Transcript 0:00 Righto, Money Miners. 0:01 Another bloody wealth of knowledge coming to you by Axis Mining Technology, the best friend of a geologist, the best friend of a driller, and JD, the trusted advisor in drill hole survey instrumentation The best friends of Money Miner as well, mate Fair. 0:18 Oh, Jesus Christ, I love them too. Mate, we've got a very interesting character from Chicago on for this yarn. You'd say he's a bit of a, bit of a mongrel mix. Bit, bit of a commodity trader, bit of an investor. 0:35 Mate, Bentley Atterbury from Myst Capital, an absolute GC, has- Yeah... come on the show An all-round guru Yeah, mate. Any, everything bloody... 0:45 We talk, we're talking metal, we're talking copper, we're talking aluminium, tin, lithium, bit of nickel, bit of, bit of uranium at the ending Yeah, couldn't, couldn't forget the U Oh, couldn't ye. I'd have- PGMs... 0:57 sneaked that in there. PGMs as well, mate. Yeah And, like, real high level on the bloody, the, the... Any- You wanna know about TCRS and refining charges for copper, mate, this is, this is the one-stop shop Yeah. 1:08 Fascinating chat, and kinda like you say there, Myst Capital as well as Myst Trading, so it's a, it's a funky crossroads between commodity trader and investor in, you know, the, the natural resource world. 1:19 He's got some colleagues that he works with that focus on other commodities, but he is all about the metals, like you said, Matty. He's spent a lot of time lately in China. 1:27 He's got some, you know, inside knowledge that he wants to share with us from, you know, the, the lithium operations, the integration over there. 1:34 He's taken positions in copper lately, so we talk about the, the really dramatic run-up that we saw and then, you know, the, the short side of it in the last couple months. 1:43 So yeah, it was a, it was a fascinating chat and a, and a deep dive on someone who's clearly done a lot of work. He's- Mm... 1:48 posted some research on the, on the company's website you can get into and, and read his sort of, his takes and his words. So yeah, all, all these- It's all go, mate... funky directions. It's all go. Let's just rip in. 1:59 Let's do it. Boom. Righto, Money Miners, here we go. We've got Bentley Atterbury from Myst Capital in Chicago. Boys, we, we engaged with Myst a while ago. 2:09 We asked for the Scottie Pippen, but they've sent us the Michael Jordan- [laughs]... of Myst Capital. [laughs] The main man himself, number 23 in funds management. Cobba, welcome to the show. 2:23 Ah, that's just a hell of an introduction. I don't even know what to say to that, but [laughs] I told you I'd come up with something. [laughs] That was a great reference. I wasn't expecting that. That, that was good. 2:33 That was good. Uh, but yeah, thanks for having me on, guys. It's, uh, it's a lot of fun. Been, 2:38 uh, tuned, tuned in to you guys, I don't know, maybe six months ago or something like that, and I found it really interesting. Ah, awesome, mate That, um... 2:46 I struggle to always find, uh, podcasts in the finance industry, um, just 'cause a lot of the time it tends to be people that are, you know, you know, talking heads on TV and stuff. 2:54 They like, they like to basically go on TV just to sound smart, and so you don't really get much out of it, and there's no personalities, so I get bored, I guess. So- [laughs]... then found you guys and- Us, us two. 3:03 Yeah, that's why we started the podcast. [laughs] No, that was it. That was the foundation of the business, mate. That's awesome. 3:06 [laughs] We're like, "Fuck, there's no one on YouTube that just talks shit about the markets." [laughs] "Um, yeah, let's do that." [laughs] Nah, we just try to sound smart. Yeah. Mate, let's, uh... 3:15 We're gonna rip in with, uh... Mate, we're talking metal today. Every type of fricking metal on the planet, and mate, these boys have, uh, got it mapped out sensationally. JD- Yeah... where are we starting? 3:28 Yeah, I think we wanna start with copper, right, JD? I think we've got to. So you're at that awesome intersection and c- you know, copper's that, one of the... It's probably the most interesting place to start. 3:38 Given what's happened in the past couple months, you've had the, the short squeeze up. 3:42 You've got that real mixture of hedge funds getting involved, commodity traders, you know, the, the, the people more downstream, the smelters and refiners having a bit of a pinch on. 3:51 So how has copper sort of played out versus your kind of expectations this year, Bentley? 3:57 Um, well, I, I guess you guys have probably seen the date on the, on the piece I wrote, so it was, it was painful there for a couple months, but [laughs] - Mm... it's, uh, it, you know, that, that shit happens. 4:06 Um, and ultimately it's played out. 4:08 I guess, you know, we're fortunate to be recording this now and not a month and a half ago, um, so now I can essentially say it's played out pretty similar to what, what we've been, um, expecting outside of that period between April and, uh, two, three weeks ago, maybe a month ago. 4:24 And uh, I was actually just reviewing some notes earlier too from a couple years back, and it was interesting. 4:29 Had, had kind of an, a, a different situation where, um, you had TC, TC rates, the treatment charge rates, rising quite a bit- Mm... which typically signals, you know, just, um, oversupply in the concentrate market. 4:42 So I know you guys have brought it up a few times before, but just for anybody that doesn't remember, uh, a treatment charge is what the smelters make to refine concentrate, essentially, into metal. 4:52 Um, sometimes it goes to blister first and then, then to refined cathode. But that's effectively their margin on it. And 5:01 we saw how, it was '21, '22, so '22 heading into early '23, I believe it was, you had, uh, PPC, so Pan Pacific Copper, they're one of the larger, um, smelters out in Asia, uh, uh, Japan actually, and they ha- had unexpected maintenance, and they ended up dumping a couple hundred thousand tons of concentrate onto the market that hit China, while at the same time, all these smelters and refiners in China, 5:26 um, including Tungsten, I believe, they were, um, also slower to ramp up new projects and that... You know, fast-forward, we'll get into that. It's kind of had an impact now. 5:36 So you actually had TCs rise quite a bit unexpectedly, and I was, you know, writing, writing a note back then about how, hey, TC rates are rising, but that doesn't actually mean that copper is oversupplied right now, the metal. 5:48 Fast-forward to this year and you had a little bit of the... Essentially the op- the exact opposite happened. Um, 5:55 i- if you look at demand data for refined copper cathode last year, you'll actually see that, you'll look at it and it looks like China had a, something, somewhere between 5 and 7% increase in demand for copper cathode. 6:07 And okay, anybody can-You know, look, the green energy space has made up a big difference, um, in terms of the lost demand from, um, construction like real estate and that sort of thing, and, and also late stage real estate picked up last, last year, like finishing, that's where copper comes in as well. 6:26 But you're like, "Ah, that just doesn't seem right. Um, something, something's not here, right here." So, you know, for us, we look at that and we're like, "Okay, someone, someone's holding the metal somewhere." Um, and 6:37 then you had Cobre Panama happen, which you guys are all familiar with. Um, uh, positive news from them actually today. Uh, we can get in that later, but, um, Cobre Panama happened towards the end of last year. 6:48 So then you had almost, it almost felt like a squeeze in the trader space, the, that needed to 6:57 s- secure material for 2024 at that point in terms of concentrate and, and/or the traders were potentially kind of squeezing the market. I, I don't know which. I won't necessarily conjecture too much on that. 7:08 And so they're, they're hoarding the concentrate and looking at that a little bit, we're like, "Well, okay. 7:14 That, uh, the, the metal is not in, is in short supply at this point, but the concentrate clearly is, and there's, there's a problem going on there." And, um, you also had a combination of that in the refineries. 7:26 So you have a lot of smelters and refiners coming online, um, still happening, uh, everywhere from, um... Oh, God, what's, what's Freeport's- Indonesia... project in the... I can't remember their- Freeport- Yeah. 7:37 Not, not, not, like a... Not Grasberg, but their smelter project. Oh, yeah, yeah. They have that coming online this year, so yeah. PT- Yeah... FT. PT, yeah. Mayar or something. [chuckles] So yes. So they had, um... 7:52 So they were also holding onto extra concentrate at the same time and they, you know, recently the government's left to export it. 7:57 That, that could be somewhere between 300,000-ish tons of concentrate possibly in the market or more now. 8:03 And so you just kind of had this general squeeze in the concentrate markets and, you know, that signal got picked up on the, um, by, let's just say the financial side of the sector, and copper had been in a pretty tight range for several months and it's been pretty bad. 8:18 I mean, just demand and manufacturing globally has been pretty weak, and that lines up with that. 8:22 So you had a little bit of a breakout, technical signals, then you had the financials taking advantage of, you know, the breakout and the squeeze, and it also 8:31 caused an issue on the CME, which is a actually completely different issue, and that then just accelerated things, and so you had this period where, 8:40 um, you know, time spreads, pr- prompt spreads blew out to record levels. Not necessarily as a percentage, but, um, you know, it was, you know, still nearing full carry on that sort of thing. 8:49 And it just, all these signals were, okay, supply is not that, or demand is not that strong. 8:54 And, um, sometimes that can be frustrating as someone, as a, if you're taking call it like speculative positions in the market, and it's all about 9:02 the way you position that and being able to hold through such things, you never know how far it might go. But we've seen that definitely release a little bit here in the past several months. 9:10 Now we're back down towards 9,000. So it's a little more of an appropriate price level. Um, you know, inventories are still high. Chinese inventories were at near record levels at one point, I think. 9:21 So, uh, the metal is starting to flow back and forth but, um, I don't know if you want me to go into- Yeah... a little bit the CME issue. 9:28 I, I- That's a little bit different but- It's kind of, it's kind of interesting, right? Because I think, you know, to a, to a, a rookie just observing the, the copper market, you don't necessarily, you can't... 9:36 You don't distinguish the difference between the, the concentrate market and the, you know, the, the metal units or, or cathode market. 9:43 Um, and the price kind of ran up but, you know, based on a, on a, on a, on a capa- capacity dynamic with the, with the sm- with the, with the smelters as opposed to the actual end product demand in that case. 9:55 Is that a fair synopsis? Yeah. Yeah, definitely. I think, um, I think I was actually had... You had guys on, a guy on in like a month or so ago that was pointing that as well, and that's what it was. Yeah. 10:04 It, it was kind of run away for the, for the wrong reasons and there's also, out of 26 10:12 to 27 million tons a year in cathode space, um, you got, you still have about 4 million tons of that, 4 and a half million tons of that actually comes from, from recycled sources. So that's part of the, 10:24 um, forgotten, forgotten space as well, but it's also... Now, now they're starting to actually be a little bit of a issue on the supply side for, um, scrap that's happening right now as well. 10:35 So we're kind of keeping an eye on that 'cause- Y- you're both a trader-... 0.5%... 