Transcript 0:00 Righto, Money Minders. Welcome back to another week. Geez, we just slot straight into it, don't we? Bloody love it. Hey, if youse aren't on the director's special yet, get on it, moneyofmine.com. 0:11 This bloody newsletter is the only mining email you need to open every day. Can I say it more simply? I'm really happy with how it's going, mate. Oh. Thank, thanks to you too. [laughs] Great job. 0:23 Uh, right, boys, we've got a bit of a day today. Mate, a bit of, uh, speculation and whatever out of, uh, Gold Road. Yes, mate. 0:34 Right Can the, um, the mighty Gold Road, who has one non-controlling joint venture interest, make it two- Mm... in Canada? [laughs] And a shareholding in Degro. 0:42 [laughs] Uh, and right, Pr- Predictive Discovery chucked out this study today for the Mancan project. You've gone in the weeds here, Matty. You're just, uh, Mister- Mining and now Metallurgy. 0:55 Hey, you've, you've got a new- Thanks to Mr. Nathan Stoynes. What an episode that was. Fuck, that was a ripper. I've re-listened to it three times, not gonna lie. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. Bloody, bloody brilliant. 1:06 Uh, oh fuck, jeez, Jesus. I- overwhelmed by the awesomeness. Keep it going. Keep it going, Matty. Uh, mate, what, Jada, you're, uh, this is, reeks of you. Russian metal band from the LME. 1:16 I knew you would say that as soon as you read that off. It does reek of me. I'm pretty keen to talk about it. The, uh, aluminum price jumped up almost 10% on the LME, and nickel up 9%, so very interesting stuff. 1:30 Oh, mate, tell you what else is interesting, Rio Tinto's Rio blowout. Like Zhao Jin, they've chucked a best and final in for T- Tienanmen, given it a bit of that one. 1:40 And, uh- That's not the only best and final, mate, because, uh, Emerald have done the same at Bullseye. Mm. Is there a best and final coming for Sierra Rutile? Who knows. [laughs] A little bit out of them. 1:51 Touching on Emerald, mate, she's absolutely all go. Trav, take it away, mate- Mm... 1:57 because Gold R- Gold Road has confirmed, based on, uh, your long lost sister's news article in The Australian this morning, uh- [laughs]... confirming interest in a gold project in 2:11 Australia's favorite gold mining jurisdiction, Canada, where there's... North America, where there's been so much success. Ah, this, there's a lot of angles to this story, and that is one of them, Matty. 2:22 But the gist of it is, before, you know, I've done some analysis today. I feel proud of myself. I've actually done some work. 2:27 Um, but you know, Bridget Carter's done the most work because she's put, she's put a banger in, a zinger in data room once more that's got our attention. 2:34 Uh, so late last night she revealed in her column that Gold Road is pretty advanced in its attempt to buy a 40% stake in Greenstone Gold Mines off of private equity group Orion. 2:43 Now, Greenstone Gold Mines is a, a Canadian, uh, asset. It's 40% owned by Orion Mine Finance, that's a private equity group. The other 60% is owned by Equinox Gold. 2:54 Now, Orion's been looking to sell its stake for some time, and being a private equity group, like you can basically assume that they want cash. 3:00 They gotta get a return, return that, um, like it's, in order for the fund timeline, give the cash back to LPs, happy days. 3:05 And I, you know, so, so in this sort of deal you gotta think, "Okay, consideration's gotta be cash." 3:09 And this morning Gold Road's basically confirmed their interest in the asset in this one-page announcement released to ASX in a response to the media speculation. 3:17 Um, but they, they say that, you know, there's nothing, no binding or definitive acquisition agreements just yet. F- first of all, before I, before I do my, a bit of analysis, Matty, what do we know about this asset? 3:28 Well, we know that Equinox is the majority joint venture partner, and it is the operator of the asset. 3:34 And the, that company, Equinox, they gave a big spiel at the Europe Gold Forum last week with a good chunk of detail about where the asset is, um, at the moment. 3:42 So they say Greenstone's gonna be coming online in second half of this year. It's got an initial 14 year mine life for an open pit, 1.3 grams per ton. 3:49 They say they expect Greenstone to be producing at sub 1,000 bucks per ounce, I assume that's US. Now, they say it's started hot commissioning already, ramp up, um, in Q3. 4:01 They reckon it'll get to about 80% full production, and they expect 95% capacity, uh, through the plant by the end of the year. About, what is it, 4- 400,000 ounces, isn't it? Yeah, in the early years. 4:13 I mean, it's a- Yeah... it's a pretty, it's a pretty, like- Big humdinger... big humdinger. Uh, it is quite large. You're, you're 100% right. 4:18 And look, Equinox is a US, like $2 billion market cap company, and their share price has rallied about 50% in about six weeks, which is- Jesus Christ... 4:26 a pretty big, like, you know, rally for a, for a company of that size when you factor in the base effect. And you know, in that time their valuation discount to NAV has tightened from about.64 times NAV to.88 times NAV. 4:39 So my interpretation of that is that, you know, the market's basically saying, "We think the Greenstone ramp-up is on track," and de-risking, you know, your valuation accordingly. 4:48 Of course, gold price has rallied in the interim as well. But you know, even that, that discount to NAV is really tight. 4:52 And so here's, here's a snippet I just wanted to include, um, of how Equinox talks about this asset in that latest presentation. 4:59 It's the, uh, it's a, it's a rare asset in that it's going to be a very high volume, as you just saw, producer annually. Uh, typically these mines are owned by majors or very large private, uh, groups. 5:07 So it's one of the very few, uh, as we move forward, uh, high output gold production mines that's gonna be owned by a mid-tier gold producer. 5:14 Now, with all of that out of the way, the bigger question to answer is should Gold Road actually do this deal, right? And I have a bit to say about this topic. A lot of moving parts here, Trav. Lots. 5:24 Uh, to answer this question. Lots, mate. Lots. 5:27 And the stock's down 8% today, which is more than other goldies are by a long shot, and that's probably got something- Yeah, most of the goldies are down, but not by that much. Totally, mate. 5:35 It's probably got something- Except for 150... to do with this key sentence in the data room column. 5:38 It's the third sentence and it says this, "It is believed that should Australian Gold, or Australian listed Gold Road buy Greenstone, it would be accompanied by a monster capital raising." [laughs] It is believed by who? 5:51 [laughs] A monster capital raising. So look, of course the stock sails off in early trades today, way to spook the market, and it's that sentence that tells you everything you need to know about the source of this leak. 6:01 Whoever has leaked this deal wants the deal dead. That's my interpretation. 6:05 Because-Y- you leak the deal, allude to an equity raise, the stock sells off, shareholders, you know, they'll eventually speak up against the deal, and the deal falls apart. 6:14 That's kind of the pathway to kill a deal, right? So perhaps now we should all talk about who, who has the biggest incentive to kill the deal here? 6:22 Well, firstly, it sounds like they've, they've used whoever the source is' exact wording is, "Monster equity raising." [laughs] Sound- sounds like it's come straight from the horse's mouth. 