. Guys, I think there's, uh, 1:19:21 sort of limitless amounts that people can learn from, from this conversation. I've, I found it fantastic. 1:19:25 I think we should wrap it up with a, a question you guys have asked a lot, and I wanna sort of serve it back to you guys. What is, starting with one each, something that should stay firmly in the industry? 1:19:41 You go ahead first. Oh, I knew you were gonna say that. You gotta give me time to think. Something that needs to stay. Um, the training of field geology. 1:19:52 So one of the things that we're under real pressure, uh, is that universities, geoscience is in decline as a university subject globally. 1:20:03 It's about the economics of universities and the economics of running sciences in universities. It's got nothing to do with our industry. That's one part of a Venn diagram. 1:20:12 There's another Venn diagram that the industry is rising and needs more geoscience. It sounds like an equation that can't be solved. The way it's gonna be solved is, um, to w- to do things differently, 1:20:26 but the real risk is that people won't get the training that they require because it'll be too expensive to do so. So fieldwork has become one of our largest costs, the cost of putting people into the field. 1:20:41 But at the moment, even with the promise of AI and every other technology you can think, this is still a field-based science. This is still a science about observations and a science about going into the field. 1:20:53 We've gotta keep that, even though at the moment the equation looks like we're gonna trend the wrong way. 1:21:02 Um, I'm g- I'm gonna go on, on, on a, um, similar point to Steve's, but I'll, I'll try to make it, and, and I don't mean to say this controversially. 1:21:12 I actually think that, like, the, the idea that we should keep in exploration is it's not all about the rocks. I just think it's about people. I think it's about the environment you create. It's the culture. 1:21:21 It's the relationships you foster. It's all of those intangible things outside of the rocks. Now I get that. I, I take your point. 1:21:28 I think you still have to treat people, like train people so they know what the rocks are. But I, I, I think there is so much more you could do, uh, that we just don't do at all because I think we value 1:21:41 -- we just don't put any value onto, onto any of those things at all. And what's something that's gotta leave the industry, guys? I'll, I'll, I'll go first since I threw you under the bus last time. 1:21:50 Uh, I would say that the, the one thing that I would say that we have to get rid of is this, um, this idea that this one-size-fits-all paradigm works. I think we gotta get rid of that. I, I don't think it, it works. 1:22:04 I don't, I don't think it works from a people point of view. I don't think it works from a geographic point of view. 1:22:10 It, it definitely doesn't work from a jurisdictional point of view in the various jurisdictions we work in, and it definitely doesn't work on a, on a company-to-company point of view. 1:22:18 Everyone wants to create this like one magical thing, like this one magical paradigm, and I often say, and we talk about this, right? Like this WMC culture that people wanna create. 1:22:28 You know, like WMC culture was great, but it might have been... One view is that that is an artifact of history now, right? Like it, it may not be able to be replicated in that same way. 1:22:37 So it's that one-size-fits-all paradigm I don't think works. 1:22:40 And I think we're, as, as mining companies, I think we're, we're definitely going down the path where we wanna take one approach because it's that systematic like, you know, or system thinking in that it's one system. 1:22:51 I can teach you, you, you, and everyone understands the system and it'll work magically. But, you know, but y- you're an individual, you're an individual, and you're an individual. 1:23:00 Like your ability to look at that, like the conversation we talked about rosters, again, I have a com- completely fundamentally different view on rosters than you have, right? Based on how you look at it. 1:23:10 So does the same approach work for you as it works for me? I, I don't think so. 1:23:14 I think we need to have that leniency in there, and the way to have that is to not make it system or, or to make some part system but make some parts of it a little bit more human and allow people to kinda a- add to it. 1:23:26 So the idea that I'll, I... In a long-winded way, the idea that I think should die is this, this one-size-fits-all paradigm I just don't think works. 1:23:34 And, and I've actually changed my mind just from listening to you, and I'm actually just gonna amplify the same comment 'cause I think it's the problem. I don't think we've ever been more conformist. 1:23:47 We're living in a time of massive development of diversity, and yet we are making people the same, and that isn't going to work. 1:23:58 One of the starting premises, all the way back to the abstract again, is that these are different characteristics. If you don't want to acknowledge they're different, then you are literally following people into decline. 1:24:11 We cannot afford to build businesses of... So teams are not made of the same people. They're made of complements. One of the reasons why Ahmad and I started working together, we're just very different. 