10:38 and a, and a hedge fund, Bentley, so what were the, what, what were the financial players actually doing during the, in the copper run-up over the, you know, early part of the year? So it was all over the place. 10:51 People were... 10:52 So from the trader's perspective, we had saw Trafigura and IXM trying to cover positions by getting metal to the US, and then that in itself is very difficult because, um, that CME contract tends to be the one that, um, a lot of financial players use, but it's not a very representative contract of the market. 11:10 In fact, it's very little. It, it, um... Oh, yeah, Matt mentioned in the notes that it is very reminiscent of the problem we had in nickel on the LME a few years back. Um, and it... 11:23 We expect this sort of thing, by the way, to happen again in the near future for the similar reasons, just because, you know, demand in the United States for copper peaked in the '80s effectively. 11:35 Um, now it's only about one and a half million tons a year here used of copper cathode. Um, even less these days. 11:42 I think that figure's about right for '23, whereas at the start of the century, we were over two million tons and it was 15% of global demand, and now it's more like 5%. And supply is the same story. 11:53 It's been going downhill for quite some time, but typically inventories and trading, um, gravitates towards where it uses, so where demand is. And 12:06 you just don't have that many war- that much warranted mater- material that you can warrant onto the CME out there. 12:13 It's, uh, you can't use any Chinese material, you can't use any Russian material.Uh, South America's okay. Uh, there's a lot of South America that actually, it clears customs tariff-free. 12:21 So, uh, what we believe we saw Trafigura and ICSM doing, and I won't... I don't necessarily wanna speak for what they're doing, but I'm just conjecture, is having to shift around materials. 12:31 So they had to pull material probably out of South America or even here domestically, and then cover that with, uh... What you would do as a commodity trader is you'd have to cover something else. 12:40 So you couldn't use Chinese material, but you could use Chinese material to cover the, what you need for other clients, while as you can shift maybe South American material up to the US. 12:47 [laughs] And they've been working to try to do that and get, um... Yeah, deliver, just to take a advantage of the, the price spread difference as well. And then, 12:56 you know how the financial players get with the media and stuff. They're like, "Oh, price squeeze," and they all try to squeeze the markets, and it just kinda- Yeah... overlaid with that. 13:02 There were so many, there were so many, like, big names being like, you know, "Copper's the trade of the, of, uh, you know, of m- of my career," and all this sort of stuff. Mm. Um, he- heaps of headlines like that. 13:12 Oh, I do that. Is that, is that, is that the, the playbook in the US? You just kind of, you know, ramp your thesis and then exit on, on the speculative [laughs] like mania that comes from it? 13:22 [laughs] I don't necessarily do that. [laughs] Um, so I, I don't know if I wanna speak for others. We, I mean, we were, uh, just being open about it. 13:33 It, it's no secret if you kinda read some of our stuff where we were, we were short, so we were not doing that. [laughs] Um, hung out short, did just fine. But, um, yeah, you hear people do that, right? 13:44 You had a- someone like Andrew Bent. Um, no, no comment about him. He's, he... Very successful hedge fund in the commodity space, but he's known for his crude, right? He's a very, very well-known- Yeah... crude trader. 13:55 Even like, go on his website and it's all about green energy and windmills, it's kinda funny. [laughs] Uh, and he all of a sudden was like, "Oh, I'm, I'm out of the crude markets now. I'm only on copper and cocoa." 14:04 And I'm like, "Oh, Jesus, all right." Like [laughs] Yeah, he did the same with cocoa. Like... [laughs] Yeah. [laughs] It's like- Yeah... "Oh, no." Which cocoa's a whole... 14:11 I mean, that's, you're betting on weather effectively at that point, so. Yeah. Mm. You get, he had a lot of that. And then when it's not a deliverable, when there's not much product to be delivered, you have problems. 14:21 And we actually see it in Nymex crude as well, and that's part of the reason why that went to negative pricing. 14:28 There's a lot of that that went on as well in 2020, and you might see that as well, 'cause Nymex crude is a pretty specific... Right, it's the same thing. It's got like, it's not, uh... It's not really what... 14:39 You know, Midland WTI is not Nymex crude, even though it's what it says it is. So, um, yeah, the, if they don't, the exchange doesn't do anything to fix it, you'll, you'll see this happen again. With the- Yeah. 14:49 [laughs] With the cop- copper on the LME, uh, when you're talking about nickel before, like, you know, nickel you got, you know, briquettes, the sulfide. 14:58 Like, comes in all different forms that all gets sorta priced the, priced the same. Is... How does the copper one work? Do you... Say, if you've got copper cathode, is there a copper rod, uh, market as well? 15:10 Are there different products, or is copper cathode the end- Oh, wow... product? Geez. Matty, how old are you? [laughs] Too young to not know. [laughs] Oh, no. 15:21 [laughs] No, no, I was, I was making a joke, 'cause there was, back in, oh my God, '70s, '80s or something like that, they tried a few different, um, copper products, um, 15:31 on the LME, and they effectively found that the highest value, highest quality good survives. And they did have a, I believe it was a rod product for a little while. But it, it, just the cathode is what survived. 15:45 So it is... Copper is just cathodes. Yeah. Um- Okay. That makes sense. Yeah. [clears throat] Yep, yep. And, um, 15:53 I believe the CME as well is the same thing, it's just the different brands that can be delivered in the different delivery types and locations, right? I mean, you're... 16:03 Who's gonna want or deliver material to a Phoenix, Arizona warehouse? Like, that's, that's a pain in the ass. 16:08 That's expensive rail from probably West Coast port, unless you're Rio Tinto, as we were talking about earlier. Someone like that, that's their free port, right? Well, yeah, sorry, Phoenix would obviously be free port. 16:20 Odd to have a warehouse near their offices, but, you know. Yeah. [laughs] Yeah. Someone's paying the bills. How, how homogen- How, how homogenous is copper cathode across the world? Is there different qualities of it? 16:32 It's- Does it vary much or not? Yeah. No, there, there certainly are, but it's gotten to the point where it's pretty... It's, it's one of the more commoditized commodities, as we like to say. 16:43 Um, you know, we'll get into lithium stuff later, but, you know, commodities are really not commoditized. Um, crude oil's the same way. It's the largest one that there is. But, uh, it's pretty homogenous to the point... 16:55 I mean, there are li- And the equivalent grade cathodes do trade. They have their own discount or, uh, never seen a premium, but they have their own discount to, um, deliverable grades as well. 17:07 Um, those went really deeply negative actually about a month ago in, in China, down in warehouses, 'cause it's like, well, you can't even deliver these anywhere, so that's just for cu- downstream customers. 17:16 But there's, they're still pretty... I don't know. They're fairly homogenous. Yeah, right. I, uh, Bentley, I'll tell you what, but. I'll tell you something that's not homogenous like copper cathode, 17:27 a mining services contract with MMS. Mm. That is complete polar opposite. That is, I'd say, fully heterogeneous. Yeah. 17:35 That is, mate, 'cause holy snapping duck shit they can craft an open, open-pit mining contract agreement in any way that, any way, shape, or form that just gets dirt moving. 17:47 You know what is homogenous in MMS contracts, Matty? What's that, mate? The bloody quality. Yeah. Top-tier quality- Yeah... every contract they do. Yeah. 17:56 So it's, it is, it's probably the only thing in the world that is both homogenous and heterogeneous at the same time. It's that weird spot in the Venn diagram, isn't it? Yeah. Yeah. 18:04 And that, but that's, you have the ability to be like that when you're a turnkey solution- Absolutely... for mining services. So, mate, 'cause I'll tell you where, where this has gone in WA. 18:13 If you pretty much, in the future, you will see any piece of broken rock being dug up, being hauled, being trucked to a bloody mill-You're gonna know that MMS have done it. 18:24 They are taking the industry by the balls and get in quick. Mineral Mining Services to move your open pit dirt and help you bloody finance your operation to get going. That's it. Details in the show notes. Go MMS. 18:36 I didn't actually know they were that good till I said it like that. One phone call. Gee, one phone call. One phone call. Right, back to it. 18:41 Bentley, to sort of wrap up on copper, I'd be interested to hear what, what are the features you think we're gonna see and hear a lot about in the next few years talking about, you know, from a smelting and refining perspective, a, a production perspective, and a kind of markets perspective. 18:57 What are the sort of stories perhaps that might be, you know, more short squeezes or more disparities between markets, or more smelters and treatment charges coming down? 19:05 What are the features you think s- are gonna stand out? Yeah, that's a good question. I would, I would expect TC rates to, to... 19:13 They've recovered to low teens, um, 20-ish range, maybe hang out around there, 20s, 30s-ish. Uh, I mean, you'll still see fluctuations. I mean, it's not gonna be a flat line, but, uh... 19:24 And there, there's a still a lot of refining and smelting capacity coming online in China, and the, the, a lot of metals are this way where refining and smelting is not really a, a constraint in these markets. 19:36 It's pretty quick to be, these things fired up. I believe Tongling has like a 2 million ton per year smelter they're still getting fired up, and it's, it's bloody massive, right? Like, it's huge. So 19:49 from that perspective, you might see, you know, you, you wanna stockpile material before you get it fired up. So y- you might see another similar situation to this. Um, that, that will be in the headlines. I think 20:04 there's some solid mining capacity coming online. Um, so we didn't have... We had '24 that was fairly balanced/small surplus. Early '25, pretty similar. 20:15 Um, uh, you're starting to like bet on macro at that point, so push around whatever it is. Um, but after that, by late '25, a lot of big projects. 20:25 But essentially once OE Tolgoi really gets full ramped up and stuff like that, y- you're, y- now you're gonna be starting to get actually constrained by, by, um, concentrate and stuff. 20:36 So w- more later half '25, '26, um, but, you know, that's freaking bite my... I get things wrong all the time, so there's, you know. [laughs] So do we, mate. [laughs] Should we move to aluminum, guys? 20:50 I think this is a, a super interesting one to talk about, and we probably know a lot less than we should given there's, you know, quite a bit of bauxite mining and alumina refineries here in our own state in WA. 21:03 But I'd, I'd love to hear your outlook. There's quite a of, um, varying opinions out there from sort of bulls to people not so bullish about where aluminum goes down the track. 21:14 So kinda to start with, can you give us a lay of the land of how you see the, the broader aluminum market and obviously alumina and, and bauxite kinda play into that? Yeah. Um, ali- ali's a super interesting metal. 