6:30 [laughs] That, uh, that's probably on the money, right? So I got, I got two theories, uh, on who the, who the... who would, who would leak this deal, right? 6:38 Nu- number one would be, and I've seen this before, it's whoever's got the, the second-- like the, the second-best bid. So, like you could imagine, I don't know what stage this sale process is at, but if they've... 6:48 If the, the sellers, um, or the advisors have declared Gold Road as preferred bidder, typically whoever's like second can kind of figure that out, they can deduce it, and via their advisors, they'll, they'll sometimes be a bit cheeky and leak something like this, which can have the effect of killing the deal. 7:04 And then all of a sudden, the second-best bidder is the best bidder. Um- And we alluded to this exact sort of scenario playing out a couple years ago in the, uh, director special this morning with IGO and the CSA mine. 7:16 Yeah. I mean, you can follow the, the, you know, the, the article, um, [tsks] as they un- articles as they un- unraveled with that sale process of, of CSA from Glencore. You know, IGA... 7:26 IGO was in pole position, preferred, preferred bidder, deal g- deal gets leaked. Of course, there was gonna be an equity component to that deal. It was like a billion-dollar, um, sort of sale price or, or purchase price. 7:37 And, uh, look, the... I think IGO fell about 15%, um, [tsks] in a single day, which, which effectively kind of killed the deal for them. And then ultimately the deal, um, was done to, to... 7:47 It was Acquisition Corp instead. You got, you got I- IGAs on your mind at the moment. IGA. [laughs] My bad. [laughs] What, um... So h- here's another left field one. 8:00 Would the source that, uh, leaked the deal potentially want Gold Road to be cheaper 'cause they wanna buy Gold Road, more than not... Not as likely. That's, uh, that's a, that's another theory to throw in the mix. 8:12 And I think the, the corporate appeal of Gold Road is, is a big topic I wanna talk about towards the, the, the tail end of my spiel here, Mattie. So back to that better question, right? Should Gold Road do this deal? 8:24 And subject to whatever the terms of the deal would be, I'm pretty damn critical of this one. I looked at a couple of broker reports for Equinox Gold. 8:32 These reports, they typically ascribe about US $1.8 billion of NAV to Equinox's 60% interest in the project. So based on that, a pro rata 40% interest would be about US 1.2 billion. 8:46 Maybe subtract a little bit for the fact that Orion's share is non-controlling and apply a further discount given, you know, it's... 8:53 There's still ramp-up risk here, so it shouldn't transact a one times NAV until ramp-up risk is removed. 8:58 So call it, call it about a U- U- US $900 million price tag for 40% of Greenstone here, or about $1.4 billion Australian. That's just a thumb suck number, um, based on, you know, those broker reports. 9:12 If, if that is the case, I think the data room commentary is right there. It would be a monster capital raising on the cards. 9:19 Gold Road is capped at only 1.8 billion Aussie itself, so you'd be looking at a hefty entitlements offer to buy this thing. 9:28 And to get that away, you needed to raise it an attractive enough discount to the last share price. 9:33 So I remember when, when Regis did its one for three entitlements issue to buy 30% of Tropicana, that was done at a 15% discount to its last traded price. 9:42 And look, it's actually the equity raise implications of this potential deal that I'm most critical of here. So if you, if, if you... None of us are Gold Road shareholders, but if you were, what would you think? 9:56 Mate, I'd... If I was a Gold Road shareholder, you know, I... 10:00 And, and Gold Road basically decided to buy the, the Greenstone interest by doing an equity raise at, you know, a 10, 10% plus, 15% discount, I'd be, I'd be pretty, pretty f- fuming. 10:12 And, and, and I'll do my best to try and articulate this. 10:15 A company should not willy-nilly dilute its shareholders to do a deal if their scrip is, is undervalued because then you're effectively double punishing existing shareholders. Take, for example, look at this chart here. 10:27 I've simply charted the relative share price performance of Gold Road and its peers on the same chart over the last 12 months to Friday. So to, you know, to the last, uh, price before, before today. 10:39 I think Gold Road, Northern Star, Regis, West Gold, Silver Lake, Red, um, Genesis, uh, Evolution, Remelius, Bellevue, Capricorn. They're, they're the peers, right? 10:47 They're, they're all the, you know, mid-tier gold producers with Australian dominant portfolios. And guess which company is the biggest underperformer of the lot? It might surprise you. [laughs] It's Gold Road. Yeah. 10:59 Wild, right? Closely followed by Regis. [laughs] So, like, this, this data is before the sell-off today. Last 12 months, right, the, the share price has dropped 6.8% while gold has been rallying hard. So i- 11:13 i- if the stock has substantially underperformed its peers, why does someone choose to, to buy Gold Road today? Why would you buy the stock Gold Road today if it's substantially underperformed its peers? 11:23 I'll tell you why. You buy it because the company is an M&A target, and you want it to get taken over. And fair enough. Like, what even is this company, right? It's like the worst royalty company in the world. 11:34 You've gotta pay costs. It's [laughs] like they've got a non-controlling 50% interest in Gruyere. They've got a 20% stake into Greatworth, about 480 million bucks. 11:42 And for the longest time, shareholders have, have, you know, copped having to stump up all of the costs and overheads associated with this company, despite the fact that they aren't a real miner. 11:50 And look what they spend on exploration every year. Just like, look at that expense, right? So that's, that's some $35 million a year. Unfortunately, they haven't found another Gruyere with that money to date. 12:00 Throw in another $20 million per annum in, you know, in our overheads, corporate, corporate, you know, GNA expense. 12:07 If you NPV that-Call it $55 million a year in, in overheads, um, to present day terms over a 15-year period. 12:14 You can kind of paint the case that there's $500 million of present day synergies to any acquirer by simply buying Gold Road, wiping the exploration and corporate expenses, right? Mm. 12:26 Just, just cut out all of the, the, you know, the fat and, um, and you don't actually have to do any additional work if you buy Gold Road. You know what I mean? 12:34 Like, it's, [laughs] it's not like you have to allocate any additional, like, overheads yourself to, to administer these assets. They're non-controlling. It's, it's like sweet fuck all. 12:43 So- So that's a, that's an application of where 500 million present day- [laughs]... value, like the Karora- [laughs]... WestGold thing is quite applicable, I think. Yeah, but y- yeah, you know what I mean. 12:51 Like, what do you- Yeah... what do you actually have to do owning Gold Road? Like, there's not much work to do. 12:55 Like [laughs] It's kind of, it's kind of fascinating that they'd look at a- another non-controlling JV interest as well, given like, having tuned into the, the last few quarterly calls, you know, they've got so much anger at being in that position and pointing the finger and, you know, at various people, mainly the, the contractor, and saying they can't do much about the situation, that they just look to dig themselves into the same hole again. 