Transcript 0:00 Metal market bifurcation. This is a radical shift from where mining and commodity production has been historically. I believe now the, the various sort of macro conditions and geopolitical conditions are right 0:17 to be actually executing on metal market bifurcation, getting paid appropriately for the standard at which you produce. [upbeat music] Right, good day, Money Miners. 0:30 Monday, 16th of October, and a much demanded man is back on the Money of Mine show. 0:39 He's- Not physically with, with us right now, Trav, but, uh- He, he's been one of the most requested people to come, probably the most requested to come back on the podcast. People loved his first appearance. 0:50 It was punchy. Yeah. It was a topic that no one talks about, and he delivered it in a very compelling way. We're talking, of course, about Mr. Rusty Delroy. Russell Rusty Delroy. [laughs] Founder and, uh, what is he? 1:03 Chief investment... Is, he call himself chief investment officer? No, I, I can't remember his title, but, uh- He's the b- 'Cause, 'cause D- Dingo's CEO. Dingo's CEO. But- But Rusty's-... 1:13 Rusty, he must be chair or something there... executive. Let's say he's executive [laughs] chair, chief investment officer. 1:19 [laughs] Keys to the gates of the Nero Resource Fund, a spec- a special boutique resource fund based here in, uh, in Perth. Yeah. And, uh, as I said in the pre, go listen back to our first episode with him. 1:31 Mate, he's absolutely s- smashed the returns in previous years, 500% over bloody- Oh, it's 25% compounded over, over a decade... 25% compounded over a decade. Yeah. So, uh, yeah, very, very impressive. 1:44 So an absolute GC of the industry too. Big time. Now, uh, you would've got a little prelude in the in- in the intro about what this is about. We're just gonna get right into it. Big, big topic that, uh, 1:57 w- we've split it up into two parts. And you don't have to give much away 'cause it's Rusty, so you just listen to any episode with Rusty. That's the golden rule of Money and Mine. If Rusty's on, you listen to it. 2:09 [laughs] That's all we need to know. [laughs] We're gonna get right into it. So two parts. Part one, obviously. We're not Pulp Fiction. [laughs] But, uh, we're starting on part one. 2:17 So part two's gonna come out in a couple of days. Now, Trav- I'm excited, mate... sponsors for the, today, and, oh, quite pertinent to the, the electrical revolution we're seeing. Ooh. 2:27 Smec Power and Technology, Marty Lore and the team at the forefront of old electricity- [laughs]... and new electricity. Mate, if you want a bloody, a blue electrical box or a substation or anything underground- Yeah... 2:39 for your diesel-fired power station to power, y- he can service that part of the industry. But he can also serve the greener methods of variable speed vent drives. Like it. Vent on demand, power saving. 2:54 Mate, he caters for the new and the old, everything electrical. You couldn't beat their, um, very organic ad slip that we slipped into the podcast in a pit. We didn't even bloody plan that one. 3:04 They just started talking about Smec, and before you know it- Organic advertisement- There's the ad... from managing directors. 3:09 But that just goes to show you how, um, how much, you know, the, the, the real bloody intellectual capability of Marty and the team there to create genuine cost savings for Westgold that it just come up in bloody conversation without, [laughs] without realizing really. 3:23 Pleasure doing business with Smec. It's a good one, Marty. No, no. Keep saving costs everywhere, and, like, it's bloody good for the environment in the process. 3:29 Hey, when you've got a company that's nearly worth a billion dollars sproken about how instrumental that Smec have been in their business, mate, our, our work is done here, Trav. 3:39 [laughs] Get a hold of them, Marty Lore and Smec. Give them a ring. Every... You know, and you know what every sponsor says, "Oh, mate, we're getting heaps of comments. No one's rang us yet." [laughs] So ring them up. 3:49 Just ring them up. So ring it up 'cause they'll listen to Money and Mine. Just for a yarn. Marty loves to chat. [laughs] Or go to his Friday barbie. Righto, Trav, let's get into our chat with Rusty. Uh, mate, ripper. 4:00 Part one, here we go. Righto, Money Miners, talk about, talk about going back in a bit of history where, uh... Where, what's this joint called, JD? You'd know. You're gonna- Crow Bridge Gallery... 4:13 own it in bloody 30 years. [laughs] JD's in the wheel. We're in his bloody father, at his father-in-law's, uh, what would you call it? Bit of a gallery, museumy. You make everything you need. Sure is, mate. 4:24 It's a beautiful setup for this one. Quite, quite pertinent too, JD, because the history around us is gonna feed into the history that we are about to hear about from the infamous and enigmatic Russell Delroy. 4:39 [clears throat] Rusty from the Nero Resource Fund, the main man. Rusty, great to have you back on. Well- Thank you... well received, your, uh, first episode, mate. 4:49 [clears throat] Uh, we absolutely loved it, so did the Money Miners. Good to hear, Matty. Thank you, mate. Um, awesome to be back, particularly in, in, in this place. This is unreal. 