1:24:23 There are different things that we do and want to do that help get the complete job done. That is not a fatal flaw. That's actually a secret to building a team. 1:24:34 A team is about finding complements, not replicating yourself. I think we are incredibly conformist. Yeah. I mean, like, you know, we started this whole premise in like, why, like, why did Exploration Radio work? 1:24:47 And I think that's really the reason, right? Like, I would have a certain view of looking at things. Steve would have a certain view of looking at things. 1:24:54 You know, like was it a, uh, a situation where it was like completely, uh, free of tension or conflict? No. 1:25:01 Like, you know, the- Definitely not I, I, I jokingly always say this, like, you know, Steve and my relationship was very much like if anyone that ever followed Seinfeld, it was Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David who like, you know, were continuously trying to quit the job of writing the show, right? 1:25:15 There were times where we'd go, "I just don't really know how we can, like how we're gonna create this," right? And, and I think you gotta have that healthy level of tension, I think. 1:25:23 You know, like and so, so if you're an organization -- so, so here's something that, you know, to, to extend that point you can take as an organization. 1:25:29 If you're an organization and you don't-Have the ability to handle, like, a certain level of tension between your, your employees. 1:25:39 I'm not sure, you know, like, you gotta question whether you're actually gonna get to something meaningful because I think it's, it... Like, you need to have that kinda, kinda tension between people to get somewhere. 1:25:48 So I- Es- especially in a world like exploration where so much is unknown, like, you know, you have to have that. 1:25:53 I, I, don't know how you're, you're gonna be able to do it without that I, I, I'd frame it, just 'cause we keep, uh, going back on each other, um, I would frame it that there's not enough leadership and there's too, too much management. 1:26:05 People are trying to manage into conformity, w- as opposed to lead and allow people to just develop their own idiosyncrasies and their own personality come through. You know, sometimes the secret sauce... 1:26:17 I'll, I'll, I'll, let's make a compliment towards my former co-host. What's special about Ahmed is his individuality. What's a pain in the ass about Ahmed is his individuality as well. He does things he wants to do. 1:26:32 He really does. That is a special characteristic, and you've gotta learn how to deal with that or we're both gonna have exactly the same ideas. 1:26:43 I've, I, I've selfishly loved the responses, but I have t- to pin you down for a, a few rapid-fire. You just gotta say the first thing that kinda comes into your mind. Okay. Not allowed to justify. 1:26:54 Is this a special part that you guys wanted to do or? This is me managing your individuality, mate. [laughs] Good. So if I fail this, then, uh- You're... I'm deleting it... I fail as an individual. 1:27:03 The, the podcast's not going out. Yeah. [laughs] Exactly. Um, the most memor- Ahmed, the most memorable podcast conversation you ever had over the 10-year journey. Uh, it was a lady named Samantha. 1:27:16 I forget her last name. It was about serendipity. So it was this researcher that researches serendipity. Mm-hmm. 1:27:22 Um, it's probably, probably one of the few times where I've had, like, a Skype call or whatever it was at that time that went eight or nine hours. 1:27:31 Like, I just talked to her the whole day, and she was based in the Netherlands. 1:27:35 And I remember getting off that call at, at like, whatever, 2:00, 3:00 my time and going, "Wow, I just talked to this lady for a whole day, uh, on the phone." 1:27:44 And yeah, so like, it- you know, like, that's the one that, like, yeah, it always sticks with me about- Mm... the stuff that I learned because it was just... Like, everything that she said was just completely new to me. 1:27:55 Steve, the one guest you wanted to have a conversation with on the podcast but could never get over the line. So many. Man, that's o- opening up wounds. So we really wanted to talk to David Lowell, and he died. 1:28:10 Um, and the reason that's relevant is that we did get to talk to David Kingston, which is one of the more memorable episodes you'll ever listen to. It's a petroleum episode. And he died after the episode. 1:28:22 Um, but these are true legends. These are the sort of people that you tell people to go and watch your own podcast because the person is on another plane. That's... So we talk about, you know, Mark Bennett. 1:28:34 No offense to Mark Bennett, but he's one of the most successful people that you'll ever meet, but David Lowell is the man. But you, you read my next, my mind for my next question, Ahmed. 1:28:45 The most, the most important explorationist in modern-day era. The most important explorationist. Um- Minerals explorationist See, this is where I like, you know, like Steve and I kinda, kinda differ in a sense, right? 1:28:59 Like I, I think, you know, like David Lowell is definitely from, from a, from a scientific point of view as a geologist, I think is definitely the, the person. 