13:19 Well, I, I think it's because they don't have operating capability in their team, right? Like you, you... Like, why, why take risk that's outside your wheelhouse? You kind of... 13:27 Like, you know that, we all know they had a big crack at trying to get their hands on the non-controlling interest in Tropicana, which ultimately went to Regis instead. Um, here they are again. 13:37 It's, it's in their wheelhouse to wanna own something where they don't actually have to apply the operating capability. 13:42 But, uh, but that to me, like it's, it's just like they, they're such a, a potential target to the right sort of buyer, especially given what's happened to Escrip over the last year compared to peers, so. 13:52 When you, when you look at that J and A, Trav, it's interesting when you think that they are a non-operate- like a non-controlling interest in that operation, so technically you would need less people- Totally... 14:03 if you're non-controlling. Mate, you don't need anyone. [laughs] You know what I mean? Like, like the expenses come- It makes the term look good... under the joint venture. 14:09 That's, that's the, that's the G and A outside the joint venture. Oh, wow [laughs]. You know what I mean? Like, you don't need to spend anything. Cut all, cut it all out. Like- Yeah... 14:16 so it's, it's, that's the appeal of like, you know, to a, to a potential acquirer of Gold Road. Um, now I'll, I'll tell you what you absolutely don't want Gold Road to do. 14:28 [laughs] You do not want them to use their scrip when it has underperformed like crazy to get a deal done that is in a, in a different jurisdiction. They'd have to raise the equity at a discount. 14:38 The deal gets them another non-controlling joint venture asset ripe for Gold Road, who must love not having to do much work. But I would, I'd be pretty filthy if I was a Gold Road shareholder- Mm... 14:47 subject to whatever the terms of the deal are, because we don't really know them yet, but, you know, the financing might, might be, um, funky and... 14:54 But, but like, if it is a big equity raise and all, and all the, all the rest, I'd be pretty filthy because- So they, so they can't, um, as you said, Oran want cash, so they, it won't be a scrip offering likely to Oran. 15:07 It's gonna have to be some sort of debt equity package to pay for this, so we'll- I would assume so, yeah. And look, look, you should, you should need to demonstrate to your shareholders that 15:19 w- you know, why you're currently trading at a giant premium to your intrinsic value if you wanna use equity, and that's why it's appropriate to use your scrip in a deal. 15:26 You shouldn't use beaten up scrip to do a deal in a different jurisdiction just because it will fend off potential acquirers who might be circling you, and everyone gets to keep their job. 15:34 I mean, I wanna be fair to this company because I'm at risk of being pretty harsh on them. Like, there are some things I like about Gold Road. 15:41 For example, they report their corporate all-in cost, or CAIC, um, as popularized by Johnny Mac, as a fair way to assess their real costs. 15:48 I just think the company needs to be incredibly thoughtful about articulating why the best thing for shareholders would be raising equity at a substantial discount to get a deal done in a jurisdiction, versus just selling themselves at a premium to someone who might be corporately interested in them because they could get, you know, $500 million of synergies on day one. 16:08 [laughs] Based on that J and A, Trav- [laughs]... soft issues sunshine. That's probably right, Matty. [laughs] Oh, what do you, what... It, it was interesting looking at the article from- Sorry... 16:21 the Australian last year. 16:22 Uh, 'cause they were talking about this Greenstone project and how the most li- when it was sort of up for sale then as well, the most likely acquirers, they were pointing to Northern Star and Evolution, but then the next paragraph just went on to Ramelius. 16:36 [laughs] Seems to be a bit of a relationship going on there. [laughs] Oh, Matty. The whole thing was... Become you. I love it. [laughs] Made well tried. 16:45 I, I couldn't be like you, because only you could give the rundown on Predictives Bankan PFS in the way that you have today, and I'm excited for it. Back at Bankan. 16:54 Uh, mate, we're heading over to Guinea, JD, your lovely... your holiday destination. Uh, the Predictive Discovery's PFS is out. 17:01 Mate, give us, just give us the lie of the land before we get in the weeds of this, this, uh, beautiful study that anyone can read to go to sleep. It's just our good study. [laughs] So love 'em. 17:13 [laughs] All righty, mate. We'll, uh, we'll stay very much in our lanes and I'll let you get into the mining stuff, but we'll just, um, skim over the, the highlights to give people a feel. 17:21 And Trav, you mentioned Gold Road down eight odd percent. Predictive is as well. 17:25 So the reception hasn't been too kind to the study today, although that is a kind of common phenomenon when you get into these studies starting to come out. 17:34 So they've trading at an AV of about 450 million as we speak, and yeah, the, the market's not taken a liking to it. 17:42 So the headline numbers are, they've come out with their maiden ore reserve, 3.05 million ounces, and then they've provided two cases. They're actually pretty similar. 17:51 One of them's got a bit of an expansion that includes some inferred answers. So we'll focus on the, on the base case. 5.5 million tons per annum processing rate, 11-year mine life. 18:02 The, the expansion just has a 12-year mine life. 18:05 You got open pit and then getting into an underground averaging 1.4 grams per ton and then 3.2 grams per ton underground256,000 ounces per annum, it's pretty chunky, at 92% recoveries. And here's, here's the cost. 18:20 All-in sustaining cost, US 1,130. NPV5, using the, the lowercase of US 1800 gold, is US four-- 570 million. So that's a 24% IRR. 18:38 And then in the sort of, you know, more bright light scenario, NPV5 using gold of 2,300, so that's a, a very recent gold price- The old five percent discount... you get US- Five percent discount in guinea. 18:49 I'll, uh, yeah, I don't know about that one. But, uh- Yeah, it's crazy... anyway. So you get 1.2 billion NPV for the upside case and a 41% IRR. And both scenarios show a pre-production CapEx of US 460 million. So- Mm. 19:05 Interesting... with that, uh, discount rate aside, Matty- Well-... let's get into the, the mining side of things. 19:12 And the metallurgy, JD, 'cause geez aren't we more, more, much the wiser, the money miners, after Nathan Stuart has graced us with his presence, mate. 19:22 Uh, well, most of it's coming out of the open pit, so out of that three million ounces, 2.3 million are coming from a 1.4 gram pit, so that's a pretty bloody decent pit. 700,000 ounces coming from the underground. 19:35 So strip ratio 4.6, pretty good. Strip ratio's really good at the start. And looking at the underground, that looks, looks pretty bloody good, I reckon. 19:44 So, it's like a bulk mining, so 15, 20 meter wide stopes, 30 meter level space. And so the, the... You'll read in there, it says that it's transverse primary, secondary with pace fill. 19:55 So, I'll show on the screen, they'll be developing into the ore body from the footfall side and then, you know, taking the primary stopes and then this, uh, pace fill them and take the ones, uh, in between the pace once you're done. 20:07 So, it's one of those ones, once you, once you open those big stopes up, nice and wide, pretty tall, pretty easy tons compared to narrow vein mine and at a grade of 3.2 grams per ton. 20:19 So look, 15 strike, 20 wide, 30 high, that's 25,000 ton stopes at three grams gold. That's, uh, buddy, you'd take them any day of the week. 20:28 So, um, and I think it looks like they've only got to get it in the first five years. 