Transcript 0:00 In my opinion, based on seeing setups like this, when it, when these sort of setups finally go, they tend to go pretty fast and pretty hard. 0:07 Um, and I don't know where the supply is gonna come from, um, to meet demand from higher prices. It's one of those ones where it's had such a long period in the, in the doldrums that, 0:20 y- yeah, it's, it's, it's hard for me to see where it's gonna come from. Righto, Money Miners, uh, Easter Monday special. Sam Broome from Sprott. You think Sprott, you think Eric Sprott. 0:33 [laughs] You think Sandvik Ground Support, you think Derek Heard. They're pretty much exactly the same. Uh, there- Don't you think? 0:39 [laughs] There's one difference, and that's that I think Eric Sprott's been, been involved in Sprott for, like, 10 years, but Derek Heard, mate, he is, like, he's been at, like, DSI, S- now Sandvik Ground Support for, like, 30 years. 0:50 He's not, he's not leaving. He's, he's been there forever, and he's not leaving. I think he's- He's not gonna give up like Eric Sprott It's the only jo- [laughs] it might be the only job he's ever had. Yep. 0:57 [laughs] Mate, and, uh, he's pre-- 'cause he knows there's so much still to come out in the ground support world. 1:02 Like, mate, after, as I was saying, the self-drilling Polymix bolts and the bloody resin technolo- injection technology that's gonna be put on Sandvik jumbos. 1:11 Derek Heard wants to see this through, and it's not gonna be the last thing he sees, 'cause he is gonna be making ground support till he's pushing up daisies. I'm telling you that right now. 1:21 Mate, revolutionize the industry. Go Sandvik. Go Derek Heard. And what did yous talk about? With Sam Broome? We talked about a lot of stuff, mate. Anyway, back to Sam Broome. [laughs] Yeah. We talked a lot about gold. 1:33 Gold is a, um, you know, t-top of the list for anyone that kind of works at, works at Sprott. But very interesting coming off the back of some of the predictions. 1:41 Money Miners might know Sam Broome because he featured in our, our investor sort of fundy predictions for the upcoming year, so he had some very interesting picks. 1:49 He's also, uh, located in North America, so he's got a bit of a different kind of lens to the world that we kind of have here down under. 1:58 He sort of talks about the investor sentiment towards gold, the ETF flows, all these kind of things. And then- You can tell, you can tell his style of investing is really, yeah, like, like 2:07 looking for c- contrarian things where you can have a, a differentiated view to what the market's pricing, have some patience, you know, back good projects, good management teams, um, and, and get the reward. 2:16 But interestingly, not con- not a contrarian view right now is, is the love for gold, and he actually thinks it's quite early there, which is, um- Ooh... which, which I did find interesting. Yeah. 2:24 On a contrarian sort of vein of thought, we did speak about vanadium, we spoke about platinum. 2:30 Silver hasn't quite got the, the love yet, so there are a few other metals that, that we touch on that, uh, you put in the, the more hated than loved basket at the moment, and a whole heap more as well. Yeah, very good. 2:41 Righto, let's get into it. Sammy Broome. 2:43 Sam Broome from Sprott, thank you very much for, uh, for, for making the time, your evening, our morning, to, um, to, to chat all things happening in our very volatile markets at the moment. Yeah, thanks lads. 2:56 Pleasure to be here. Thanks for having me on. The pleasure is absolutely ours, mate. 2:59 We, um, we really enjoyed your, your brief perspectives when we, when we dialed you in for our kind of end of year fu- fundy predictions and, uh, a lot has changed in the, uh, the, the few months since we recorded that. 3:11 I mean, markets are, are seemingly very volatile. I think there's like, there's certainly opportunities around and there's, um, at the same time, kind of, you know, ma- the, the macro landscape is changing. 3:22 Tariffs are moving absolutely everything. How are you just taking stock of the market we're in and how it sort of translates to the, the metals stocks that we're, we're all interested in? 3:32 Mate, she's, uh, she's been an absolute cracker of a start to the year, hasn't she? 3:36 Um, gosh, I guess, I guess 2020 was pretty volatile to start the year, but this, this would probably have to be up there as one of the most volatile starts to a year I've had in the business. 