4:59 Well, it's- You guys are really lifting the bar. And, and- Production, you know. We're 1% better every day, hey? Yeah. And we always said once we get- Continuous improvement... 5:07 once we got Rusty's first one out of the road, and as you said, it was your first and we needed to be gentle. Yeah. [laughs] But, uh, look, you've just come back next weekend for a bit more. 5:15 Am I expecting violence this time? [laughs] Mate, Rusty, uh, this is a very broad, broad episode that we're going into, I'd say. But I... Maybe you can surmise for the Money Miners- Yeah... 5:27 what we're about to tackle in this chat. For sure. Um, I'll say off the bat, I will get a lot of stuff wrong. So this is a bit of, um, I think a bit of- You'll fit in well, mate. Yeah. [laughs] All good. 5:40 [laughs] It's my job not to be, but, uh, but I continually do it. [laughs] Sorry, mate. 5:47 So, uh, yeah, first up, the, uh, I think the, the topic we're gonna talk about is, is, you know, there's a, there's an, a element here of where are we at, and then there's a big element of where are we going. 5:58 And the, and so there's a lot of crystal balling around all of that. 6:02 But the, um, yeah, the, the topic of conversation, which I think is, um-Yeah, a really big one in our sector and, and, and unfortunately a bit overlooked, and it's around, uh, metal market bifurcation. 6:15 And, um, what is that? That's a kind of fancy way of saying- It's something that everyone's been saying, but no one knows when it's happening r- and really what it is. Yep. 6:24 And we hopefully, uh, we're hopefully gonna enlighten people today. Well- Do you, do you know? [laughs] Not really. [laughs] So, I, I feel like this is, 6:37 this is a radical shift from, um, where, where mining and commodity production has been historically. So I, I, I think 6:47 there's probably been lots of people over the course of history who have thought about this and thought it made sense, and then it never gets off the ground. 6:56 Um, and what I would say is that I believe now the, the various sort of macro conditions, if you like, and geopolitical conditions are right to be actually executing on metal market bifurcation. 7:14 And, and what does that mean? It really just means, um, getting paid appropriately for the standard at which you produce something. And 7:27 that bizarrely, um, is something mining companies have never seemed to really advocate. I think they've probably tried around the fringes, and there's bits and pieces of it, but yeah. 7:37 So Bellevue aren't completely full of shit when they talk about growing gold. Bellevue are definitely not full of shit. 7:43 [laughs] Um, I, uh, I, I suspect, uh, Bellevue, as far as I'm aware, are, are going to be the lowest carbon gold producer on the market, or that's certainly the, the intent. 7:54 I suspect we'll see groups eventually go to zero carbon gold and zero carb- I, I think we'll see a lot more in this direction around particularly decarb, 8:07 but as well as that other, um, you know, I think it all gets thrown in this, you know, ESG basket. But I, I think we're gonna see, 8:16 um, better, increased scrutiny certainly from capital, um, which is what everyone listens to ultimately. And then, and then hopefully we're gonna see, um, 8:30 government and industry working together to make sure that you get paid for that. There's-- You can't... 8:38 Anyway, we, we'll, I think we'll jump into- Well, I think, I think before we, before we get right into it, I think for the money miners that don't, haven't, maybe haven't heard or don't understand what price bi-bifurcation is or what it may be is the example that Bellevue with this low carbon intensive gold that they will produce due to their solar, their renewables on site and things like that, they will potentially be able to get paid more for that by someone because it is a low carbon produced gold. 9:08 That's right. 9:09 So- And then, and for nickel, w- it would be a, a class one nickel sulfide producer in Australia will possibly get paid more for that nickel to go into a battery than a high carbon intensive Indonesian or Philippines nickel producer producing nickel laterite. 9:26 Yeah. Does that, is that pretty much sum it up- That's, that's-...Rusty? That's a really good suite of examples. Yep. So, so wait, I'm just gonna sit here and drink and vape now. [laughs] It's all done with that. 9:34 [laughs] Are vapes legal? Are they? Underground next year. Yet? You know they're banning vapes and smoking underground next year. So mate, oh, I've got out in the r- at the right time. 9:45 I thought we were going the other way with drugs, but anyway. [laughs] Um, no, that's, uh, that's another topic. [laughs] Rusty- That's, that's the Money Miners OnlyFans channel. [laughs] That sort of stuff. 9:55 I'll, um, I'll leave you in, Rusty. I mean, we find ourselves talking about mining companies every, oh, day on our podcast, and we're like laser focused on two things. Mm-hmm. 10:07 How much do they produce, and how much did it cost them- Mm...to produce it? Mm. And why are we so focused on production and costs? 