20:32 They've only got to get 900,000 ton of ore out from the underground, so mix that with, in with the development ore, should bloody piss it in. So, um, now, they've applied... Found this interesting at the start. 20:45 Mining dilution of 15% or, and a recovery of 90%. So, when you've got, uh, bulk mining, especially when you're taking your primaries out, if you're getting dilution from your walls, that's 20:57 the stopes next door, so it's not waste. Whereas, I'd say the front and back of the stopes dilution and recovery of 90%, it's like if you're pace fill and everything, you should be getting most of the ore body. 21:08 But looking here, they've actually leaving some sill pillars and stuff, so they will, won't get full recovery of the ore body. Um, so for instance, Bellevue 21:19 leaving pillars gets 83%, so that means 17% are left in pillars and dirt they don't recover. So, um, 15% dilution, I'm like, "Oh, that's pretty, looks pretty overestimated for what they're doing." 21:32 But you look at the dip of the ore body, it's pretty, pretty bloody laid over. So if they're coming in from the foot wall, they'll have to cut a bit of the foot wall out, um- Mm... 21:43 to, 'cause it's sort of going back over themselves, and then you've got the hanging wall coming over at a pretty bloody flat angle, so they might get some dilution off that. 21:50 So- What's the, what's the worst angle to, to, to i-in case that, like, that dilution's like th- Oh, any-... 35, 40... anything like, anything 40 or below- Yeah... 21:59 it means it's really laying over and you're gonna leave probably even 50 or, 50 or below, leaving shit on your foot wall 'cause it won't reel. And that's where the- Like the golia and all that... 22:08 that's where that dilution comes into play. Yeah. Yeah, well, you, you... The dilution comes from the hanging wall leaning over so much and breaking. Yeah. Just 'cause of the, the gravity, like it's just laying over. 22:20 And then your recovery is when it's, you don't, you can't get it to reel off the flat foot wall, and the dirt gets le-left there, so you're not recovering the ore. So, uh, where are we up to? Metallurgy, mate. 22:38 Let me just bloody scroll down. Beautiful p- beautiful bloody pictures here. But yeah, she's, uh, she's bloody piss- pissing it in. Look, 250,000 ounces, up to 350 by year seven. She's frigging flying. 22:51 Mate, metallurgy looks pretty, pretty basic, uh, for this region by the sounds. Free milling, around 92% recovery. About 39% of that res- is recovered in the gravity circuit, so that's always good. 23:04 Five and a half million ton per annum going through a SABC circuit, so that's a SAG, ball, cone crusher, grinding to 75 micron. 23:14 And as Stoit said, 75 is about as low as you wanna go before you have to go down the ultra fine grinding- Yeah... pain in the arse route. You're pushing it, it, beyond that. Yeah. 23:25 Yeah, and it's just bloody shit loads of power and everything. So the way, what an SABC circuit is, so it means the SAG mill does the... So it goes through a jaw crusher first, 23:34 then the SAG mill does the secondary crushing, and from that you have these, remember we talked about s- the scats that come out? You have these parts, the, like these oversized parts that the SAG mill can't crush. 23:47 Those scats then come out and go into a cone crusher, or a, they s- or a pebble crusher they call it, and that gets the scats back below that critical size, and then they feed them back into the SAG mill, and then all of that then goes into, keeps feeding the ball mill, which grinds it to 75 micron. 24:05 Biggest-- So, uh, met looks pretty bloody simple and good, so no, no met risks here I don't think. Um, permitting risk is the big one here, and this is, this is obvious when you see the proposed dry stacked tailings. 24:21 So-When we see a, in Australia or whatever, when you see, like, a tailings dam or it's just wet tailings pumped out, thickened up, thickened up tailings pumped out to the bloody tailings dam, thrown in a big frigging dam. 24:35 Dry stack tailings, so you see on the flow sheet, they've got a... 24:39 There's a tailings thickener and a detox, which you'd, you'd probably, you'd have the tailings thickener, 'cause that's what, that's what thickens the tailings to pump out to a wet tailings dam anyway. 24:50 Detox probably depending on if you needed it for approvals for the cyanide management, so I don't think every o-operation has a detox, but detox is a, usually an, an option that, like, neutralizes the cyanide in the tailings. 25:08 But then you see there's a filter press to give a dry tailing, so... And once it goes through the filter press, you have this dry tailing stack, which should be de- like, ne- all the s- no cyanide in it. 25:18 You've then gotta truck that load and truck that dry stack tailings to the dry stack tailings facility, which is pretty much like a tailings waste dump. So some of that gets used for the pace backfill. 25:31 So I guess between the filters and the loading and trucking, it's a bit of extra opex to manage the tailings. 25:39 But the only reason they would be doing that is because they have to to try and get it permitted, 'cause they can't have a wet, a wet tailings, tailings dam effectively. 25:49 So that's- So they're in the, um, the sort of secondary buffer zone is what it's called of this, um- Yeah. I'll, I'll go through it down here... of this park. It just shows where- Yeah... 25:56 they are, and it's, they're sort of on the fringe a bit. Um, also, they're looking to get a better power solution, so currently they're going down the route of, uh, diesel generators with a solar farm. 26:10 So, but there's this, uh, Linsan Foami transmission line. Wouldn't have pronounced that right. Sorry, don't care. 26:17 Uh, that'll give 'em, that'll give 'em grid power, so it sounds like Guinea is trying to strive to get grid power to these operations. 26:25 Not yet, so that'll be a big one if they can get that over the line and actually get main supply rather than going down the other route. 26:32 But with the, I guess with diesel generators and, and a solar farm, first call they should be making is Silverstone. That's the lo- Absolutely... logical thing, even at, at this early stage. 26:44 The, th- th- they want these diesel gennies to get the underground going, which looks like it's starting. Silverstone do that. They wanna chuck in a solar farm. Silverstone do that. 26:54 They want battery storage to make use of the solar energy for the nighttime. Uh, what do you know? Silverstone do that. Silverto- Silverstone do that. Uh, wanna reduce the emissions on site. 27:05 That's another good thing for permitting. Uh, get some bloody battery vehicles, battery buggies floating around. Well, holy snapping duck shit- Silverstone do that... Silverstone do that. 27:15 Uh, I feel, I feel now that any time you have a question about anything mining related, uh, automated response will be Silverstone- Silverstone do that... do that. Yep. Vertically integrated one-stop shop for mining. 27:27 Silverstone love Guinea. Yeah. Kenny Kay goes there once a year for a bit of a business refresh. I think that's where they have their building, team-building sessions. Yeah. Mate, love it. 27:36 Mate- Pleasure doing business with your producers. They say, they say S- Simandou, not Simandon't. [laughs] Simi- Silverstone do, Simandou as well. 27:46 [laughs] Mate, so yeah, per-permitting and jurisdiction is the big risk here. So, 'cause theys- You got the PFS, which is this, and then the ESIA, the environmental document. 