21:26 So it, it's, it's got a hell of a history whereas it... 21:31 I, I can't think of anything else, any other metal that went through this in, I don't, it's not really modern, but let's just call it, uh, post-Industrial Revolution times where, uh, when, when France held the World Fair in 1860s, 1850s, um, 21:49 Napoleon actually put on display, um, a bunch of like aluminum utensils, and if you were lucky enough there, big enough, ding-a-ling a tree, you got to use, you know, aluminum utensils. 22:01 And to put it in perspective back then, oh man, what was the equivalent price? It was, it was something to the tune of nominally like one, $1 to $2 million per ton. And within a matter of a couple years, the, 22:16 God, I pronounce it wrong all the time, but the [laughs] the modern day aluminum smelting process came, came, came to fruition, and only took literally a couple years. 22:25 Act- two guys actually figured out pretty m- similar processes with Har- Harold and Herlow. 22:29 Um, I'm not, not a mets- or an engineer, so I won't g- too much into that, but basically, you know, with a matter of a couple years all of a sudden now it's, you know, 22:37 100 bucks a ton, $50 a ton or whatever it would've been back, back in those days and, you know, today it is $2,300 a ton, right? So it, that, that, that aspect of it's pretty fascinating. Um, and then 22:49 it, it go, it goes through its cycles like every other commodity, where sometimes it finds new reasons and new ways, n- new uses and, you know, you had post-World War II where you had ton heaps of the shit left over, especially in, in the UK. 23:01 So that's why in the UK a lot of the Jags and, and, uh, even original Range Rovers or Land Rovers, I believe, were actually built on, with ali 'cause it's like a hundred left over ali, right? 23:11 Whereas other places in the world there's, no one had it. 23:13 So, um, kinda fast-forward, the bull thesis a lot of people do have is in the EV sector because it is such a m- lighter material than, um, a, you know, steel, and considering how heavy these batteries are- Mm... 23:29 you gotta get the weight of the vehicle down, and that helps rolling resistance, which helps, you know, mileage and, and range and that sort of thing. So there's a lot of benefactors to it. Look pretty easy to press. 23:38 Um, you, the alloys are what, where a lot of the technology you'll see come from, so it does get tough where you'll see these numbers of like, all right, we're going from, you know, um, 100 kilograms per car or whatever, 150 kilograms per car. 23:54 Well, you know, you know, all the way up to like 300, what, maybe even... 23:57 Yeah, I think it's like 250, 300 kilograms per, per automobile now of ali in the future and it's like, well, okay, there's gonna be some sort of, um, adaptation with alloys. 24:08 Now, with that, with that said, you know, it's used in solar as well. Um, k- I had the... I can't remember the exact now. It's like a gigawatt hour is, is something like, you know, 17,000 tons. 24:19 I'll, I'll double check that one and get back to you guys in a little bit on that. But, uh, so it's really big in that aspect. 24:25 You gotta, th- they tend to not use a ton of it in wind, even though you'd think those massive turbines and-I think it's, uh, has to do with tensile strength. But, 24:35 um, so the green energy space is where a lot of it comes from, and transmission lines. So when you have power lines underground, you tend not to use aluminum. Um, you're more space constrained, right? So on a per, 24:51 on a weight basis, ali is actually more, um, uh, more... What's the word I'm looking for? Uh, [chuckles] a better conductor of electricity than copper is on a, on a per weight basis. It just takes up more space. Yeah. 25:03 [clears throat] So the other benefit of that when you're hanging big transmission lines is you can actually space out your towers further apart because they weigh less. 25:11 So that then saves on that cost as well, and that's where we're seeing a lot of demand increases for it, especially as, you know, new energy requires new power grids, essentially. 25:21 And you're transferring electricity from further distances, so you need more of the shit. So that's where a lot of the bull case comes from, the demand from it, that kind of the new energy space is... 25:32 And, and, you know, not, in all honesty, I, I agree with that. It's how much of it's gonna come from recycled sources, which someone like Harbor Aluminium, that guy is hell-bent on, you know, recycled's gonna take over. 25:44 But, you know, you can only... Recycle can only replace what's already been produced. You can't really grow, right? And then now you have the supply strain- capacity strains of 25:56 China, which is the largest producer of aluminum in the world, at about... Their, their capacity is basically 45 million tons, and that's actually government set, and it's a 71 million ton a year market. 26:05 So we're bumping up against that right now, and it's a highly... Uses a lot of electricity, and that's where I think a lot of these bull narratives come from, research houses or sell side. 26:18 Um, you know, us included, I can see that as well. But I, I, it, it... Price determines things a lot of times. So the higher something gets in price, the more likely we are, we are to find a substitute. 26:30 But as of right now at current prices, I, I, I see, I see that story. I believe it. Um, it looks like you wanna, uh- Mm... talk, Geoff. [laughs] Oh, sorry. [laughs] I was just, I was just taking it all in, to be honest. 26:43 But, um, yeah, like, one of the comments that was made to us recently was the entire complex is a lot more f- like fragile as well. Um, yeah, there's been some- Yeah. Yeah... 26:53 kind of like, you know, down the, the entire complex, some, some, um, s- you know, supply curtailments here and there. Some in, in West Australia themselves with, with Kwinana. 27:03 Um, you've got issues in, in Queensland with, with, with Gladstone. 27:06 Um, and then, uh, you're, you're looking into, into China and there's been, you know, even, even some, some depletion over there, and they're, they're, they're going to Guinea for the bauxite. Do, do you... 27:18 Would you agree with that sentiment that the entire kind of complex is fragile, and, and, and heck, if you had some sort of disruption, it might have a much larger impact on the price than it would've had in, in prior years? 27:29 Uh, c- certainly. I think, um, I actually had to look up the [chuckles] bauxite price chart recently because I, I hadn't, I hadn't looked at it in a while, and I didn't realize where it was at. It was $70, $75 a ton. 27:38 So I was pretty impressed on that. But it, it does have to do with... 27:43 So you had Indonesia, I think you guys mentioned the other day, where they, they, they put in similar constraints as they have in, you know, all their other industries, just value add, right? 27:50 So they, they no longer can export bauxite into China. And one of the problems with that actually is, is, um, just the, the metallurgy and the chemistry in- involved in, in alu- alumina refinery is, um... 28:03 So yeah, for anybody who doesn't know, about two tons of bauxite goes into one ton of alumina and about 1.9 tons of lu- met grade alumina goes into one ton of aluminum. Ooh, that's a good one to know. So, yeah. 28:16 It's essentially 41- I'll be, I'll be quoting that flat out like, mate, like it's my own idea after this. [laughs] Okay. That's good to know. And then don't get... 28:24 I, you know, as a commodity trader, we've had it come up before where somebody's, um, trying to been, um, pushing us, um, like white fused alumina, which is a completely different thing. It's actually a lot higher value. 28:36 But the, there is a, there is a different use between alumina for metallurgy than, as there, than there is for, um, like refractory stuff. So you gotta be a little careful there as well. 28:46 But most of what you would read about or talk about would be the, the met grade alumina, and that's like that FOB Aussie price, that's met grade. Um, yeah, so yeah, look, pretty dependent on, on, on, uh, Guinea. Um, 29:00 that's been one of the transformations as well is accepting Australian bauxite, and now that you have these issues with the natural gas pipelines in Kwinana. 29:07 I think there's a Kwinana refinery as well that, that's, uh, struggling- Yeah. Yeah... there, right? Um, that, you know, price has spiked 500 plus. 29:15 Um, so about a 30% of your cost as an aluminum smelter is your alumina input, so it matters. We saw prices in China spike. Um, we've seen them not only have imports increase, but also exports. 29:29 Uh, I think I mentioned that the other day, where the other... So one of the, one of the Aussie, I think the, the one with the Rio, so the Rio alumina, alumina refinery down there was a JV with Rusal. 29:43 And in April or March of '22, the Australian government was like, "Nope, no more," right? So, uh, Rusal then had to, uh, find other means to get their alumina. And so now they get it from China. 29:55 So China actually exports as well as needing to import, so it's kind of an interesting dynamic there. And, and, you know, Russia is an important... That's, 30:05 what, six, seven percent of global aluminum production comes from Russia. So it's, it's pretty significant. You, Bentley, you spoke about substitution and price obviously driving that before. 30:16 And I remember reading a, a Bloomberg article maybe a month or so ago talking about the, the biggest copper buyer in the world, the China, I think it's called- Mm... State Grid Corp- Yep... 30:27 um, started to really, uh, rotate their copper buying and, you know, put their copper buying kind of on, on hold and started buying a lot of ali as a, as a substitute, as copper-... 30:37 kicked up to whatever it got to, over $11,000 a ton. How does that kind of play into your thinking, you know, in, in terms of copper and where that, that price goes and ali- ali's demand in the future? 30:51 Ah, lo- long term I don't think that's a... I think that's just, they do very seasonal purchases, um, 30:58 tend not to be hanging new UHV lines here in the middle of the summertime out there, whether it be from, depending on geography, either monsoon season or just, I don't know, freaking hot. So 31:09 they will, um, load up purchases for the fall. And, uh, and, and excuse me, I know the ref- the article you're referencing as well, but that- that's, um, very much just 31:19 getting their inputs in line and being like, "Okay, well, we're gonna, we'll, we'll do our ali input purchases here because of where prices are, but we'll, gonna hold off on copper" sort of thing. It's not a really... 31:30 The, the use cases for both of those where th- where they're used in electricity transmission is, is different. It's not as replaceable as it seems. Um, [laughs] 31:41 construction here in the '50s and '60s tried to make it replaceable [laughs] and you ended up in a lot of building fires. So 31:48 a- at the transformer and those sorts of points of contact, you, you need, you, you want copper, you don't want aluminum. 31:54 Um, so a lot of times, you know, you have the big transmission lines, that will be ali, and then when they're, get to the transformer state, they end up using copper. Um, so that- that's one aspect to that. 32:06 I did read about some auto manufacturer trying to use ali to lighten the weight in their car. I don't see how that would work. 32:11 That takes up more space and that, especially with the battery EV, you don't, the last thing you want in one of those things is a fire, so I'm n- not sold on that part of it yet either. 32:20 But, um, you know, hey, if prices ever get too out of control, I guess you just use silver, but that's [laughs] we're a long ass way from that. [laughs] It might be a while down the track. Yeah. 32:30 It's funny drawing, um, like parallels to, like, aluminum for, like, in terms of conductivity in relation to it being cheaper and better, but just, it just takes up more space. Mm. 32:43 It's actually a metaphor for Get Wet bladders, I think. It is. Yeah. You- Yeah... you're dead right. So- Exactly the same... 32:49 you know, Bentley was talking about these massive breakthroughs that, you know, society, the world had with the Bayer process and the, the Halls-Héroult process where aluminum just got that much cheaper, and I think of Get Wet pretty similar, Matty. 