3:46 Obviously, the, the macro landscape has, has arguably completely changed in the last sort of two or three weeks. You know, the, the tariffs that the Trump administration have come up with are 4:00 materially larger than even the sort of most hawkish kind of expectations going into this whole shenanigans. So look, we've had crazy levels of volatility. I, I don't think that's... I don't think we're done with it. 4:13 You know, we've had a couple of days of calm now. Um, I dare say we're, we're probably not, not out the back of it. You know, net-net, I think 4:23 probably the biggest beneficiary of every, you know, of everything that's been going on is probably the, the precious metal space. 4:29 Um, you know, the gold market has a weird knack of knowing what's going on ahead of time a lot of the time. You know, it... You could argue it rallied ahead of the COVID crisis as well. 4:41 Obviously, gold, second half of last year had an absolute bender of a run, um, into this. So, you know, just at a very high level, I think it, it, it's, it's no longer the contrarian trade, clearly, but I can't see how 4:56 the precious metals trade, um... 4:59 Or I, I at least see extremely good risk reward even from here after the run we've had in the, in the precious metals trade, just given the sheer dislocation in the global financial system and trading dynamics of the world moving forward. 5:14 Um, you know, as a, as a Kiwi guy living in the US, I feel like I have a pretty good or pretty unique perspective to be able to see things from both sides. 5:23 Um, and I just can't see how this doesn't completely alter the whole US dollar as a reserve asset of the world status. Um, and it, and it isn't gonna change overnight. 5:34 It's such a huge behemoth that it's, it's gonna be one of those things that the changes that result from all this last for, or, or play out over years. Um, and I, and I th- I think that trend's only gonna 5:47 become even more entrenched. Um, there'll be some volatility along the way, but gold's probably the big w- big winner. 5:54 Um, in the very short term at least, you know, anything related to global economic activity's arguably the loser. Um, you know, we've seen big, some big downdrafts in a lot of the base metals. 6:07 Energy's doing it really tough.Um, that is the logical first order of thinking, at least in the short term. Um, 6:16 in saying that, I think we all know what central banks around the world and, and, and governments are gonna do if things get bad enough, right? They're gonna turn on the spigots of, of easing and stimulus again. 6:28 We're already starting to see some signs of that, or at least talk, you know, discussions about that happening. Um, so I s- I don't necessarily think it's gonna be as bad for some commodities as it might seem right now. 6:41 Um, and even then you've still got, you know, you've still got copper north of four bucks and, and things like that. That's on top of China's property sector basically being in a depression for the last couple of years. 6:52 So a lot of these things are actually hanging out or holding on better than I would've expected, given what's going on in terms of eco- economic activity, and I think it actually bodes quite well, you know, perhaps six months plus out once we get through this kind of crazy phase where no one quite knows what to do or think. 7:10 So that's kind of the really high... the real high-level take. Probably nothing too nuanced there. 7:16 It's probably consensus at the moment, but this is kinda one of those events that's so sort of, um, kinda out of left field that consensus might be the place to be for the time being. 7:27 Credit to you, Sam, when we spoke in December, your non-consensus pick was a weaker US dollar, and it was, um, it was a bit out there. 7:36 You were sort of reading the tea leaves of what was happening in the, in the macro land and the, the so-called Mar-a-Lago Accords, the... all these sorts of things. But that's turned out to be, uh, quite a good pick. 7:46 But we'll, uh, we'll save your flowers for the- [laughs]... end of the year. Let, let's dive a bit deeper into gold, Sam. 7:52 So I'm, I'm curious to hear, to start with, how the dynamic is over where you are, because here you can't walk five meters without someone telling you what the gold price is. 8:01 But what's that sort of like for you based in the States now? It's completely different, mate. 8:06 I mean, you know, as someone who's spent a bit of time in Aussie where gold is a, is a part of the general discussion on, you know, investing and things like that, here in the States it's still very much a, I would argue, a fringe asset. 