10:14 It's because, like, we assume miners have no influence on the price that they're gonna get for the metal they produce. They're price takers, right? Yep. 10:22 So in this conversation, I think we're gonna momentarily challenge this assumption- Yep...over the course of the next hour or so. 10:29 We're gonna explore the global factors at play that may justify dispersion in metal prices- Mm-hmm...based on the location and manner in which they're produced. If that seems a bit crazy, 10:43 none better than the crazy Rusty Galroy to unpack it with us. [laughs] Okay. So we're, we're pretty stoked that you're here with us, mate. Cool. Thank you, boys. 10:50 He went through, he went through a strict, um, there was a strict bidding process, strict review of who was gonna deliver this chat. [laughs] But Rusty passed all the filter tests. 11:00 Hopefully we precipitate some, some thought and, and some conversation and, um, we can then get really, you know, way smarter people than me on to, to break down some of the, the subset, um, pieces to this. 11:15 'Cause there's a lot on it, and, um, yeah, pumped to get into it. I think just on that comment you made around commodities, it's a... And, and the two things you focus on when you're looking at companies, right? 11:28 It's, that's what's, um, always been perceived as that's what's controllable for a, a mining company or a pr- any producer of commodities, agriculture, anything. 11:39 You know, you produ- By definition, commodity is, is homogenous, and so therefore I'm a price taker. That's all out of my control. I can simply control volume and cost, um, and hopefully volume up, cost down. 11:56 So [clears throat] that's the landscape in which all commodity producers have just been bred in and, um, and understandably, right? 12:06 That's, that's just how things have been, and particularly in a globalized world, um, that's only become truer.Uh, what, what, what has never really been focused upon bizarrely is the revenue line. 12:20 And if you look at, um, uh, guys like, like Buffett and the like of, 12:26 you know, I don't think they even invest in commodities [chuckles] because they invest in pipelines, like things that service commodity producers, but they generally don't like commodity producers because of that price taking element and the lack of moat and all those sorts of things. 12:41 And, and if you look at an Apple, for example, I mean, they produce a phone. There's lots of phone producers out there, but they're, they're not the same as an Apple phone. And you can't build in brand 12:53 like Apple does, um, perhaps in commo- in commodities is the, is the concept. So or, or been the historical sort of position. 13:01 So I think there's this natural place of saying, "We produce something, it goes on in exchange, it's ubiquitous, it's homogenous, everybody has the same playing field, and therefore I just take price." 13:13 And I think we're entering a world, hopefully, where the commodity producers actually wake up and say, "Why the fuck am I accepting the same price for something done the right way 13:26 as a guy or a girl or whomever producing something perhaps the wrong way, cutting corners, um, you know, uh, degrading environments? Why am I, why am I accepting the same price for that? 13:40 And why is the consumer saying-- paying the same price for that? Why is the government okay with that?" There's a range of, um, uh, stakeholders in this process that all need to coordinate, and at the moment they don't. 13:54 Is there, is there, has there been any examples in history in mining where there has been price making, like maybe the early spodumene concentrate sales from Pilbara, sort of chucking it up for auction? Yeah. 14:05 Or is that... Yeah. Is that an example of sort of what you're talking about and what price making versus price taking should look like? Yeah. The, uh- 14:16 Or is this more, it's more focused on the ES-- if they're doing it in a responsible-- ESG responsible way, they should be getting paid a higher price for it. Yeah. So when you're trying to, 14:27 um, differentiate a product like, like a, like a commodity, um, y- I think what you're talking about there is there have been things around the fringes. So, so-- and that relates to spec. 14:40 So, so there's two components to this. One is spec and one is providence. And I think historically, yes, there has been plenty of stuff around the fringes on spec. 14:49 So if you look at, um, you know, let's take lith for an example, uh, maybe not SC6. Let's talk about, um, finished lithium. So, so what I think what the industry likes to throw around is battery-grade lithium. 15:03 There's very-- there's different pricing. You know, if you really hit high spec, if you push through, 15:08 um, to the lowest level of impurities on certain measures, then yeah, you're gonna get a, a bit of a premium product versus the ninety-nine point fives. And I think the best example of that would be Orocobre. 