1:29:08 I would think that the best explorations right now, I think it's Friedland. I think so, too. Because I... Like, yeah, his track record is, is unbelievable. It's, uh- And I actually think it's by a long, long way. 1:29:19 Like it's 99- And the fact that he's done it with different teams, you know, different areas. You know, like clearly he has... Like he, um, like I don't know his technical chops on what he know. 1:29:29 I'm sure he has some, right? But, uh, but yeah, I think, like I think what he's done is I think is incredible. It, it's, it's... I'm, I'm staring at the big score as you're, uh, answering that question and- Yeah... 1:29:40 my God, we could have a whole nother conversation just about Friedland alone, I'm sure. Um, but I, I, I, I, uh, I won't. Steve, 1:29:48 the most important exploration book or the book that you read that maybe, maybe had the biggest exploration outlook impact on you. Um, so it's, it's behind us as well. It's the, um, Copper Mountain. 1:30:01 I, I challenge anyone to read that book and imagine being Jacques Dozy and taking that long to get to a discovery, um, without knowing it's there in the first place. It's 28 days. 1:30:18 That's incredible. That's it. But even, even more incredible is that Freeport redo that journey knowing it's there with that length of time in front of them. I don't think that's even possible in the modern age. 1:30:34 I don't think it's even conceivable in the modern age, and I don't know who impresses me more, Dozy or Freeport. Both of them are on another plane. 1:30:45 Ahmed, the, uh, billion-dollar mining company or, or higher that is most capable of making a significant discovery. Billion-dollar. Um, so the, the true unicorn in the mining space in that sense. Yeah. 1:31:00 The, the mid-tier and higher that is capable. I mean, I'll, I'll go a little bit different in that, um, 1:31:07 you know, like what I'm interested in is, uh, like I may not name one, but what I'm interested in is companies like, like Cobalt or, or, or things like that, that are trying to do something different, right? And I think, 1:31:20 um, I'm always interested in that because I, I look at it from the lens that I'm, I'm, I'm sure 99% of them are not gonna be successful, right? 1:31:30 Um, but what I'm interested in is, is there someone that can come out and set up a new paradigm?Right? And then, and how does that happen? 1:31:39 Like, how, how do we go from the point of looking at exploration co- like a certain way to completely changing it and looking at it a certain way? 1:31:47 And so I think there's companies like, yeah, like I know Cobalt has its distract- uh, like detractors and it has all of these k- kind of issues of whether they're a true exploration company or not, but I think what they're doing that's interesting is that they're just able to access a, uh, like a, a source of capital that I don't think other people have ever had. 1:32:05 And so, so if they can combine that source of capital, which is really the thing that's like hurting a lot of other companies, and they can combine it with the fact that they, uh, that they, if they take a longer term view, which I think they're stru- somewhat struggling with, which is why they've gone down the path that they have, then I think that would be an interesting kind of company to then, to then see. 1:32:25 Steve, the, the, the most gripping discovery story of all time. Look, I'm talking to somebody who's almost obsessed with the discovery of, uh, Norilsk and Talnakh. 1:32:39 It's been a life's work almost to put it together because it's not something that's in the public domain. Um, it's the deposit style I focus on, but it's just, uh... it's almost from another era. 1:32:52 It, it feels like it's too hard- It feels like Columbus kind of like story, right? Like it's- It, it, it does. 1:32:57 It feels like it's too inspirational, and I think that's the same with, uh, the discovery of Grasberg and Etsburg. 1:33:04 People will immediately go, "No, we're not doing it," because it's too aspirational from our current starting point when we're getting on a plane and flying off in our, in our orange suits. 1:33:17 We, we just can't imagine how we can go from there to there. Are either of those two the best site visits you've done as well, or have you got a different answer to that question? So the... 1:33:27 This is actually one of my, uh... H- how long have we got here? [laughs] This is one of my favorite topics. There are-- You can't read your way to the success. 1:33:38 There's so much to read and it's easy to imagine, but you've got to get off your ass and do stuff. And so Ahmed's been to Norilsk. I've had the fortune to both work in Western Siberia and been to Norilsk. 1:33:49 There's-- If you see a super giant like something-- So Oktyabrsky is fifty-three times the size of Nova, okay? You're not looking at a comparable beast. No offense to Nova, I love the deposit. 1:34:03 You're looking at a very special moment in your own personal life, in your own personal development. So clearly that's what I call a teacher. 1:34:12 So I believe that there are ore bodies that are teachers, and it isn't necessarily all about grade, although that's got to be something. Like it's-- it could be something just... It could be diversity. So 1:34:24 a couple of days ago, someone posted something on the, the internet in Russian, uh, on Norilsk, and it was, it was a phenomenal piece of work. I went to the bother of translating that in the last few days. 1:34:36 So what I did is went through a, a OCR followed by automatic, followed by manually went through every single line to translate this just to give it to people so they, so they could see the diversity of things that was in there. 