27:59 They're the key docume- documents they gotta submit to get this- Sorry. I got one more. Silverstone say, "Yes, we bancan do it." [laughs] That's horrible. [laughs] Keep going, Matty. [laughs] Bancan do it. That's bad. 28:15 [laughs] Oh. Go on, Matty. I'll just kind of keep it in there. Oh, anyway, permitting jurisdiction, we're talking Guinea, we're talking West Africa. Um, 28:28 where, uh, you see on this map here, as you mentioned before, JD, they've, they're just... They're right on the peripheral zone, uh, from this Niagie National Park, so from the... 28:40 There's a buffer zone, the peripheral zone, so they're sort of right on the edge there. 28:44 So the PFS and the environmental document, they gotta, they gotta submit that to the Ghanaian government to get the exploitation permit, so on track to submit that shortly. And 28:58 look, you know, I suppose you look at the area, like, it borders, when we're talking Guinea, we're talking borders Mali, Senegal, Sierra Leone, Côte d'Ivoire, Liberia. 29:08 But there's, there's a bit of gold mining in this, uh, s- how do you pronounce it? Siguiri Basin, JD. Sounds good. I think that's- That's where- I think that's better... the project's located. You got... 29:18 And notably, you got big operations in there, uh, that AngloGold Ashanti and Nord Gold run. 29:24 So, um, and on the, interestingly, on the per- political front, I think you, you've probably mentioned this and I haven't listened, uh, previously, JD, but the last month, uh, Guinea's then government was dissolved and the military junta appointed a new prime minister. 29:42 Military junta is a group that rules a country after taking power by force. So good old West... That's just West Africa. Love it. 29:51 Uh, new, the new mines minister was appointed, and I guess his initial speech was very centered around increasing the resilience of Guinea's mining sector via downstream value add opportunities. 30:03 Simandou going ahead is probably a sign of positivity for new mining in Guinea. So now in terms- Yeah, Guinea, Guinea's a massive exporter of baux- bauxite already- Mm... 30:13 and obviously trying to make a big presence in, in iron ore and that, you know, de facto group that's in power, they first took over three years ago now, and they've sort of been justRunning, running the country with de facto power, and they're sort of rejigging it as they go. 30:29 Yeah. So like I'll, so I'll bring up the map. All the bauxite's in the west. This, we're talking in sort of the far northeast of Guinea, and then the iron ore's down in the south. 30:38 So the, the country, Guinea will have 15% free carried interest in this project, then, then there's a 5% royalty and a 1% contribution to local development. 30:49 So 6% of revenue does go out the door, uh, which is pretty high. And they'll think-- Then they have an option to purchase a further 5% to get up to 20% if they choose to. So there's a bit of bit going on there. Gotcha. 31:03 Is that, is that the NPV that came out today, did that factor in, though, that, that regime, the economic regime there? You knew I wouldn't know that. [laughs] I would imagine it has to. The, the post-tax NPV numbers. 31:18 The 15% free carried interest, the royalty, et cetera. I th- I think the, you know, the headline numbers there, that 25% IRR NPV- Mm.... 31:26 it's, it's kind of calculated at the project level, so it kind of assumes, it assumes the ownership of project co is, um, not PDI separate from, from the government and kind of just looks at all of it together. Yeah. 31:37 In reality, PDI would have to sulfide CapEx, but they only get, you know, what is it, 85% of the profit. Um, so the, the, you know, for equity holders of, of PDI, it's a bit, bit worse than that. 31:48 Of course, its PFS numbers kind of tend to change a little bit in the interim, and the fact that the stock's down, like, 12-odd percent, it's probably just a little bit of, um, disappointment with, uh, you know, the, the skinniness of, um, of that headline IRR. 32:01 Yeah. Albeit at spot prices, things are, are better, but, um, yeah, that, that'd probably be explained by the, by the numbers. Mm. 32:06 And then, well, I suppose then it's, it's 85% of the profits, but 6% of the revenue goes out the door. At, at the top line. That's for- That'd be baked into the PFS numbers. Oh, that. The royalty would be. 32:16 But if you think of the... Like they've, they've calculated capital, capital going out the door on a 100% basis- Yeah... and profit sort of coming in after, like, those cash flows. Yeah. 32:26 So- And they factor in the, the royalties. But if you think of it, think of the capital going out the door, that's 100% gotta be stumped up by Pred- Yeah... PDI, but they only get 85% of the profit. It's over there. 32:35 So when, when the, when you say 85% of the profit, is that profit calculated after the 6% of revenue and- 6% royalties... contribution goes- Yeah, yeah... goes out? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. 32:46 And, and a 15%, you know, equity stake for, for nothing. [laughs] Yeah. Well, they're laughing. This is what we need. 32:52 Water's, water's the other one [clears throat] that y- you look at with these studies to see if it's gonna bugger 'em over. They do say taking into account mine dewatering, they will remain net positive for water. 33:05 So it sounds like they've gotta pump the water out, recycle it, reuse it to remain net positive. Um, it looks like the joint needs some Get Wet bladders to lock in that net water positivity. Don't you reckon, JD? 33:19 I sure do, mate. Get Wet's going global. Oh, mate, aren't they? What? It'd be... Mate, uh, talk about an environmental tick of approval if that water's being stored instead of pissing it down the Niger River. 33:30 Uh, mate, I've... You know what I've even found out on the w- in a bit of weekend reading? These bladders apply to the coal seam gas plays over east too. Talk about environmentally saving the world. 33:41 After they frack the shit out of the seams with a gut load of water, that water has to go somewhere. Ah. Why not chuck it in a Get Wet bladder and keep all those bloody over east farmers happy? 33:53 That's actually a very good use case, mate. Mm. And he w- And another one. Live from Indonesia, Matty Hall, he's set up a Get Wet bladder to supply this massive fuck off ship with fresh water. 34:05 Uh, th- and this fresh water is used for pressure testing sea ba- seabed gas lines. Wow. Mate, Get Wet Solutions is currently out there saving the world all around the world. Wow. Un- unbelievable. 34:18 So how does, how does that work on the, on the ship? Well, they... No. He obviously stores it, then they, he... 34:22 'Cause a pumping system and piping system, which Get Wet installs as well as the bladder, pump it onto the ship, and then they use it for all their bloody pipe testing. Wow. 34:33 The bloody- From what I understand, they need, they need it to be reliable, they want it to run at the same pressure consistently, and the only one that can do that is Get Wet. Oh. So just give 'em a call. 34:42 Mate, the only, only company that does it in Australia. That's all you need to know. The things you find out on your weekend reading. Boys, let's touch on the financials, I guess, 34:52 and more in the realm of is Predictive a takeover target? What are you- Matty, we-... predicting for this? 34:59 [laughs] We're gonna get into my weekend reading as well, 'cause coincidentally, I was reading a fundy's quarterly report for the first quarter, and Predictive was mentioned in there. So I pulled it back up. 35:12 It's from Paragon Funds Management, and it was, it was a brief comment on a broader thematic of gold and copper. 