33:01 Mm. The breakthrough the world has had with these bladders is second to none. They've just changed the way mining is done. They've changed the way you can manage water at your mine sites. Well, they- Look no further... 33:12 you got, and you haven't got the constraints of a, like an EV where you got space restrictions. Like aluminum sounds like it would be the better option, but there's a space restriction. Mm. 33:21 Get Wet bladders, they're in the desert, mate. Yeah. That's as much bloody, just clear, just bloody flatten out a massive patch, chuck a Get Wet bladder in, avoid the concrete foundations required for a hard-sided tank. 33:33 And mate, you can store water, you can get rid of water into it, you can get water from A to B. Mate, they do the piping, they do the infrastructure set up to go in, out, and anywhere from a Get Wet bladder. 33:45 And that's it. You can, you can roll it up and move it when you wanna- Oh... you know, you get to that point in time. You haven't even mentioned the guarantee, Matty. Oh, mate, I- These things last forever. 33:53 Oh, th- and I think, oh, [laughs] I think, what, they got a 10-year warranty, but they last for easily 20 years and probably 30. So the 10-year warranty's just, you're just- Yeah... getting that. 34:03 You're pretty much getting half price effectively. Like what a generous offer. So mate, Get Wet bladders just save the, save the mining industry by saving your water. Give Matty Hall a call. Good on ya, Matty Hall. 34:17 Get Wet. Metal that's close to my heart, mate, tin. [laughs] Um, you've had some, some involvement with this, uh, this, this, you know, me- metal over time. Uh, where, where, where, where are you at? 34:29 Are th- are you holding some now? Look at that. Oh. We got a baron here. [laughs] Yo, I, uh, I don't know. I just, I don't even know why. It was a random gift. But I remember 34:43 brother-in-law was asking, "What, wh- what do you want for, as a gift for Christmas?" I'm like, "I don't care," right? Um, it's not, not really my thing. 34:48 I'm kind of the Grinch a little bit, but I was just like, "Ah, it'd be kind of cool. I, tin or whatever." And he's like, "That was the weirdest Christmas gift I've ever bought was somebody, a tin ingot." And just died. 34:56 [laughs] So that's unique I guess. But yeah, it's, uh... Look, I am not, uh, a baron. I, I don't, I'm not too familiar with those guys. I know you guys have brought 'em up before, but what, what are they? 35:08 Like, just like Cornwall old family? Like who... [laughs] The king, the King of Tin is. I think he's from, well he's- Oh, okay. [laughs]... he's got an English accent- Oh, yeah. He is... 35:17 so I'm just saying he's from Cornwall. Yeah. He probably isn't. The, the Barons are a Twitter community, that's for sure. Don't know where they're from. [laughs] Probably, probably all over the place. 35:24 Um, but yeah, y- so you're, you're not a, you're not a baron, um, of course. You're a trader, you're a mercenary. 35:30 But wh- where, where, what, what's, like, you know, you've, you've, you obviously still be following the supply demand dynamics there. 35:35 I think it's, it's in the, like it's 30 odd thousand US a ton now, so it's come off- Yeah... quite, quite a way from 35, like just a couple months ago. Um, how are you watching that market? 35:45 I mean, at one point it had kind of similar dynamics with the, with the smelting constraints and everything to copper too. Ooh, yeah. Uh, pretty closely actually. So we're involved a little bit in both sides. 35:57 It's been, you know, when people used to ask me as a fund manager a few years back, you know, "Okay, what's the, what's the, what's your favorite metal for the energy transition?" I always said tin. 36:06 Always did, and I still believe in it actually. Uh, it, part of it was to be a little more contrarian to being like, "Oh, copper," but you know, look, copper is... 36:14 That, that is as well, but you know, tin's got that constraint of, it's not really mined as a byproduct of anything. It is a lot of ASM, um, and the technology to get... 36:28 One of the things that's held demand somewhat constant, I guess for the past, 36:33 oh, I don't know, 10 or 15 years, um, fairly constant and, and, and, uh, relative to other com- other metals is you had-Kind of the miniaturization, right? 36:44 You had Moore's Law, and you also had just the, the, like, okay, how do we use as little bit of tin as possible? 'Cause it's the, you know, the glue in electronics essentially. 36:51 And you also, you know, like, tinnies are not really a thing anymore other than a term. It's a lot of aluminum, let's replace that. But that's been going on decades ago really realistically. Um, and then now solar too. 37:03 So, um, tin paste is used in solar. It's pretty significant use there as well. But, uh, yeah, I've always thought of it that way. And you got... 37:11 So you got the far upstream constraints of, um, the Wa State, which came out of nowhere essentially when, almost a decade ago now, or eight years ago. And then 37:22 one thing I will point out about the Wa State is you gotta bear in mind that part of Myanmar is native Chinese speaking. So they actually, kids there go to school in Chinese. 37:30 They all speak Chinese, and they, that's, they do have really close relationships with Yunnan as it is a, they share a border. 37:36 Uh, well, for part of it, it's actually like, it's like one, it's like a cutout part that's not part of the Wa State. But, um, not to be mixed up with WA, Western Australia. That'd be- [laughs]... 37:46 unless you guys have military leadership as well, I don't, I'm not aware of. Uh, so we, we haven't seen... 37:55 So they, they had stockpiles of that, that flowed through the border that kind of kept, you know, tin and stuff alive. Um, yeah, Metal X also, Tasmania, them, them increasing production nicely has helped them as well. 38:05 But, uh, w- we just saw... It was interesting because, you know, electronics demand hasn't been great. You know, chip demand hasn't been... 38:15 The last quarter or so, it's really picked up, but the numbers we look at, it's basically picked up to get back to 2021, 2022 levels- There we go... rather than new highs. Yeah. 38:25 So a lot of inventory did show up in China and in LME over the past, let's call it nine months. And, 38:33 uh, so you did, you, you saw a little bit of a similar kind of, I don't wanna call it a squeeze in, in LME tin prices, but it was partially spec driven that, like, the metal's there and it wasn't really in short supply at that time. 38:49 Uh, the Chinese didn't, just didn't wanna get rid of it. Uh, they didn't, they weren't gonna... They were holding for their own, uh, downstream. We started to get some inquiries for concentrate a couple months ago. 39:03 Um, actually just got a message over the weekend that, um, now they're, they're really starting to look for it, so we, we think smelters maybe, maybe some of that Myanmar stuff has run out and, um, 39:17 yeah, that would be my little inside scoop to you guys [laughs] on, and, and the listeners on that one, is that we, we started to get questions, "Hey, do you, uh, do you guys have anything?" Um, 39:27 and, uh, it, it is a hard one for traders to find, um, and if you're not involved in it, just because, you know, you're l- you're talking about either really small producers or [laughs] producers that fail due diligence. 39:39 [laughs] We had that one in the past month as well. Pretty bad. [laughs] Really? 39:44 To any, uh, [laughs] aspiring miner out there, when a trader sends you a due diligence form, a lot of times they, there's like, these things are fairly standard. 39:53 We customize ours, but it, you know, there's like an OEC framework for it, right? Mm. And we ask for the location of the mine, and you put confidential in all caps, like, that's the worst answer we could possibly have. 40:02 [laughs] [laughs] Somewhere that we're not allowed to get it from. Uh... Yeah, yeah. We're talking about s- somebody in Colombia, not Ajico. I'll say that 'cause I know... Well, they're not public anymore. 40:13 But it, it wasn't them. But, uh, [laughs] it w- and, yeah, in Colombia, which is a, it's a not, it's a jurisdiction that doesn't traditionally mine tin, by the way. Um, the geology is there. 40:22 It's, you know, Ajico's funny. I don't know if you guys are familiar with them. But, um, they found out as well, and that their deposit is on the river that borders Venezuela, so, you know. 40:32 If you put confidential and you're telling me it's coming from Colombia, but- [laughs]... I know geology a little bit enough to know that that may not be coming from Colombia, then yeah, that's, yeah. Anyway. 40:43 [laughs] There's a lot, there's a lot of confidential things that have come out of Colombia historically. [laughs] That too. That too. [laughs] Uh, yeah. Anyway, so, uh, we didn't buy that material. Um, but- [laughs] 40:59 You weren't part of the cocoa bean squeeze? Yeah. No, look, if you, if, if so, just send it over to me. [laughs] You know, if you come across it. 41:06 Bent- Bentley, I'm keen to, uh, pick your brain because you're at that crossro- crossroads of, you know, hedge fund, commodity trader, and we were hearing a lot, it was probably just coming through the, the kind of Twitter echo chamber that, oh, these big, these big funds are getting interested in tin at this l- you know, at, at the sort of levels. 41:22 That was a couple months back now, and who knows? 41:25 Maybe that could be one or two people in a pod at, you know, a, a citadel or whatever, and then you can, you know, kind of slap their name on it and make it sound like these big, these big money managers are interested. 41:37 But did you get any sort of whispers that, you know, financial players with a bit of backing behind them would actually be interested in tin given the, the, the size of the tin market ultimately? Hmm. 41:48 Yeah, that's a great question, actually. So it, uh, I won't, I won't speak to Citadel. There's too many people in this building that- Get the bang from Chicago. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. 42:00 There's, a lot of them are still located here, even though they've, they've moved to Miami. Um, but actually, o- one thing I will say is 42:09 we've been involved in the LME for years now, and the great thing about the LME is... 42:14 Well, there's a lot of good things about it, but, uh, I guess the unique thing, I shouldn't say great, but the unique thing is there's still some of it that's, you know, done by phone. 42:21 It's actually done by chat, is what it is, not phone. But, um, you can still do it by phone if you want, but it's done by chat. 42:26 And, uh, you know, you speak to the guys some mornings and they were like, "No, you're actually one of two US customers we have." There's only s- At that time there was only... 42:36 No, there's still only eight ring members, and most of them are still, they're either China or Europe or London. But I was like, "Wow, really?" And in terms of, like, a fund, not in terms of hedgers. 42:46 But I was like, "Oh, that's interesting." And, um-He mentioned the other couple ones that are there. 42:50 So there's actually just not a lot of interest in, from fundies using metals th-that are on the LME, and I know that the nickel market stuff happened, and so they, they pop on and off pretty easily. 43:00 They have big, uh, operations teams, so it's not hard for them to get access and then fade away and not use it anymore and that sort of thing. But I had heard of... I heard some murmurs. I didn't hear anything huge. 43:13 I remember there was a guy back 10 years ago or so in London, even longer than that now. He tried to squeeze the tin markets and, um, which... Uh, a good, a good squeeze is always, it always cracks me up, right? 