15:18 I'm sure you guys remember the journey there before the lithium market went crazy, and it didn't matter. Before then, you know, they really struggled for, um, full price participation because they could never meet... 15:31 They were, they were sort of hitting that ninety-nine point five, not ninety-nine point nine and, and the like. So I think historically there has always been differentiation in pricing on spec, 15:42 and that, that persists today. But where I think things need to be far more focused is on providence, and that's like understanding how and where something was produced. 15:55 And this is a very complicated issue, and there are a lot of vested interests who do not wanna see this happen. 16:03 Um, and if you break the industry apart and you look at just how influential metal traders and the like groups like Glencore and Trafigura, um, who are great guys, by the way. Um, [laughs] no. 16:17 But you know, it's, it's not in their interest to see this. They, they, they operate, you know, um, um, you need product, you make product. You guys just talk to me and I'll make sure everybody gets what they need. 16:30 Um, that, that middleman black hole, um, it works for them that there's not transparency and, and the like. So, uh, providence is something that I think a lot of vested interests have never wanted to see. 16:46 Um, and, and you know, shuffling of commodities out of places that they're not supposed to come from is an age-old tradition in commodity markets [chuckles]. 16:56 And you only need to look at, you know, Russia and Iran, and it's still going on today, right? So without question. So providence is something that hasn't been well fought for by the mining companies. 17:08 I dare say there's been a lot of vested interests that have fought against it. But it is absolutely essential that it, that it, um, that it evolves for a variety of reasons. 17:20 But most importantly, you need to have a price signal to bring on product from the right places. And what does that mean? It means 17:32 we all-- I mean, you know, I think the community by and large has a really negative perception of mining and in, you know, in general in first world jurisdictions. And, and I would say probably 17:44 somewhat fairly in the sense that the industry... Yeah, I think it gets a little bit unfairly targeted. I mean, there's a small footprint relative to agriculture and the like. 17:53 If you actually look at the ecological footprint, it's very small. But when things go wrong, they can go really wrong. 17:58 And, and when it impacts water tables and the like, and you look at Ok Tedi and some of the things like that have gone on, you go, "Fuck, fair enough. No wonder people get upset." 18:06 The industry has allowed itself to constantly have this race to the bottom on cost because it can't control rev line-Right? 18:17 They can't control the revenue, can't tr-control the price, they can't influence the price as their perception so it's just this constant focus on cost. 18:24 And when you do that, invariably you cut corners and, and managing things, you know, to an environmental standard 18:34 whether it's decarbonization, whether it's, um, a mine site r-rehabilitation, sequential land use, these sorts of things, they all cost money. Um, and so, y-you know, if you're in a tight... 18:49 If you're constantly competing with others who maybe don't do it, so let's say, [lips smack] 18:53 ah, let's say you have a nickel mine here in Australia, and then you also refine that nickel all the way through to finished product and that's all done at certain standards. 19:04 How on earth are you gonna compete with, you know, a, a- Norilsk or something like that in- Well, yeah, exactly. Yeah. 19:10 The guys in the back of Russia doing whatever they want and then, and then punching- Who knows what they're doing? [laughs] Well, yeah, exactly. Something cool. Uh, no, but so- no, it's probably something very bad. 19:19 And, and, um, and, and the same in, you know, Africa and these sorts of jurisdictions. There isn't the same environmental scrutiny. 19:27 And then, you know, that product getting processed in China, um, as well to, to way lower environmental standards than we can do here. And this is very complicated, but we need to have 19:43 the, the price for the product encouraging higher standards. So it, it needs to be there, and if it isn't, then we're going to continually race to the bottom on, on environmental standards. 19:56 I think there's so, so many directions we can go. One question I want to ask you, Rusty, is around metals processing. So the, uh, the jurisdictions in which the metals come from is a sort of even mix. 20:08 We know a lot comes from Australia and a lot comes from Western countries, as well as the likes of Africa, Europe, South America. But the processing for almost every metal in the world is dominated by China. Yep. 20:21 And that-that's no secret. What do you think needs to be done for that to change? I think nickel is a great example you touched on, and we saw what's happening in Indonesia, and that was through government incentives. 