35:17 But to, to what they said about Predictive, they just had in, in brackets, "5 million ounce plus takeover target amid a competitive M&A market." 35:26 So PDI being one of their holdings, and it's the same sort of rationale that quite a few other people have spoken about who hold the stock. 35:35 So you've got these rumors of it being a, a logical acquisition target for a number of West African or just more broadly African gold producers. 35:45 But like the, the likes of Perseus, Endeavor, B2 have been sort of thrown around. Matty, you touched on Anglo, who operate in the country beforehand. Nord Gold sort of- Nord Gold. Yeah. God, yeah. Yeah. 35:57 Right in the district, you'd think they'd be having a bloody look. Yeah. 36:00 So not all of these companies have obvious mining synergies, but they've, you know, a lot of them have a track record of operating in the area and understanding the, the regulatory profile and the timing that these things sort of take. 36:13 And of course, they often need a, a growth sort of story, which is, you know... 36:16 We've, we've spoken about it at length with, with Perseus, and they've obviously been attracted to Orcop, which they've almost wrapped up now. So-You know, we've gone through the details of Bankan there. 36:28 I think it's got some pretty attractive qualities, but when I th- when I read through it and I think about it, I continue to come to the, the same conclusion. 36:36 I, I compare PDI with a number of the other producing miners in the country, and obviously they're a slightly different proposition. 36:44 You've got one where you're kind of either hoping for a takeover and a premium, as well as potentially a, a rewrite if they get through construction, if that's what you're looking to hold it on for. 36:56 But with PDI, you know, if they don't get that, that takeover, you've got this permitting and construction risk that, that permitting, like you pointed to, Mattie, can't be underweighted. 37:06 It's pretty, it's pretty enormous, and then construction takes a while as well. So the numbers were pretty encouraging, but definitely not knockout. 37:15 You know, you needed to flash through almost spot gold price to make it look quite encouraging. 37:21 And then of course there's the, um, the ownership sort of regime that they have, plus the, the jurisdictional risk that you're, you're operating in there as well. 37:29 Throw in risk of capital escalation too, 'cause it was only PFS where you don't have... I mean, y- you know, PFS's tend to grow by 30% at least on top of that. And then reality- Absolutely... 37:39 tends to be 30% higher again. [laughs] Yeah, definitely. And then you, you compare that with a, a Perseus or a WAF who are trading on pretty cheap multiples. 37:48 And I'll, I'll chuck up a chart that I just did this morning with a, a bunch of West African as well as some Aussie just for reference, mid-cap gold miners. 37:56 And you can see the multiples and I'll, and I'll draw out a couple. You can see WAF there. Th- they're trading at 4.7 times the next year's earnings, and you might think, you know, that, that's pretty rich. 38:06 But that doesn't take into account Kiaka, which they're building and, you know, granted, if everything goes well, that'll come online by the end of next year, and that multiple will drop again. You've also got Resolute. 38:18 They've come out of a pretty rough period. They've recapitalized the business. Things are sort of on the up. They've had a bit of a, a rise in recent times on the back of the gold price and, and whatnot. 38:28 They're trading at 2.7 times. And of course Perseus, who like I said, they're, they're wrapping up Orecop. They're trading at 3.5 times EV to EBITDA. So, 38:40 you know, all in, I think these gold miners have a, a continual hunger for a growth story, and we've sort of fleshed out our, our rationale and our reasoning for why that might not always be the best case and why we think they in certain cases should actually buy back their own stock as opposed to just do M&A. 38:58 But I'm, I'm not sure if we're really gonna change how a lot of these mid-cap miners think. So I do still think Predictive is a target, especially if they, you know, get down to an attractive enough level. 39:10 But at the price they're at currently, with, as you point out, the, the risk of CapEx escalation and the timing and the permitting, you know, I w- I wouldn't be holding out for a, a takeover too soon. 39:22 I think it's-- I think the other thing too, JD, is it's, it's Guinea. Like, I just think, like, if in certain parts of Africa, the best strategy if you wanna be taken over is just sell to the highest Chinese bidder. 39:33 Like- Yeah. [laughs]... it's not about selling to the Perseus or WAF. It's, like, literally... Like, what happened to that, um, that one where Dundee had a bid? I think it was Os- Os- Os- Osmino. 39:42 It was, like, a Canadian miner and then this- Yeah... Chinese group came in. Um, I just think, like, these assets go to China, not, [laughs] not Western buyers anymore. 39:50 Yeah, I mean, we s- [laughs] Yeah, we saw with, with Cardinal in a, in a similar- Yeah... area as well. They got-- had a bidding war with the, between the Russian and, uh, Chinese group. Um- Tio's about to get gold... 40:00 the Russians won. Yeah. I mean, like, yeah. 40:04 Well, that's, that's- It's not, it's not, it's not a horrible strategy if you're a shareholder to just, like, you know, take the bid from Chi- from the Chinese as long as you, you cop a premium along the way. 40:11 But the valuation isn't like a, like you're gonna get a, um, a crazy return by buying it corporately at, at this point in time. So, you know, maybe, maybe it'll take some time before that potential offer comes. 40:23 Yeah, I mean, it's- James, it's unreal, your bloody Westgold and Silver Lake trading at three and 3.4 times. Bloody- Mm. Bloody five. At- Yeah... African levels. Uh- It is, mate. Right. Uh- All righty. 40:34 Let's- JD, take us to bloody potent territory, mate. How good's- Yeah, on-... Russia? On the, on the theme of these- Speak on all of that... certain countries. [laughs] So Russian metals have been banned from the LME. 40:47 Now this is on the back of sanctions that have come through by the US and the UK. But if you look at some of the price action, it's pretty interesting. We saw LME priced aluminum up about 10%. 40:58 That was their biggest jump for that metal since 1987. And nickel as well surged almost 9%. Now, you wouldn't really be able to tell that from the ASX nickel stocks today. They're just so beaten and battered up. 41:10 But on the aluminum or alumina front, you can see S32 is up to 3 bucks 44 now. So they're up 5% today. 41:19 And, uh, you've also got alumina up to a buck 58, so they're up over 5% today and they're up about 60% since we spoke about the Alcoa takeover. 41:29 So getting into, to what's actually happened here, like I said, the US and the UK have imposed these sanctions on Russian products. 41:36 Now, this obviously applies to all this Russian metal that comes in, and the date is as of last Friday. So not a total surprise. It'd been in the works for a little while. There is a catch though. 