43:27 So when, when has it ever worked, right? Well, it works a lot, except for it doesn't. You know, it's like we asked the Hunt brothers. It... You, you, you squeeze the market and then you gotta sell it. You, you... 43:38 There's no... Unrealized gains don't matter, man. Like, [laughs] realized gains are what matters. So, um, that happened to that guy as well. This go around, I mean, that wasn't really a squeeze, but it, it... 43:51 Yeah, I, I think there's, there's definitely fund money getting involved 'cause you can see that there are open, um, positions for certain dates that are, are larger than what was realistically able to be delivered. And 44:05 look, the, the best way to, to try to call those p- I'm not trying to call them out, but the best way for traders to try to call them out would just, like, you know, squee-squeeze them on the roll. So, um, 44:21 that's where you can see depending on... A lot of them aren't that... Most, most fundies get bothered. And th-th... I got told a long time ago, I guess, by our brokers, they'd be like, "Yeah, I'll let you do... 44:32 " It's called the tom next. "But, uh, let you hold till then if you want, but if you're not taking delivery, then I r- don't recommend it. It always ends in tears," and it's because, you know, the whole... It is... 44:42 There's only eight ring members, right? So if there is... When you read about it being a financial firm, it probably is. The ring members know. So [laughs] that's what I'll say about that, and they will... 44:52 Eh, if their broker's nice, they'll be like, "Do not let it get to this expo or else you will get squeezed," and, and it, it happens. You'll, you'll see, um- So what's a ring member? Just watch the tom next bit. 45:03 So it's a unique... So you can only... Trading has to be done either through a second tier or directly through a ring member on the LME. Um, they're, you know, what you think of in the pictures, right? Mm-hmm. 45:14 Um, but they... And, like, electronically there's only eight members, and that's the members you go through and the... and they have their own clearing now as well. Uh, that was the problem from the '86. 45:24 You know, going back to tin. That, that was the tin crisis of '86. It was kind of wild to think that 1986. What... 45:29 It wasn't that they didn't have their own clearing house, it's that they had no clearing, so that we're all relying on each other to... You know, it was like an NDF sort of thing in the currency markets, which is 45:39 kind of my background. But, um, well, you're, you're basically, you're relying on the others not to go bust, and that's what happened in '86 when the ITA can... Nope, well, not... Sorry. 45:47 [laughs] Ooh, don't wanna call those guys out. [laughs] I like the ITA guys. It's [laughs] it's what was before the ITA. Yeah. Sorry. 45:54 Um, yeah, they were trying to prop up prices and then you had, you know, Brazilians basically and other countries that weren't members producing up the ass and undercutting them and they could no longer prop up prices, and then all of a sudden 46:06 people are getting... Going bust left and right. And that's what Mark Thompson- But it comes clearing-... speaks about in the, in the sort of creation of the clearing houses behind the LME- Mm-hmm... 46:14 is that they just walked away- Yeah... with huge amounts of, of debts, right? Yeah, massive. 46:21 I don't remember, um, who eventually paid for all that, but it, it, it was pretty large and that, you know, it's what happened in nickel. Like, everybody... So the LME went to... 46:34 They used the London Clearing House for a while, um, and now it's done their own thing. They have their own internal. And it's, uh, without going on too much of a tangent, it is a bit to 46:49 watch out for, especially in, in all these, these metals when we talk about squeeze. A lot of the times it might actually be you are effectively margin calling a producer that's trying to hedge. 46:58 And there are ways around that, uh, if you're a producer or a trader that's trying to hedge short. Um, depending on, you know, the markets, you, you can make it so you don't get margin called. But, um, 47:13 look, instead of a margin call, you have to buy them back, right? It doesn't make a lot of sense 'cause you're a producer. 47:17 You're like, "Well, I can deliver in, you know, six to nine months or whatever, 'cause that's when I have it hedged out." 47:22 Uh, and that's a lot of times what you actually end up seeing is that those players, um, you know, the producers are having to actually buy those hedges back. 47:29 And what happened in nickel was it's like, well, he couldn't even actually deliver because it's a lot of MPI product. And, um, look, things on... Tsingshan did just fine. Um, that's why I think that story is 47:43 really overblown, uh, and actually misleading in my opinion. I know, like, the media loves a good story, right? Uh, but, you know, like, the guy produces 600,000 tons a year, and they... 47:55 He w- rumors were he was short anywhere between 180 and 300,000 tons. So it's like, oh, okay, he did just fine. Prices got squeezed up. Guess what? He m- it's a private company, he's not at profits, but 48:05 looking at all the expansion they've done and Bataru and all that stuff that's up around now, like, I think he did just fine. Um, the real problem was is you had... There's only eight members, right? 48:16 So that clearing pool, if you had prices go from 20,000 to, you know, at one point in the night it was over 100,000. Mm. Tho-those, those little members, they couldn't... I don't wanna call them little. 48:28 Some of them, most of them are public companies and fairly big, but some of them are smaller. That's a hell of a margin call you have to come up with if you haven't, you know, if, if you're on the short side of things. 48:37 And that was actually what the fear was, is w-was, it's the sy-sy-systemic risk from, um, one of the, you know, I've heard about two to three members were in serious trouble during the LME squeeze. It wasn't... 48:52 It wa- and look, JP Morgan had most of-Sing Shan's short. I don't think JP Morgan was in trouble. [laughs] They're just, they can cover. Um, 49:04 that's the unique aspect of the LME, and that's the u- the, that's where squeeze is real- really, I guess, evolved from is you have all of that activity that happens behind the scene. That's where volume comes from too. 49:16 Th- there's, um, there's one commodity which you might have a bit of insight into, you know, far, far, f- far deeper than, um, the usual person we talk to because you just spent a month in China, um, and, you know, visiting some of the- Mm... 49:30 the, the, the lithium refineries out that way. What, what, what was your takeaway kind of, you know, through M- May and June of this year kind of visiting some of those, um, facilities? 49:41 What, what is actually going on over there? It- You've, you've seen it with your own eyes... 49:48 uh, you know, I've, it, it's a big country and they produce a shitload of lithium upstream and downstream, so I won't have the full answer, but I can talk ab- a little bit about what, I guess, my experience was out there. 49:58 You know, we, uh, the, from our trading business, we went out there. We've been s- well, when we decided to launch trading business, a lot of it was in, for lithium purposes. And 50:08 so, uh, I spoke with, um, a lot of the bigger players and got to, was fortunate enough to visit a few of them as well. Um, and one of the interesting aspects I didn't quite fully realize going in was the, 50:24 a lot of the midstream and a little bit further downstream, so it's, uh, 50:29 interesting that you can create, you know, a lithium carbonate that's not necessarily battery grade or, you know, lithium hydroxide that you should be producing that's battery grade, but some of it does go into ceramics. 50:40 Um, the battery grade stuff, that's a very much, that is specialty stuff. And even the, the non-battery grade, it, it, it's just not really commoditized. It's very difficult. 50:52 And these, these, um, I guess refineries that got built and that, that, that are able to handle a- and produce the... It's not necessarily the highest grade, by the way. 51:04 It has to do with like impurities and stuff, um, for what these, you know, the cattles of the world and stuff want, BYD and Eve and all the battery makers. 51:13 Uh, yeah, and even Japanese and Koreans as well are big in the battery space too, is they, they've set it up a- as, as spodumene as one of their main inputs, and I, a, a lot of it is economics too. So if you are, 51:30 you know, for, for example, one, one of our clients, they will, they effectively are looking for 300 plus thousand tons of spodumene per year and about 5,000 tons of lithium carbonate. They can probably mix it, match 51:48 a little bit more different but, you know, if you use, what, seven, 7.54 divided by 330,000. I don't know why I just gave myself, that's a terrible number. 51:56 You have thir- 30, 35,000 tons of lithium carbonate equivalent right there. Did I do that math right? I think it's about 40. I think it's something like that. Okay. There, yeah. [laughs] Go 40. 52:07 [laughs] 40 on the dot it is. Is Matt, is Matty like secretly a, like a math whiz over there? Don't you worry about me, mate. [laughs] Genius. I ca- I cooked me brain at uni. I was smart as fuck in ye- in year 12. 52:17 [laughs] Too ma- too much fun in King's Cross. [laughs] Oh, well, the, you know, yeah, hey, that's j- that's just college or uni. [laughs] American accent, I apologize. But, uh- [laughs] 52:35 I've been working on it, but schedule is really hard. Uh, that's the proper way to say it, but- [laughs]... we don't, we also sched- schedule over here. Schedule. [laughs] Um, anyway, yeah, so they, they're, uh, 52:49 they can extract more value out of, out of spodumene. 52:53 And spodumene tends to be a little bit easier to actually handle impurities like, uh, less chloride or boron and that sort of thing in the end product that comes through their refineries. So, uh, one of the... 53:07 And I was speaking with some, uh, Europeans that's up in the space as well after, and they kind of like, uh, sideways face like, "Really?" And I was like, "Yeah, it's really interesting." 53:15 Like, look, spodumene demand is healthy. They want spod. Um, and I saw some [laughs] wild stuff, but, um, 53:27 the, the lepidolite is still gonna keep coming from the integrated guys just because what they can effectively do for them is it's not about making money on the lepidolite mine, right? Or lepidolite, sorry. 53:37 It's, it's about being able to sell that end product and if you can, you make up for it by your bigger margin when you're refining to a hydroxide or carbonate. And some of it's pretty extreme. 53:50 Um, I was at a facility where they actually import ore from Africa, and then they had a huge spodumene concentrator there in the middle of China. I was like, "Holy shit, you are [laughs] 54:04 you're not, there's no concentration, nothing happened in Africa. You literally just boom, ore on a ship all the way here as it," but- Oh, right... it's an integrated facility. Damn, sorry. It's, it's pretty wild, yeah. 54:13 [laughs] Yeah. Yeah. Can you probably like, is there a, you, you alluded to it then, and that's the biggest, most opaque thing, is the, 54:21 the cost of production verse le- of lepidolite in China verse the actual benefit and purpose of it for the vertical integration. And you're sort of saying that the cost of production is irrelevant in a way because 54:38 of the vertical integration, and they just want the end product for China, and China just don't care. Yeah. Correct. 54:45 So when you had the, um, inspections go down, it was like beginning of this year, late last year in Sichuan, um, 54:51 the guys that were really failing the inspections and stuff, that, you know, that wasn't the Tianqis of the world, GanFengs of the world, anybody like that, right? 