20:32 They pretty much said- Yep... this has to be produced here. You're not taking it elsewhere. Exactly. So- Bang, you got eight H power plants. Yeah. [laughs] Like, that's how quick it is. It was pretty effective. Yeah. 20:41 [laughs] Yeah. It was incredibly... Like there's- Yeah... so many examples of government initiatives that would have not worked anywhere near as successfully as that. 20:48 So it worked remarkably successfully, but, uh, you know, I wouldn't bet that government initiatives are always gonna work so successfully. But do you think that's what it sort of takes? Yeah. 20:57 So [clears throat] there are, there are a lot of components to this. There's action required from 21:04 the miners to advocate for, um, scrutiny of supply chains, um, and, and other mechanisms to get the price signal, whether or not you get paid a premium or you just cut out unethical or, uh, you know, n-n-non-uh, environmentally compliant material from the supplier. 21:23 There's a variety of mechanisms, but first of all, the miners need to get the pricing happening. Government needs to play a role in that, in scrutinizing these things. Um, and then realistically, if we want to have 21:39 finished product in f- you know, in raw materials, then yes, then the downstream has to have, um, proper screening. And, and I, I don't think there's a world in which you can expect to do that out of China. 21:56 Not at the moment anyway. That doesn't mean the Chinese can't do it elsewhere. So downstream requires... 22:04 Yeah, I, I think there's a, there's a strong push for, again, a variety of reasons, geopolitical, um, being the, the biggest one, geostrategic, 22:12 around reshoring, and that reshoring will go hand in glove with ESG and decarbonization. 22:20 So it'll be bringing home downstream processing, doing it to a really high standard, in fact, the current standard and better, and particularly decarb, and it's gonna cost a lot more money. 22:33 And that's the scary part and the big challenge and. 22:36 As an example, I think you guys will have seen like in the lith sector, I think Albemarle came out not that long ago and, and said, you know, the equivalent, and I think maybe Mintz as well, the equivalent, um, processing plant in the US 22:52 was three X the, the CapEx of the plant in, in China. And, and then, and then OpEx will be, um, no doubt a multiple of that too. So- And the Chinese one's always on time too. Oh. Usually the- So-... 23:07 same as the Indonesians H power plants. Yeah. And, and I think this is really important to get into. 23:12 F-first of all, there's this, uh, I think an understanding that, hey, geostrategically, we are way too entwined and dependent on China. 23:19 If you go to a, a, a, a war footing or a proxy war footing, as is the case with Russia, then if you go to either of those with China, it is-- there is no way we can... 23:31 Y-you know, the, the, um, uh, commercial sort of, um, constraints we put, we can't do that. We're so dependent. There's so much product going through. It's not just manufacturing. 23:42 It's, it's all the way through that chain, particularly around processing. So there's an awareness. We need to decouple. That means friendly jurisdictions and bringing it home. 23:54 Um, [clears throat] and so that's all well and good and, and it's, it-- I agree with all of that. It's very important to do it, but there's an enormous cost. And it... 24:04 What we failed, I think, really introspectively recognize is w-we've spent thirty or forty years moving this stuff. 24:14 We've, I think, collectively, as a f- as, you know, the West or the First World, has really told itself, "Oh, remember all that filthy stuff that used to be? 24:21 And we've really cleaned all that up, and here's this oldGerman industrial site and now it's this wonderful new, um, residential precinct and, you know, great stuff. Awesome. 24:33 Those things weren't done better, they were just done elsewhere. And so we've shifted that, right? And it's all got, you know, textiles to India, um, metal processing, um, to China predominantly. 24:49 That's created a whole set of risks. We've kidded ourselves that we're doing things better. It's really just taken that env- you know, the externality or the environmental cost and just parked it somewhere else. 25:05 Um, and then we're sort of now saying, "Hey, there's a risk to that." I don't think that the environmental drivers unfortunately are the reason for the, for the concern. It's the geostrategic, 25:19 um, issues that are the most pertinent. There's a recognition of that, but then there's an assumption that we're just gonna bring that home. It-- These guys haven't... 25:27 You know, I think China gets a narrative around copying and it, you know, they, they do things cheap and nasty and they don't-- I think that's fucking bullshit. They, they're way past that. 25:37 Maybe a decade or so ago, sure, but that's fucking bullshit today. These guys are innovative. They are dominating mineral processing. They are so far past where we were when we handed it over to them. We have no idea. 25:50 Not only do we not, um, have, you know, the, the cap- like the competitiveness on cost, we don't even really know how to do a lot of this downstream. [laughs] Well, I think look, look at the examples. 