41:48 Old metal is still permitted, and the, the sort of split between new and old metal is as of what was produced before or after April 13th, so a few days ago now. 41:58 So apparently LME's still gonna take this old metal, but they're gonna sort of suss it out on a, on a case-by-case basis, and this has led to some speculation that a, a good wave of supply could still hit the market. 42:10 But overall, I think it's something pretty important to note because the, the London Metal Exchange, they, they facilitate the, the pricing for these metals. 42:20 And people have asked why this hadn't happened a, a couple years ago now, and that's because buyers were still happy to take Russian product, but now that that's been banned, the LME is just reflecting that ban that's come by the, um-The country, the country in which they operate. 42:35 So the ramifications are, are pretty interesting to think through. 42:39 The LME's often been the, the benchmark for metals pricing, and we've seen lots of people since we started the poddy criticizing the LME for numerous different reasons. 42:49 Nickel comes to mind in 2022 when there was that big debacle on the back of the short squeeze. Now, if you, you sort of compare the LME versus, say, 42:59 Shanghai and their metals exchange, the LME gets far more of its product from Russia, so it's, it's pretty meaningful. 91% of its aluminum comes from Russia, 62% of its copper- Wow... and 36% of its nickel. 43:13 So if you compare the LME aluminum price, which I said before, up 10%, with the Shanghai price, that was only up less than 3%. 43:20 So LME pricing isn't essentially the be all and end all, but heaps of contracts are still priced off it. And we spoke about l- uh, with Luke and Joel from, um, Wyloo a while ago now about payabilities. 43:34 Payabilities are obviously huge, but they're often still linked to the LME price ultimately. So 43:41 taking a step back, if you, if you th- look at what Russia produces in terms of metals, 6% of the world's nickel, 5% of the world's aluminum, and 4% of the world's copper is pretty bloody significant. 43:53 But it makes me think of what happened in the oil market when Russian oil was sanctioned and the follow-on implications. It didn't leave the world supply of oil. It just got rerouted. 44:04 So the global market just found another place for it to go, and the majority of the oil just went to India. So in this case, the ultimate outcome is that the metal is gonna go to China, 44:15 and, you know, that is the only place for the metal to go now. 44:18 And in terms of, you know, Aussies and Western countries, how we think about this, I think, like, quite a bit of thought needs to go into it because ultimately Russia, and therefore China, is just gonna get more power in terms of pricing the refined metal because even more of the metal now goes through the country. 44:37 So I think there's some pretty serious ramifications from this that will sort of be clear in, in time. What, what would they be, JD? What some of... What's an effect on the Western world in summary? 44:50 Well, w- w- we already talk about how much of the, the metal that we all need comes from Russia, and that, that... 44:59 You know, we, we speak literally every day about how we need to do something about that, and that's only gonna increase after this, you know? 45:07 Only more of the world's metal is now going through Russia, uh, China rather, because the Russian metal has nowhere else to go. 45:15 It used to go through the West, which gave the LME some, you know, significance in the pricing of these, these commodities, aluminum, nickel, zinc, copper, 45:25 and now more of that power sort of just falls in the hands of, of China. I mean, the, the West is essentially buying the, the vast majority of it straight from the Chinese now. So yeah, I mean, it's, 45:38 it's the same with the, the oil thing I just brought up before. 45:40 You think you, you ban the o- oil supply from Russia, but it just finds another way into the world market and it just gets rerouted to India, and the oil price for the rest of the world went up because it's a less efficient trading route. 45:54 'Cause I think if the, if you sanction Russia from taking their stuff, it's like you gotta know the stuff is elsewhere. Uranium's the interesting one that the US Senate bill still hasn't come through to sanction- Yeah... 46:08 that they're not gonna take uranium off Russia. But most of the world's enriched uranium comes out of Russia, so where are they gonna bloody get it from if they... Yeah, I don't know. 46:17 It's a, there's a lot to play out, JD, and you- Absolutely, mate... are gonna be the man that delivers it to us. Uh, bloody love your work. While you're on a frigging roll, mate, uh, Rio Tinto's Argyle, uh, blowout. 46:30 So that's a diamond mine, for those who don't know, that Rio shut in late 2020. What's going on there? That's right, mate. Yeah, the, the famous diamond mine. 46:39 There's a, there's a book on this mine behind, I think, Trav there- Yep... called Argyle that's a- Authored by Stuart Childs... pretty interesting read. Yeah, it's a, it's a fascinating read about the history. 46:48 This is the, the mine that produced almost all of the world's pink diamonds, so it's a, a pretty historical sort of mine. And like you say, Matty, closed up in 2020. 46:57 Their rehab liability has jumped from 580 million to over 850 million, so pretty- Just chuck it on top of-... pretty huge... um, ARI ARI, yeah. Piece of cake. Exactly. It's a thing. So an- another boot into them. 47:12 Now, this one is not one that they can sort of kick down the road. They've already spent a lot of it. They've already spent 300-odd million closing the, closing and rehabilitating the land all around it. 47:23 But the, the reasoning sort of stood out to me. It, it sounded awfully similar to a massive pre-production CapEx blowout. I'll give you some quotes. 47:31 "A result of general inflationary pressures, difficulty sourcing specialized labor and equipment, managing unforeseen issues relat- relating to the nearby lake." 47:40 So they expect that they can be finished with the closure and the rehabilitation by 2026. And, you know, it's a, it's a huge bill. 47:49 I'm kinda glad it's with a company like Rio that has the pockets to be able to do it, and they were the ones that reaped the rewards from the mine for a long time, so it's obviously their responsibility to do, and obviously a great opportunity for them, given their recent track record to, to do a rehab properly. 48:05 Mate, that's a great point, and I think, like, uh, you know, I hope we're in the, the era where the, the big miners just decide it's time to, to just, like, clean stuff up instead of kick the can down the road. 48:16 Like, for example, if, if Nickel West goes on care and maintenance, which, like, economically it probably should just go on care and maintenance, like, let's see BHP clean up Kanbrarda. 48:25 Like, don't kick the can down the road. Just clean it up. Yeah. Mate, I, I could not agree more, and I think the, um- It's like a, a zombie apocalypse town when they're not mining nickel there, isn't it? 48:34 Yeah, it's just- It's just all left there... this, like, this... Yeah. 48:37 Just clean it all upAnd the, the, the goodwill in the, across the mining industry as well would be, would be pretty huge if the, the miners can take responsibility for those ones. 48:46 And, you know, in comparison to the huge dividends and profits from their iron ore business, you know, it's a, it's a, it's a substantial cost, but it's definitely achievable, so let's hope they can do the right thing. 