54:59 That was-Independent mines and they're just like, "Well, okay, now we have to actually adhere to these tailings rules," and that makes it so it's not profitable, so they, they basically shut down. 55:10 Um, the ones that are integrated, okay, they can adapt their tailing policy even though it's, you know, still a shitload of tailings. 55:17 But they adapt those policies and stuff and as, yeah, as you put it, exactly, right on that. It's, it's just that they, they make it up further downstream the chain because they're vertically integrated- But then-... 55:27 um, which isn't- How, how-... always the best strategy. Yeah. So and how many, what, or someone's told me before, what is the percentage of the lepidolite mines that are vertically integrated versus ones that aren't? 55:40 Uh, I, I don't have an exact number, but I would have to say at this point it's got to be close to 100 at some point. Like, you, you just, you wouldn't be at this price, you're not. Mm. 55:49 You gotta have some sort of vertical integration I think. Yeah. Um. Yeah. And so, and the Afri- 'cause the Afri- the lithium coming out of Africa is a bit of a talking point at the moment as a disruption to- Yeah... 56:01 the ones in West Australia, for instance, that are starting to really, it's only the incumbents at the, in the lowest cost, in the Q1 cost quartile that are, uh, probably gonna survive sub a thousand, uh, spodumene prices is, and the talk is that the supply out of Africa is a real worry for a lot of the ones that aren't in that first quartile. 56:25 So do you see that as one of the biggest, not the biggest, but a, a big factor going forward in the global spodumene supply dynamic? Um, y- it, it's, it's certainly a, 56:40 it- it's a factor, but, um, even in China there are plenty of refiners that are like, "Eh, I'll take some African stuff, but I prefer the Australian, the Brazilian," you know, the, the more, the more known stuff. 56:52 Um, we've had one of them tell me, tell me that. I was like, "Oh, that's good," 'cause, uh, African logistics is not my specialty, so- Yeah... kinda saved me some. [laughs] Yeah, well that's it. 57:00 And, and is that based on a what a quality and impurity side of things? The fact that it's already concentrated- I, I think-... when it gets to them instead of DSR out of Africa? Fuck. 57:12 Yeah, I don't, I don't know how much of, um, o- of the o- of the ore stuff is, is... I don't know if I was just, that was a unique aspect that I found or if that was more common than I realized. But- Yeah... 57:23 um, it, I, I, I'm not, I, I asked that question and he said it doesn't matter as much, they can figure out how to use it. 57:31 Um, it was more of just, "Hey, look, logistics are a pain in the ass there," and, you know, our job as a trader is to make sure they get the material. Um, 57:42 and I, I think he was kind of just hinting more at for themselves. He, he was a commercial manager, right? 57:46 So he's a procurement manager and he's like, "Well, I can't really trust my stuff, but if you're gonna purchase it, that's fine." Um, it wasn't necessarily a, a, a quality thing, no. Yeah. 57:55 But- And so how do, how do you view the- Yeah, fair... how do you look at the lithium price going forward? Like, we've, we've seen mania in lithium. It's obviously the opposite of mania now. 58:09 But how, like, if you combine the, that Africa stuff, the 58:14 shitload of lepidolite that China has access to, uh, do you think there's gonna be a bit of a ceiling on lithium but just because there's so many options globally and we won't see a mania again or do you think we might? 58:29 I, no, I've never seen that. I, I can't [laughs]... You know, putting a certainty on anything is nev- never a good idea. But what I will say is- It's a, it's easier when you say it and we don't. Like, the- [laughs]... 58:38 all the accountability's on you then. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. Sure, yeah. For sure. Oh, I'll take that, no problem. [laughs] On my job. [laughs] Uh, no, I, I would never model in, um, 58:54 80,000 carbonate in the foreseeable future, but, like, or 8,000 spod. 59:02 Uh, I, but with that said, I, you know, I, I don't know what, what the cap would be i- in, in terms of the upside just because, you know, things can go way to the upside and be very profitable for, you know, how mines are, right? 59:14 They're not, you don't turn them on next year, talking about multi, multi-year process. Um, in terms of a floor, yeah, I mean, I think we're near it. 59:25 So I think, um, just 'cause of what the production that's needed and everything, even, you know, I don't want to talk too much about DLE just 'cause it's still speculative, but even with that crap, no, sorry, it's not crap, but, mm-hmm. 59:37 [laughs] Even with that stuff. [laughs] Some of it is, by the way. Gotta be careful with what people say in that industry, but that part of the industry, but some of it's- You could say DLE doesn't look exceptional 59:48 at this stage... yeah, I think the an- the anhydrous stuff, so what SunResin does, there's another guy that's picking up on the DLEA. That looks like it's gonna be something, but anyway. 59:56 So at in, in the spod side though, like, not a lot of new c- it's, it's about new capacity moving forward, and it's th- those constraints and, you know, inflation in anything in, in, in the world is... 1:00:09 Look, commodity prices go up. Um, not a common thing that people realize, but if you look over the past, you know, just historically, they tend to go up on a similar to the same appreciation of equities by the way. 1:00:23 It's actually a very similar thing on a price basis, right? So, you know, five and a half, 6% annualized over the past 100 plus years. If you really want to look at a long, long-term thing of it. 1:00:33 So the reason for that a lot of times is just the cost of production and demand, right? So that's risen, right? I mean, you got like, ah, you got Sayona that's out there. They're, 1:00:44 them with Piedmont and stuff, like they have those pricing and it's like, okay, well, they're gonna be struggling right now. 1:00:49 Um, but I think they'll survive, you know, the stuff in Canada is, it's, they got some quality assets out in that, that, that part of Canada, but, um, the Aussies are obviously fine. 1:00:58 Uh, well, the ones that are, you know, I was gonna say, like, what, Pilbara's definitely fine. Uh, Greenbushes is- YepIt's fine. [laughs] It's, it's all right. 1:01:14 Now that they, you get some like, "Well, what, what's your actual, you know, financials on that?" 'Cause they have the 49, you know, joint venture with Albemarle and stuff. 1:01:23 But- There's a bit down on there They'll be fine. [laughs] Yeah, exactly. I, I think the African stuff is gonna run into shipping constraints as well. So it, it, it'll just all catch up. 1:01:36 I think we'll see it especially starting possibly '20, as early as '25. We'll, we're gonna start to see where it's like, all right, we need... 1:01:44 Like I don't, I wanna, I know I hate putting prices as a floor because prices can go underneath the floor for a substantial amount of time and substantially underneath that floor. But look, 1:01:55 800 bucks is tough, US, is tough to get under in spot. Um, w- a lot y- a lot of it does have to do as well with what are the margins? So what is a refiner- refiner's margin? 1:02:10 So what is their cost of conversion and where are the prices of carbonate and hydroxide? And it, those two do play off each other. And, you know, the last I, you know, we've heard from it, like spot demand's decent. 1:02:25 I know prices came off a lot here in the past month or so, but that was also happy to know that [chuckles] downstream guys were not buying at 1,300. They were, they was not, they weren't okay with that at that point. 1:02:35 But they're like, "Hey, if back down towards a thousand, like let's, let's start, start doing some more." So I think, you know, never know near term. 1:02:44 Next couple years, I, it, it, I can't really see it being much underneath 800 for the spot prices on a SE six basis, but that's just... Could change my mind tomorrow, I guess. But- Mm. 1:02:55 [laughs] Yeah, it's fu- it's funny when you talk about Pilbara Minerals, um, as a, you know, ver- obviously very well established and we talk about companies that have talk to the commodity price. 1:03:06 A lot, you know, the goldies might be the s- on the smaller end that have big talk to the gold price, but Pilbara is such a big business, but it has so much talk to the lithium 'cause their cost of produ- they're not making massive margins on what the price is at the moment, but Jesus Christ, it has some talk on a big scale. 1:03:27 Yeah, I, I mean, Pilbara are like, you know, as, as I was telling, I think, uh, last night I was, I was talking to Trav and things came out, it's, that's just good execution. 1:03:37 They've done a good job at, "Hey, this is what we're gonna do." Mm. And they execute on it. And any sort of management like that, you just, you just kind of buy into. And, um, 1:03:48 yeah, they're gonna be impacted by price at the end of the day, but if you're gonna make a, you know, investment in somebody and you trust in their management team, and then 1:04:00 okay, well, I know that if something goes right, at least I believe in this management team, right? Where sometimes price goes up because a big player in the industry really cocked up. 1:04:11 That just doesn't, that doesn't, that's not a trend I see in Pilbara, so I don't think that'd come from them. 1:04:16 But, um, I guess kind of heading back to you guys, what, what are you guys seeing a lot for, you know, the others? I g- mentioned that I've spoken to Tianqi's side of, um, Greenbushes, 1:04:28 so I, I know a little bit about what's going on down there and, you know, obviously with Pilbara, but what about kind of the other, other, other players in the space or- The one to watch is Minres- Oh... I think. Um. Oh. 1:04:38 I don't imagine that they are making money on all of their mines like they say they, they are. I, yeah, I, I'd find it pretty hard to believe. 1:04:47 How's their, uh, how's their automated, automated, um, what, truck, what do they call them? What's the- Train, ship, off the road... the truck? Oh, the, the trucks. That's for, for the iron ore? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. 1:04:57 Yeah, yeah. Alba. [laughs] Well, we'll see. Alba's always fast. We'll see. It's, it's crunch time. But it, it is super interesting looking around, right? Because in, in WA alone, 1:05:05 you've got, uh, Liontown meant to come online, Kathleen Valley, Mount Holland stuck inside of Wesfarmers in a JV with SQM. They're meant to be r- ramping at the moment. We don't, we don't hear much about them 'cause it's 1:05:19 y- you know, immaterial to Wesfarmers, they don't really disclose shitloads about it. Yeah. Um. Pilgangoora is getting, getting bigger. Minres wanna expand production. 1:05:28 Greenbushes dialed back, but they wanna dial back, back up in, in the future. 1:05:32 So despite the price being so, you know, heading in the wrong direction, everyone's still talking about expanding, which is a bit counterintuitive. Yeah. 1:05:40 Min- Minres is the interesting one, especially with Mount Marion, how they, um, it, I think it's, it's what Ganfeng will want to do there, be like, you know, a 50/50 JV. 1:05:50 So, but Minres could be losing money on the, the lithium operation, but they're making a lot, they make a lot of money back from the mining services they provide to Ganfeng. 1:06:01 So Ganfeng might be losing money, but Minres might be breaking even or making money. So there's that whole dynamic that makes it very interesting. So it goes beyond the actual operation itself. 1:06:13 Then Ganfeng could be making money downstream. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. So, um- Yeah. Yeah. 1:06:20 I think, I think between, as you said, you got, you got Greenbushes, you got Pilgangoora, then you probably, then Wodgina in terms of where everything's sitting in the, uh, on the cost curve. 