26:02 You got the Tianqi RGO downstream, but I don't think that's performed too well. You've got BH- BHP's downstream nickel refinery in Canada. I don't think that's performed, nickel sulfate plant, that hasn't performed well. 26:15 Well, and I think- It's not, they're not executing yet. No. I don't think. I mean, and we've just scratched the surface, right? Yeah. Like we're just starting- Early days... 26:21 an enormous process to try and reshore this stuff. And the Chinese I think have already made a lot of noise around, "Well, maybe we're gonna constrain some of our IP." 26:33 Um, and so there's this irony, there's this perception that the Chinese just steal all our IP. And they did that. That's, that's true. They did it, but they've, they're way past that point. Yeah. 26:41 And w- ironically, we are now gonna need to steal their IP. [laughs] Like we are. We- I think battery tech is the, the best example. BYD and CATL between them, over 50% of all EVs. 26:54 So that is Tesla- So they're, they're China's EV manufacturers, are they, Jada? Yeah. CATL are the battery manufacturer. Yeah. BYD make EVs as well as batteries. Yeah. 27:03 They make over 50% of the world's EVs now, and that's to the likes of Volkswagen, BMW, Ford, Tesla, all these groups. So they're just so far ahead. 27:14 Even the CEO of BMW said not too long ago like, "I don't think we could catch them if we wanted to." Are BYD, are they in- like selling into America? So there's BYDs driving next to Teslas? 27:25 Well, that, that is a really interesting part of the debate, 'cause selling into America for a Chinese manufacturer has a 27.5% tariff on top of the IRA, which I'm sure we'll talk about, an added benefit- Mm... 27:37 for the US manufacturers. So that, that's a pretty insurmountable wall. There's no Chinese cars going that way. If it were a lev- if it were a level playing field, I'm sure you'd see much more market presence. 27:47 Same standpoint. So where, where's most of their market? Is it go- Is it mostly China that are- No, well-... driving these BYDs? B-Y... Well, the Chinese are, I think are, are about to become the... 27:56 Well, I think about, well, b- sorry. BYD is about to become the world's largest- Yeah... um, uh- Car maker... producer of EVs. Yeah. China has already become the world's largest exporter of automotives. Yeah. 28:09 And you would never know that sitting here in Australia. Yeah. You would never know that sitting in the US. You're about to fucking know it sitting in Europe. Yeah. They are coming. They're coming big. 28:19 And I think, um, Gav Cow did a, a, a great piece recently, uh, comparing like a, a, you know, a, a spec, spec comparison vehicle. So i.e., you know, same m- mileage and, and, and, and whatever the key- Yeah... 28:34 measures of specification in an auto are, between a Chinese vehicle, I, I think it was BYD, and an equivalent vehicle out of a European manufacturer. 28:45 The Chinese number I think was about €35,000, and the equivalent vehicle in Europe was about €55,000. That is enormous. That is not fractionally or a slightly or a bit uncompetitive. That is fucking miles off. Yeah. 29:00 You are gone. 29:01 There is no way the consumer is ever going to be disciplined enough to turn around and go, "Oh, I don't know about that Chinese thing that does exactly what I need for nearly half the cost of the, the local one." 29:16 I would love to think that's the case, but nine out of 10 consumers aren't, aren't gonna care. Well, I do, I didn't know. 29:22 I think I've, I think I heard this right on a podcast or something, but, uh, I don't think cars make, the manufacturers make that much money. It's like some of the... It was like a 50 grand car makes five grand. 29:33 So- Like they're not doubling their, it's- The CEO of Ford spoke about this not too long ago, and he said, "Now our biggest, you know, concern is Chinese. That's no longer Toyota or GM or any of them." 29:44 They're targeting an 8% profit margin- 8%... on their electric vehicles. And yeah, I mean, for the, EVs gone from China to Europe, that's a 10% tariff. So they can climb that, that sort of 35 to €55,000 wall. 29:59 The European Union, like Ursula von der Leyen, they're getting really concerned about this. The car making, like, industry in Europe is a $650 billion industry. It employs, I think, 13 million people. 30:13 It is a huge concern for them. So maybe you can see them really competing on luxury because that takes a long time to chip away at a Porsche, a Ferrari. Yeah. 30:24 But for the cars that the everyday person needs to drive, it's a, it's a big, big concern. Yeah. 30:29 Again, Gav Cow did a great piece on this talking about, um, you know, French being-French automotives and the French government being far more sensitive to this. 30:38 The German automotives and government being a little bit less sensitive because- Because the Germans sell to the Chinese. That's right. Yeah. 30:44 So the Germans are about 50/50 because it's a premium product, they export a lot of it. Their current position is, "Oh, well, our, you know, our brand..." There is a moat with their product, right? Yeah. 30:54 Like we were talking about earlier. There is a, a brand and a premium applied to, you know, a Porsche or, or a Ferrari or... Well, that's not a German one, but you know- Yeah... you get the picture. 