48:57 If they clean it up, they can't go back in there, but [laughs] Well, there's definitely no more diamonds there. Well, I'm sure they- No, I'm talking about Nickel and Gambalda... Nickel. It'll be back one day. Yeah. Yeah. 49:06 Uh, right. Speaking of, uh, Chinese ownership, you mentioned before Zhaojin goes best and final at Tietto, and they've bloody upped the bid, Trav. Mate, this is a JD story. 49:17 I'll tell you, everything's a JD story these days. Mate, you're on fire two hours ahead. All right. I'll, I'll fly through this one, lad. So we spoke about it a long time ago now. 49:26 Late October is when Zhaojin came in with their first bid, and it was in a period where the, the company was in a real lull. 49:33 They'd been disappointing the market with announcement after announcements, just struggling to ramp up, struggling to get the, the production right at Abelja. 49:42 It wa- it was a lot higher than they were down to like 28, 29 cents, and then they had a point of recovery. Yeah, they, they ticked up. Yeah. Exactly. 49:50 So they, they ticked up a bit, and at the time Zhaojin were 7% shareholders, now they're 7.7% shareholders. The initial bid was for 58 cents all in cash, and Tietto was, like you say, Matty, they ticked up. 50:02 They were at about 40 cents roughly at the time. Tietto stock subsequently jumped to around about the bid price, and that's the level they sort of traded for the last six months. 50:12 They've recently closed at 465 cents on the back of the, uh, sort of positive news around gold. 50:19 At the time, Tietto's board recommended that shareholders reject the offer on the grounds that it was undervaluing the company and being highly conditional. 50:29 To address this, Zhaojin have come out today, and they've upped the bid to 68 cents all in cash, so that's a 17% lift from their previous bid and a 67% premium to the undisturbed VWAP. 50:43 And they've also removed the, uh, the bid condition, simplifying the process. 50:47 So they've received the Chinese approvals, and they said they're confident enough that they're gonna receive the, the local approvals in the country there. 50:55 So Zhaojin continued to point to Tietto continuously disappointing the market. You know, they, they pointed to, um, bad production ramp-up, the uneven, um, number of ounces year over year being produced. 51:09 And Tietto in defending themself said, "We've improved gold production, improved mining rates, costs are within guidance, and cash generation has been pretty good." 51:20 And then they get this independent expert's report, which they were pretty proud of. 51:23 They get to show to shareholders that the independent expert has valued them at 79 cents to 92 cents, in between that range, and that's using 1,650 US gold and 1,730 US gold. So 51:38 that was materially above the initial bid and where the stock was trading. And then you've also got Tietto's two largest shareholders, who account for 18.7% of the stock, indicating that they're gonna reject the offer. 51:51 Add to that the board, who hold about 3% of the stock. If they can keep those on side with this updated bid, they just need to win over a couple more instos, and they should be able to knock back the, the offer. 52:04 But it remains to be seen. What those two shareholders think is obviously pretty important. Well, the, the, the interesting thing is it's, it's best and final, right? So it's not like you're gonna- Yeah... 52:12 get an uplift from this party. So the decision for the board is, um, "Do we, do we take this on the table because we don't actually don't think there's anyone else that would buy it at, at, at that price? 52:23 Or do we, um, do we continue to reject it because it's, it's undervaluing what we think we've got?" That'll be what f- what un- unfolds here. And, um, I mean, they're... 52:31 Like, the stock's trading less than that 65 cents, so I think it's like- Yeah... 62 or something. So the, the, the market's- Trading at 66 now, yeah. Is it 66 now? So it's above. Or 60- 65 and a half. Gotcha. 52:43 So the market's kind of pricing in, um, potential- Well, the, the bid was 68, so- Yeah. Okay... you know, in and around there, it's, um- Yeah. Okay. 52:52 So if it, if it's, if it's less than 68, then it's not exactly pricing in a, um, a higher bid at this point in time. TBA what the board come out and, uh, and recommend to shareholders. 53:01 I think a lot of that just hinges on those major Chinese shareholders, to be honest. Absolutely. Lovely. Trav, bit of a rapid fire to finish off, mate. Update on Sierra Rutile for me, char. 53:12 The fumble in the jungle, Matty. 53:13 Uh, admittedly, uh, I, I think I was pretty harsh in the, in the assessment of Sierra Rutile's board in, in early coverage, and I actually, I actually now think they've been pretty strong in their defense of the hostile bid from PRM. 53:23 In the supplementary target statement, uh, uploaded today, they explicitly state they'll explore selling growth project Sembehun. 53:29 Um, the way to interpret the $400 million NPV that came out on Friday for that project, that's not what Sembehun is worth to Sierra Rutile. 53:36 They'd have a much more onerous tax regime, um, than they assume in that DFS because they assume they'd get the, uh, the same regime as Area 1, which would not apply to Sembehun. 53:45 So but that's what Sembehun could be worth to a hostile bidder, PRM, who are pretty cozy with the government of Sierra Leone. So to me, it's pretty clear what the board's doing. 53:52 I think they're edging for an appropriate uplift from the c- you know, from the current offer on the table from PRM. The 9.5 cent offer doesn't cut the mustard, but would 15 cents, 16, 17, 18? 54:02 Like, that's probably where the board would be amenable to recommend a deal. If Sembehun is worth 400 million bucks to PRM, they're still getting a bargain even at a decent uplift in price. 54:11 The big unknown, though, is Sierra Rutile really in a position of strength to negotiate? Is there really any other buyer for this asset, um, if they ran a sale process? I'll be watching with popcorn. Oh. 54:21 And Gallan's at the market facility. I think it's Gallan. Gallan. Gallan. Gallan. Yeah. Slipped in late Friday, mate. There's a $15 million, uh, ATM facility to Acuity Capital. 54:31 Historically, you know, the announcement of these types of raisings have been marred with share price belting. Um, and to top things off- We love these ATMs... 54:38 yeah, they went in, they went to a halt this morning pending a, um, a permitting update, which, I don't know, it just doesn't... You know, I don't, don't get a good feeling about that one. 54:46 Oh, the ATM, you think of Hastings. [laughs] There's been a bunch. [laughs] Emerald. Emerald guys finally go- Like, talk about the longest takeover in history. Yep. Emerald guys' best and final for Bullseye. Yep. 54:57 Let's hope the world's longest takeover finally wraps up as a result- [laughs]... and we see, uh, Emerald in the Laverton region. Right-o. We've gotta go. We've got a call. 55:03 Mate, thanks to the bloody partners at the top of the show, Get Wet Solutions and bloody Silverstone, 'cause they can just do everything. 55:12 Mate, we've also got Verified, DSI Underground, Anytime Exploration Services, WA Water Boards, Brooks Airways, and our great friends at K-Drill. Hooteroot. Hooteroot. Hooteroot. 55:25 Information contained in this episode of Money of Mine is of general nature only and does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular person. 55:34 Before making any investment decision, you should consult with your financial advisor and consider how appropriate the advice is to your objectives, financial situation, and needs.