1:06:30 Then, you know, Mount Marion's beyond that 'cause their spodumene concentrate's a lot lower grade. Don't, don't forget Mount Catlin too. Mount, Mount Catlin. Yeah, well, they're- Mm... 1:06:39 they'd have to be under a lot of bloody stress. Yeah. It's prob- probably quite marginal at the moment. Mm. Yeah. Mm. Yeah. So- Interesting. 1:06:47 But then, then you got all the, then you add all the lithium mania, like the, all the other hopefuls that were, you know, looking to get going, like, you know, Develop bought, did the scheme, um, 1:06:59 scheme deal with Essential to buy Pioneer Dome, but it's like a, you know, a narrow, like a narrow vein underground lithium mine. 1:07:06 So you'd think that's probably really on the back burner of [laughs] lithium mines that could come online. I'm not, I'm not sure where... 1:07:12 And, a- and again, that's, it's how you weigh that up, that mine up against-What's the arrangement with sending it up to Mount Marion or Bald Hill to get processed by MinRes? 1:07:23 So it's where the, you know, where, how the creative accounting works on whether that gets the go ahead, um- And, and that'd be my-- Like, you know, like JD said, everyone's still ramping production. 1:07:34 They're all still dialing up production with the exception of, of what? Core Lithium, right? Or- Yeah. But ev- everyone else is still dialing up production. 1:07:42 So in that environment, it's just really, really hard to have a, a positive outlook on any of the developers to come into- Yeah... 1:07:48 production when you've got a lot more supply still coming online and then, um, people have recalibrated their expectations on demand at the same time. Mm. Well, you think like Pil- Pilbara-- Pilgangoora's dialing up from 1:07:59 effectively what they were before, six eight, you go into a thousand. 1:08:03 So they're bringing in four hundred thousand ton a year of spod into the market, and then talking about possibly expanding to P2000 and what's worked for them before was 1:08:15 getting the mine built and then there's a bit of mania and they just bring in the chocolates for a short period, and that set that business up with so much cash and they're probably like, "Right, that worked before. 1:08:28 Let's do it again." 'Cause, uh, it doesn't need to be mania for long for them to make a absolute bucket load, especially if they start producing above one million ton of spod. Be phenomenal. 1:08:40 B- Bentley, from your, from your time in China, h-how constructive were they around the ultimate demand for electric vehicles and, and batteries? How has the temperature around that kind of changed? 1:08:51 Yeah, so I think, uh, look, look, the EV demand is still there. It's, it's still growing mid to high teens. Uh, but they do have, you know, consumers in China have the same, I guess, uh, 1:09:03 concerns with it as, as, you know, you guys would have in Australia or we, we would have here in the States where it's, it's the range anxiety sort of thing and, and, um, also charging and charging infrastructure combined with, 1:09:16 um, you know, a lot of people there do live in big cities, right? Uh, you know, just in Shenzhen, that's twenty-five million people, and it-- they have the same problems that I would have, right? 1:09:27 So I live in a high-rise building. How the hell am I gonna charge my car at night, right? There's not the charging space for every single person in this building, and there probably won't ever be. 1:09:38 Well, new buildings will probably be built with them, but this one won't, right? So yeah, there's multiple constraints that come to that, and they have the same thing. So 1:09:45 plug-in hybrids has been picking up a lot in popularity and, um, brother-in-law just bought a new Li Auto, right? Which is a Li Auto. Um, that's a plug-in hybrid and they-- 1:09:59 The, the thing to be careful too with the plug-ins is I, I can't speak to Li Auto on this necessarily, but a lot of them are still, um, you know, nickel hydride batteries. They're not, uh, lithium- Yeah... ion batteries. 1:10:12 So that, that is, that is actually a partial concern with the-- when you, when you think about like the lithium battery demand, I guess, coming from all that stuff. But it-- 1:10:23 They, they have so many EV brands and so many very successful companies there that are expanding outside of China as well and exporting that it, it-- the-- it'll still grow in the teens for years to come. 1:10:36 It's just, it'll, it'll have its ebbs and flows, um, more than just the cyclicality of what an automobile is, but also from, look, there's the people that wanna buy a car right now, they don't want a pure EV or maybe they already have one, right? 1:10:51 They can pick up a Hong Guan Mini for, I don't know, equivalent to like six grand. So like [chuckles] maybe you have that to like tootle around the city and then you have something else for longer distances. But, 1:11:02 uh, so the story though hasn't, hasn't changed in terms of-- And then all of a sudden like downbeat on it, um, especially with export stuff and they're, they're growing a lot of capacity in, in neighboring countries. 1:11:12 Um, South America, BYD is doing something big in Brazil. Uh, in, in Eastern Europe, right? So Hungary's been a spot, been a hotspot for- Yeah... battery capacity companies too, so. 1:11:23 Yeah, I think they were building a BYD in, in Turkey as well, and you know- Yep. Yep... obviously there's a, a lot of geopolitics that kinda plays into that. 1:11:31 There was one more sort of group of metals that I was keen to touch on, and that's sort of on the back of you mentioning hybrids there and that's PGMs. H-how have you sort of viewed this market? 1:11:41 Obviously, it's been a, a tough place to kind of, you know, operate as a, as a producer for quite a while, but what are you sort of seeing from, from your perspective? Mate, it's so weird. 1:11:52 The PGM trade seems like a consensus trade now. Like you see it everywhere. Everyone talks about it, but- We're in a very niche part of the world I think. [laughs] Yeah. Yeah. Is it consensus? I don't know. Let's go. 1:12:03 Uh, maybe I'll take off my long now I guess. [laughing] No, I don't, uh... 1:12:14 That'd be a tough move to, to do at these prices, but I think part of that's gonna be the supply side too, that people are pretty positive on it. It's not just the plug-in hybrids, but, uh, 1:12:27 I would say the, the better question-- What... Shooting something back to you guys really quick. What have you guys heard about platinum versus palladium in this regard? Pl-- 1:12:36 Yeah, a lot of people favoring platinum, like versus palladium at the moment. That's, that's definitely the f- Okay. I think it's hard to get like, you know, the platinum dominant kind of exposure in the miners. 1:12:46 That's why people are going to the physicals and everything. But, um, yeah. I mean, you can, it's just unless you like South Africa. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. 1:12:55 Escom has been-- God, Escom issues go back to my currency trading days too. So it's, uh, yeah, it's-- That's-- Look, I favor platinum as well, I'll say that. 1:13:08 But, um, you know, it's, it's a very int-- I'll say this too, it's, it's a really interesting study on supply and demand dynamics and price, and we've always-- We did a bunch of research on this several years ago where believe it or not, but... 1:13:20 Well, I'm gonna call it supply and demand because it's what you can see and that, that's part of the issue in itself, but-Doesn't correlate that strongly to prices. 1:13:32 It's the, the bigger correlation actually happens to be with the demand side versus recent trend growth. Just what we found, right? Um, and a gr- great example of that last year is not really... 1:13:49 I can't even think of a better example of this, was palladium, right? Palladium was at a massive deficit last year, really big. And, or I don't even remember what, two years ago now prices were pushing 3,000. 1:14:04 Just, uh, well, we were below 900 a couple days ago. So that [sighs] it's a hell of a move for a market to be quasi, 1:14:13 um, in a deficit and, you know, like s- stockpiling that went on with auto- auto companies with fears of Russia because palladium is much more... Norilsk, right? Um, even in, even Norilsk's facilities in Finland. But, 1:14:27 um, uh, I don't know if anybody's noticed this, but one of the only metals to not be sanctioned by the US is palladium, so. I did not know that. Very political. Yeah, did not know that. They, uh [laughs] Hmm. 1:14:42 Whatever's convenient to them, they decide to do. Uh, [laughs] so, um, you know, watch out for that though. 1:14:47 I mean, the UK last year, at the end of the year, they, they did some stuff against like trading for it and Russian palladium, and that did cause some issues. But, 1:14:56 uh, because the LBMA, so you have the LBMA and the Swiss trade, it's still... There's a little bit of palladium involved. 1:15:01 But look, platinum and palladium are also, you're not taking a platinum ingot and using that into a catalytic converter. You, you can, I believe. 1:15:10 I believe I've read that you can actually do it, but typically it'd be more of like a sponge product that you would use. But I- I... Look, I prefer platinum as well. Kind of where I'm getting on that too. 1:15:19 That just has to do with the latest models of cars, they switched to using more platinum and... Because platinum used to be a diesel catalyst, and now it's being used in petrol. So the hybrids are typically petrol. 1:15:32 I don't know how many plug-in hybrid diesels, especially after Volkswagen's minor issue. [laughs] Very, very minor. What was that one? Yeah. [laughs] That was their emissions, uh, cheating- Oh, yeah... scandal. Yeah. 1:15:48 Yeah. So, so when you say you're long there, Bentley, in this case, are you talking purely about the metal because the, the producers are, you know, just, just tough and, and riddled with risk? 1:15:59 Or how do you sort of expose yourself to it? Yeah. So our trading business, I try to get a little bit involved. That's gonna be tough. Uh, we don't. So I'll, I'll say in trading world, have nothing there. 1:16:10 But, uh, hedge fund space, yeah, look, I own physical platinum. 1:16:14 Um, feel fairly, uh, all right about that, and I'll hedge against it and do different things that you can do in, in the derivatives market to where it's not just a pure levered exposure of some sort. 1:16:24 But- How do you, how do you, how do you hedge it, out of curiosity? Um, so precious metals are, uh, against the dollar. They're, they're more... How do I explain it? 1:16:41 Due to their supply, they, they, they... There's a, there's a lending leasing market to it so that they act a lot with interest rates. So there's a... 1:16:48 You really want it to, you didn't feel comfortable at price over the next month or two, you can literally sell forward and collect like an interest rate, just like a contango market, essentially. 1:16:56 Or we just use options in the derivatives market as well, and we'll, we'll do that and just take advantage of, "Hey, price has rallied a bunch." It's part of our portfolio management. 1:17:04 It's like, "All right, price has rallied a bunch." Um, you can either take stuff off the table, but if you hold physical, it's a little bit more difficult. 1:17:12 Or you just go in and you can structure an options position that takes advantage of the downside and then, you know, you know... A, a hedge, we don't like to look at a hedge as just like a static thing. 1:17:24 I'm gonna put in, I'm gonna go buy a put, right? And, you know, whenever it expires, wherever price is, it's, you know, if price gets to a certain point, I'm just like, "Well, screw it. 1:17:33 Why don't I just take profits on the hedge?" And no matter what, I will always be beating the price in the market, right? So as long as you do that, but if you let a hedge expire worthless, then it's not the case. 1:17:45 So that's typically what we'll, we'll do with those sorts of things, and we'll, we'll do that kind of across all, all different metals. And then in the mining space, we dabble a little bit in Zimplex. 