31:04 The French typically produce middle-of-the-range vehicles, Peugeot, for example, and they don't export them to China. And so there's-- the French are, are very big on wanting to protect those markets. 31:19 The Germans are a little bit more reluctant because they're worried about, um, protectionism that might flow back to them from Chi- from the Chinese market that they're, they're, you know, heavily involved in. 31:32 So there's complication here around the politics. The... You know, when we sort of link this back to the start of the conversation, metal market bifurcation, well, this is the tip of the spear. The EV industry 31:45 is the, is the sort of most 31:48 pertinent issue and to-- for exactly the reason you just pointed out because there is so much at stake in existing industry in jurisdictions like the EU and, and North America and, and, and, you know, Germany with, I think it's 10 to 12% of GDP being directly and indirectly out of the auto industry. 32:08 So it's a here-and-now issue, not a fucking, "Oh, down the line," or, you know, just environmental outcomes or even the geostrategic stuff. You know, you can always sort of say, "Oh, that's a little bit away." 32:19 No, no, it is like right here, right now, we are about to be fucking [chuckles] radically uncompetitive. And so, yeah, it's the tip of the spear. It's the f- I think it's very instructive as to what's happening there 32:34 for the broader metals and mining industry and processing and, and the like. 32:38 There's a lot of implications for iron ore and steel and, you know, all sorts of commodities and, um, and I think it's, it's important that we really, really pay attention to what's going on because I think what we're gonna see, uh, is, is carrot and stick. 32:55 We're gonna see protectionism, we're gonna see subsidization, all sorts of things around that, and that's gonna be instructive then to how that rolls out into other commodities and, um, you know, yes, I think the best example is the IRA right at the minute that's in place. 33:10 There's an incentive or a subsidy tied to providence of the raw material. Mm. That drags us back to where we started, providence of the raw material. And so suddenly- Foreign entities of concern. Correct. 33:23 Foreign entities. Yeah, exactly. So what does that mean? It means it bifurcates. Suddenly there are two markets for that material. There is the compliant market and the non-compliant market. 33:33 There's the, there's the product that gets you a subsidy and the product that doesn't. So what are, what are the main areas around the world that fall into that non-subsidy, the bad ones, the red, the red flag ones? 33:46 Uh- Like obviously cobalt coming out of Congo is, I assume, one example. Oh, yeah. So I think you start, start with autos and EVs. Look at the, um, minerals that go into the batteries. 34:02 That's, I mean, that's not rocket science for me to point that out. [chuckles] Um, the key minerals being lithium, cobalt, nickel, uh, manganese playing an important role as well. 34:15 Um, but they're the, they're the main ones and yeah, I mean, in terms of you then go to, okay, they're the, they're the materials. You then go to, well, what does that supply chain look like? 34:24 So where is the raw material, um, extracted? Then where is it sent and processed? Um, and, uh, you know, I th- I think of all of those, uh, cobalt is the most pertinent. 34:39 You know, in terms of concentration risks, that's 70-plus percent out of the DRC, um, and, uh, I think it's around a similar percentage, maybe higher of, of global raw material then processed in China. So you... 34:55 And, and then anything in the DS- I think 10 of 14 cobalt mines in the DRC, something like that, are owned by the Chinese. Anything that's not Chinese is owned by Glencore. Glencore. So- Mm. This is a trifecta. 35:07 So like- And, and they moved so early, like CMOC bought Tenke, like the biggest cobalt mine there, produces over 200,000 tons of copper. Yep. 20-odd thousand tons of cobalt per annum. They bought that in- In 2016. Yes. 35:22 In the worst fucking market. Yeah. Cobalt was on its knees. Copper was on its knees. No one was buying anything. I remember it [chuckles] 'cause I had a, you know, a, a, a... 35:34 It was early in my journey as a-- with the fund, and it was brutal. Everything was trading at like- Is that that time when you were, uh, saying-- you said, "Oh, we're beating the market. We're down 30%. 35:45 What, do you want a fucking pat on the back?" Yeah, yeah, yeah. [laughing] That's, that's exactly the time. Yeah. It's, it's burnt into my memory. 35:52 And, um, yeah, so, so I, I remember the transaction so c- I know where I was sitting. I remember my desk and everything and being like, "What the fuck?" Like, "What is that about?" 