1:34:50 And I got an email back from someone this morning. They went, "Oh my God, that's different." I went, "I know. Imagine if you could have seen these like I've seen these with my own eyes." 1:35:02 I honestly wish you could have seen through my eyes because you wouldn't have the same opinions, uh, about these sort of things. 1:35:13 You've got to go and do this because it's teaching you, and we do the best we can with teaching, but go. You just got to go. It will change your life. 1:35:23 It-- I mean this so seriously that you should pay for it yourself if that's your only option because it will change your life. 1:35:30 Who is the guy you interviewed once on Exploration Radio and, and he was renowned for, for doing these site trips, um, and he'd coordinate them? Uh, Mike Porter. Does he still do them or he's retired? No. No. 1:35:39 He's retired now but- Yeah. But yeah, I mean, I think that's like, yeah, like that's why I wanted to kind of get Mike, right? Because I think Mike... 1:35:46 I mean, to, to like Steve's point, um, you know, like I, you know, like I had studied Norilsk, I studied mafic, you know, like systems for a long time, and then when I went there, I think I came back with an understanding that, uh, overlapped maybe ten percent of what I knew before going there, right? 1:36:02 Because, um, you know, when I went there, I, you know, I was part of an international consortium, uh, but I consciously made a decision to actually not hang out with those guys and I spent most of my time with the exploration and the mine geologists and people that worked at Norilsk because I wanted to figure out what they-- how did they look at this ore body. 1:36:21 And the way they looked at it was f- completely fundamentally different to how we looked at it in the West. So the classic is the chief geologist of Oktyabrsky is, uh, which is the world's biggest mine. 1:36:32 I'm not sure if he knows what he's doing, but my God, does he know more than anyone else. Yeah. 1:36:37 That dude could talk your head off for weeks and you will learn, but you're also-- He's got some crazy ideas, but the bottom line is the man works on the world's biggest deposit. 1:36:47 That's like going to Olympic Dam, but it's one and a half times the size of Olympic Dam. That level of complexity, you could spend your whole life there and not touch the surface. 1:36:58 That's not the same kind of experience that, uh, some deposits give you. 1:37:04 Now, you can do it with small deposits, so the real answer to that is-- So to answer that question fully, there are people who will be listening to this and go, "But I can't go to Norilsk. 1:37:13 Not only is Russia not an option for me, but actually foreigners can't visit Norilsk in the first place." They never could. They never have been able to. You have to get... There are special rules. 1:37:22 Unless you go with a documentary film crew and then you- Yeah. Or in my case, you work in an alliance with Norilsk in Russia. 1:37:28 It-- So you can't just choose that, so it seems unfair to name something that the majority of the world who is listening to this podcast are like, "I can't do this." 1:37:35 So you got to come up with something that's easy, that there's deposits like Manali, which sit in Zambia, which have so much complexity in such a small space. I call them teachers.It's actually an uneconomic deposit. 1:37:48 It doesn't sound like a very good teacher, but it is a microcosm of Norilsk, and, um, that's the best that we can do. There are, there are options in Australia. You just gotta constantly go, not everything is the same. 1:38:02 So let, let me explain it fully. The third largest deposit of this type is Jinchuan. It's an awful teacher. Short created immediately after, um, um, production, uh, seismically active. 1:38:17 Oh my God, it's, it's just not a teacher. There's just nothing about the way it's mined that's gonna teach anybody that fundamentally changes how you work. 1:38:25 So there is a difference, and I know it's a nuance that I've learnt through experience, but I do pass it on because the one thing about experience that you wanna pass on is, how could I shortcut your learning? 1:38:37 Well, don't do this, is the simple answer. Do this, don't do this, and maybe you'll not listen. Trust me, I've got teenagers. People don't listen, but just really stress that point. 1:38:50 If you get an opportunity to do the big things, pay it yourself, and if you can't, look for the little microcosms that teach you, but it isn't everything. The passion you guys have is, is palpable. 1:39:03 I love it, and I am sure our audience will just sort of gobble this one up. So really appreciate it, guys. Thank you. Thank you. No worries. Thanks for having us. Mate, how good was that conversation? 1:39:13 I hope all the money miners out there loved that one as much as I did, and it is all thanks to our fantastic partners, Grounded, Cross Boundary Energy, and Sandvik Ground Support. Hooroogoo, money miners. Hooroogoo. 1:39:24 [upbeat music] Now remember, I'm an idiot, JD's an idiot. If you thought any of this was anything other than entertainment, you're an idiot, and you need to read our disclaimer.