1:17:55 It's a nominally liquid equity. [laughs] I don't, I don't own it. I've thought about it. I keep looking at it. Um- It's just- The, the dividend yield's amazing. Zimbabwe only exposure. 1:18:05 But yeah- That was our reasoning for it too, is, uh, maybe we were just scarred by rand trading back in the day. But it was, uh, yeah, it was like, "Okay, well, I can kind of avoid it a little bit by being in Zimbabwe." 1:18:18 And, uh, uh, the other interesting aspect to it too, or we looked at it too, we looked at it and started doing it right after this, was they started to, um... 1:18:25 Mthuli Ncube, which is their, uh, treasury, finance minister, he [laughs]... So when he created their new currency, uh, God, 2019, I think, 2018, somewhere in those two years. That was, mm, didn't work. 1:18:39 Uh, worked about as well as the one before, honestly. Um, and then, but their new scheme is, 'cause they're very much in, in Zimbabwe, your currencies that you typically would find are dollars, euros, yen, yuan. 1:18:53 It's kind of what you're transacting, right? Uh, rand as well, sorry. So their new one is actually tied to, um, the precious metals they mine. So I found that pretty interesting. It's like, "Oh, all right. 1:19:07 Zimplex could benefit maybe a little bit from that." So I felt a little bit comfortable having something small. Again, [laughs] trades like what? 50,000 shares a day or something crazy like that. [laughs] Yeah. 1:19:16 So you can't, you can't put size. [laughs] Yeah. I think- What is it? You guys know. It was like a, the, the reason why it even still exists on the ASX is 'cause- Yeah. 1:19:25 Yeah, there was a, there was a minority holdout back in theI wanna say early 2000s, um, when Im- Impala Platinum tried to, tried to acqui- acquire it. 1:19:37 Um, and so the m- minority h- hold out basically just ensure that it, it retains this ASX listing, but it's only, like, a bit over 10% of the company. I can't remember, it's like 13% of the company- Oh, right. Yeah... 1:19:48 something like that that's actually, that, that actually trades on ASX. The rest is, is just owned by Impala. And I'm, I'm, I'm sure at one point, you know, Implats will wanna wrap that up, but it's just, you know... 1:19:57 I think there's... I actually think the founder of Zimplats is one of the holdout shareholders, and he's in his, like, late 80s, this guy called Peter Van der Spuy. 1:20:04 Um, and, you know, a bunch of his friends and stuff like that have just killed it. But yeah. Mm. Is there a lot of, uh, miners, like, located that operate in Africa but located in Perth still? Yeah. 1:20:19 Yeah, lots of, lots of, like, African miners, uh, yeah, do... are, are based out of Perth, yeah, uh, just for, for one reason or another. 1:20:26 Um, a lot of pe- lot of, lot of, yeah, Perth people find themselves going to Africa to seek value or, or whatnot. And yeah, some good stories- Mm... some bad stories. Right. There's not really many stories in between. 1:20:39 [laughs] There's, I, I mean, a good amount of South African people moved to Australia as well, sort of in that time and- Ah, okay... Perth, Perth being relatively close. 1:20:48 There was, there was one other aspect of the PGM market that I was keen to get your thoughts on, sort of speaking to Trav's point of, you know, maybe it's becoming more mainstream, but we saw the ETFs, I think they were NYSE-listed ones, had record inflows in, in Q2 of this calendar year. 1:21:04 So ETFs track holding physical palladium and platinum. Is that something you'd, you'd picked up on? I had not. No, I had not picked up on that. I used to follow it closer than I do now. Um, 1:21:18 no, I can't, I don't have much color on that, I'm gonna be honest. [laughs] I, I didn't, didn't actually, didn't see that note, um- R- record levels is in quotation marks 'cause it's, you know, from a very low base, so 1:21:30 s- some of these are just tiny ETFs. But- It's not like, like, silver and gold have pretty big ETFs. Um, platinum and palladium, as far as I'm concerned, there's not a huge amount of physical trusts. 1:21:41 I think there's maybe- They're tiny... one, but- Yeah. Okay. Yeah. No, I didn't see that. Beautiful, Bentley. 1:21:49 I think we've, uh, exhaustive, exhausted my list of questions, and I'm much the wiser in the, uh, commodity trading side of things, so appreciate you, you coming on and making the time for us. Bloody interesting, mate. 1:22:01 We'll get you on next time for uranium. [laughs] Okay. Yeah, I... [laughs] Yeah. Yeah, we'll, we'll see where prices are at at that point. It's, uh- Yeah, you'll have to join him. 1:22:12 Yeah, we'll save that, we'll save that one for, for later. I, uh, probably a good thing. Didn't really wanna get triggered by things like next gen, but, you know. 1:22:18 [laughs] I'll a- we'll ask you quickly, but before we finish, the fact that the spot has just stopped trading 1:22:27 and this fucking long-term outlook that everyone's got, which would indicate to me you wouldn't think too many people would wanna sell physical that they have if they have this long-term outlook. 1:22:38 So if something's not being traded and not people, pe- not many people wanna sell it, what's gonna happen when people wanna start buying it again? 1:22:47 Do you think there's more upside potential than downside potential for that thinly traded spot market? So it's really interesting when you look back at, uh, what, 2013, 2012, Goldman 1:23:01 wanted to effectively get rid of what the... So they had, they had a lot of uranium, right? And they had physical, and they're like, "Eh, kind of just wanna get rid of this," and they held onto it. 1:23:10 Um, I don't know the... It's probably not the full story there. It's obviously not the full story, but- Mm... so they were actually the ones that held a lot for fund people. Now, I don't do business with Goldman Sachs. 1:23:22 Uh, [laughs] it's not, uh, I, I think they're, again, they do what they say they're gonna do. They do really good at their reputation. That's why, you know, it's just kind of a competitor, I guess, in a way. 1:23:34 So, um, I, I don't have a ton of insight of what they've done with that uranium and who holds it at this point. 1:23:39 I do know, as you, you know, you pointed out some of these, even miners, right, like Basin Mines I know hold some too. And, uh, you have the, the Sprott's Uranium Trust. And what you could end up seeing is... 1:23:52 So technically a trust like that, a closed-end fund, is, it, it's, it's kind of like an, an equity. So you have to, if somebody comes in levered, they could technically... Sprott's is huge. It probably wouldn't happen. 1:24:03 But they can come in levered, buy enough shares in the Sprott's ETF, and then vote and force. You could basically activist and force them to sell- Yeah... and that's probably the only way they would do it. 1:24:14 Um, again, I don't know why. I'm not a huge fan of these, these physical trusts for that reason, where it's like, what's, what's the, you know, what's the point? You gotta get some sort of cash flow at some point, right? 1:24:24 Um, people buying physi- Sure, yeah. Look, people chase all the time. So if you, if you see uranium going up towards 120 again in the spot market, I can almost guarantee there's gonna be some people that come and chase. 1:24:36 Now, is there enough out there and enough people out there that are willing to sell? That'd be, that'd be the question. 1:24:42 And then at what point do some of these miners catch on to all that and they're just like, "F this, we're gonna deliver it against that stuff," if they can. 1:24:48 A lot of them can't because of their long-term pricing mechanisms and just the way that the market is. It's kind of, it's funky that it has a spot market like that, but when people can hold physical, I find that odd. 1:25:01 But, um, you know, I mean, it's not, it's not enriched, right? So I guess there's that as well. But, um, yeah, it'll be interesting to see that. It's just, you know, y- I don't remember who you guys had on the other day. 1:25:15 I was talking about legislation being put in place and it's- Oh, um- The one thing-... Warren, Warren Irwin signed the- Yeah... DOE with a strike of a pen could essentially force- Yeah... 1:25:26 not force majeure or whatever the word is to say, "No, you have to sell those."Well, maybe 'cause you guys remember the, um, a while back they tried to do a, a physical copper trust, and they actually, 1:25:38 um, the, the downstream players that fabricated stuff went to, took 'em to court. I think it was... I don't remember who it was. I don't want to say which bank it was 'cause I don't wanna get it wrong, but it was... 1:25:48 Someone was trying to do it, right? A couple people were. And it never went through the courts, I don't believe. I think they just dropped it and didn't end up doing the copper trust at that point. Now, now there is one. 1:25:56 Spot has one, but- Yeah... um, uh, so I, I don't believe there's a precedent there. A lawyer. I'm not gonna read about that stuff, but, uh, that would be an interesting [laughs] interesting situation to get in. 1:26:09 Um, and I'm well aware that Matty holds the, uh, the physical uranium trust at some point. [laughs] Ding, ding, ding. [laughs] Smart, mate. Yeah. Look, yeah, I mean, 1:26:20 if the drive's price is higher, drive price is high, right? We're at, what, 82, 82 and a half right now, something like that. Yeah. Just kidding. Yeah. It's very, it's very interesting. 1:26:27 I think it's, I think Spot's trading at nearly 15% discount to nav as of last night, so it's, um, all very quiet at the moment. That's a lot of carry. There's gotta be hedge funds in there. 1:26:44 Well, no, they're not really easy to do. Like, the futures market's not very liquid, so- Yeah... um, I don't know how you... Somebody's probably doing it, though. That's cool. I'm sure they've looked. [laughs] Yeah. 1:26:56 No, sensational, mate. That was frigging awesome. Thanks for, um... Oh, love, love talking to people across the ditch, connecting us to other continents. Love it. Yeah. It's, it's great to, great, great to talk, guys. 1:27:08 It's been, been a lot of fun. Ooh, there we go, JD. Right in your wheelhouse, that one. I love those chats. Mate, that was fascinating, and another person I'd never heard about until very recently. 1:27:17 It's awesome these people were just happy to come on the show and share their wisdom with us. I can't believe I've listened to it before. No, that- It's so flattering, isn't it? That, that truly blows my mind. 1:27:25 [laughs] Who would've thought you'd be, people would be listening to what you have to say a year ago, JD? Who would've thought? And your face would be attached to it. 1:27:32 Yeah, but apparently we're more entertaining than the talking heads on CNBC. [laughs] What a legend. Good on you, Bentus. You bloody legend, mate. And, uh, another legend, Axis Mine and Technology. Absolutely. 1:27:44 A bloody cornerstone legend. Drill hole survey Trusted partners... oh, so, oh, Jesus Christ, they're trustworthy. Ah, mate, in the show we had MMS as well with Get Wet. Bloody- Who else we got? We got Verify, Matty. 1:27:57 Oh, we do. We got- D-... DSI Underground. D- Silverstone. WA Waterbores. Oh, Gerard James. Gerard James. Uh, CRE Insurance. K-DRIL. Oh, and bloody, a good old Spark chart every now and then doesn't hurt anyone. 1:28:10 You spark. Ooh. Who to owe Money Minds. Have a good weekend and go Australia. 1:28:14 [laughs] Information contained in this episode of Money of Mine is of general nature only and does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular person. 1:28:24 Before making any investment decision, you should consult with your financial advisor and consider how appropriate the advice is to your objectives, financial situation, and needs.