36:02 And it was j- it was r- right around the time we'd started to look at, you know, other components in the batteries. We'd done a fair bit of work around lithium, and 36:12 it was just so mind-blowing that they did it at that point. I, the, the foresight was incredible. Yeah. 36:19 And I think they've known where things were heading for a long time, and the Greenbushes transaction was equally shocking at the time, and everyone said they paid overs and, you know, they bought the world's best li- lithium asset 36:32 pretty cheaply, as it turns out. So, 36:34 you know, they've been ahead of this curve for a long time and-They absolutely dominate, um, ownership of, of raw materials in certain pockets, particularly things like cobalt and, um, and, and lith as well when you look at the asset spread globally. 36:54 They then truly dominate the processing and, 36:59 um, even to something like rare earths, which is a fascinating space and I think that's the go-to when everyone talks about, you know, China risk independency because that, that's a commodity where they, they produce a lot of the feedstock and they do the bulk of the processing. 37:14 Now, you know, a, a kind of dirty secret, and I think there's a great piece on, on Livewire from, from a, a guy you guys- Yeah, Kingsley Jones. Yeah, you've- Had him on Money of Mine. It's awesome. Yeah. 37:24 So, so-- Sorry, yes. Y-yeah, you have done a piece with him and, and he breaks that down fantastically well around, you know, even Lynas' material. 37:36 Yeah, it gets sold to Japan, but then it, it, it, you know, it goes to China. If you, if you wanna finish that stuff, it's going through China. So yeah, the dependency is everywhere. 37:48 So rare earths, cobalt, lithium, like fuck, you name it. And it's-- it doesn't stop there either, right? 37:55 And in, in EVs in particular, and this is why I think there's been some guys out there who have literally said that the, 38:03 the policy around committing to, you know, zero ICE beyond twenty thirty or something like that is economic suicide for Western autos. And, and I understand that comment. That's not to say, oh, don't do it. 38:16 It's like we still need to head that direction. But if we're that-- If we-- You gotta be very careful because the head start China has on this is enormous. So raw material security, fucking miles ahead. 38:30 The EU owns nothing, right? [chuckles] US just started buying a couple of things. They're still fucking miles behind. So raw material, China miles ahead. Processing, utterly dominant. 38:42 We don't even know how to do most of this stuff in any sort of a competitive fashion. Then you go into the precursor and actual battery manufacturing. They're f- We don't even have one. 38:55 I even think that, like, there's a few interesting startup-y type th- [scoffs] We- we-- You know, CATL being the primary. We are fucking miles off. 39:06 So s-safe to say China dominate all of those steps, raw material processing, precursor, um- Mm. -and then battery manufacturing and technology itself. All right, Trav, part one. 39:19 There we go, 'cause we went for about a bloody hour and a half, so we decided to, decided to split it up. Thanks to J.D.'s father-in-law for, uh, bloody... 39:26 Look, he did have us there, but he was showcasing all this shit he wants to sell. [laughing] But fucking let's, uh, let's just cut to the chase. I think Rusty bought something on the way out, too, didn't he? 39:35 I reckon he did. I reckon he did pick up, um, some old map of Fr- yeah, I think he was looking at. But, um- And that was-... Wicked menus... with his own money, not near us. [laughing] Yeah. 39:44 Not, not irresponsible use of fund money there. Very true. That was wicked. I'm pretty damn excited for part two. So part two, we're gonna, um, 39:52 we, we sort of then flow on from where we are to your first question is, so how did we get here, Rusty? I guess the history of what's led us to this point of why bifurcation is maybe an, maybe an outcome. Mm. 40:08 Uh, and then I guess we didn't, uh, we didn't really touch on the IRA, but we did talk about, you know, the, the implications of the IRA and where this little premium gets just floated onto the consumer. Mm. 40:22 Hence the, well, it's called the Inflation Reduction Act, and, um, talked about heaps of other stuff. What else did we talk about? I won't lie, I haven't heard the second bit yet. Cannot forget. 40:30 Oh, mate, I think we just, uh, thank our partners and let them listen to the next bit when it comes out. [laughing] Nah, beauty. Thanks to all the partners. Smec Power and Technology at the top of the show. 40:39 The OG sponsors, Anytime Exploration Services and Terra Capital. 40:43 The RC drilling experts at KDrill, and the financial recruitment specialists and golfing extraordinaires, because they only do that on a Friday arvy when they've placed everyone, at JP Search, Michael and Zab. 40:59 Thanks to all the partners. And, uh, who to roo? Money of Mine-ers. Who to roo? Who to roo? 41:04 Information contained in this episode of Money of Mine is of general nature only and does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular person. 41:13 Before making any investment decision, you should consult with your financial advisor and consider how appropriate the advice is to your objectives, financial situation, and needs.