8:18 You know, I got, I got a mate who's a financial, you know, r- generic r- you know, financial advisor, you know, got clients, whole portfolio, whole net worth with them type of thing. He has... 8:29 They have, last I checked, he had zero, they had zero allocation of gold. It's not even a consideration in your, this part of your broader portfolio. And that's physical gold, let alone mining equities. 8:40 You know, that's just, just straight gold exposure. I... If I had, if I had to guess, I bet you the average, you know, gold exposure in the average US portfolio is sub half a percent. 8:51 It- it's, it's probably even less than that. Uh, and, and there's data on that, you know. 8:55 There's, um, you know, an ETF, you know, gold-related ETF mar- you know, total net asset value as, as a percentage of total ETF, um, capital, and it's, like, at the moment it's, like, sub, I think, uh... 9:12 Where have I got it here? Look, the gold mining exposure is a sub 0.3% of total ETF AUM, right? Um, at, at its peak in 2012 it was almost... It was at nearly one and a half percent. So we're, like, mid... 9:28 We're a fraction of a fraction of what we used to be, uh, you know, at, at the last cycle peak for gold. So it's a, it's an afterthought right now. Um, it is... I will say it's, it's probably changing. 9:39 You know, it's at some point for a lot of my career discussing with institutions, like, owning gold is almost a career risk for a PM over here, or it has been. Um, 9:52 I, I do think that's probably in the early stages of, of, of, of changing, um, but it's still very much... Fringe asset's probably not quite the right term, but it's, it's certainly an afterthought for most P- PMs. 10:06 You know, you... 10:07 Here in the US large cap tech, um, NASDAQ, all that type of stuff, that's been the only game in town for the better part of the last 15 years, and really the last 25 years with a few, few blips here and there. 10:19 So there's not been no real need to go out and own other assets. Um, so it, it is definitely different over here in the US. It's not, it's not as mainstream as, as it is in, in Aussie. 10:32 You know, even, even Europe it's a lot more mainstream from what I gather. Obviously China and Asia and, you know, third world countries where you've had... 10:41 you've had to deal with currency debasement and store value type issues much more severely than here in the US, it's, it's mainstream. But here it's, it's still, it's still very much under the radar. 10:54 I'm surprised, Sam, hearing you, hearing you... 10:56 Like, I know you're a, a contrarian at, at heart, but I'm surprised hearing you say the precious trade is, is the most attractive kind of way to, way, way to, you know, to, to, to play the current environment, given it's, it's clearly in a bull market. 11:08 You know, gold's clearly in a bull market. So what... Like, what are, what are you doing to measure kind of how, how far or how deep that bull market might be? You know, I mean, I'm still... I, I think one thing I... 11:21 The, the tariff news really did flip a switch in terms of my thinking about gold. I mean, I'm always that Sprott. You can't really be a Sprott [laughs] and not be bullish gold, right? It's kind of in our DNA. 11:31 Um, but I, but I really do believe that, uh, you know, it's a worthwhile portfolio diversifier. But when that tariff news hit, I mean, 11:39 you know, it, it's basically a message to the world that to me it, it read like the US does no long- no longer wants the privilege of the re- of the world's reserve currency. The, the privilege and the burden, right? 11:51 There are downsides to being the world's reserve currency, especially if, on the manufacturing side, and that's, that's clearly something they're targeting. So, you know, a lot of money gets made by 12:04 following what governments and central banks are telling you they're trying to do, right? Um, and to me that's, that's what this announcement, a huge part of what this announcement was aimed at doing. 12:16 Um, so I think the-The, when the, the tariff announcement really kind of kicked gold into being really, really important here, 'cause there is really no alternative, right? You're not, you're not gonna see 12:31 large capital going and buying, you know, European bonds or Japanese bonds or Chinese bonds en masse. There isn't really an alternative other than the US dollar and gold. Um, so I think that ratchets up. 12:44 There are, there are... In terms of the more specific nitty-gritty stuff as to why I still think it's fairly contrarian, I mean, gold itself's had a great run, right? Um, and 12:55 generally that's been dr- put down to central bank buying, right? Central banks don't buy mi- uh, gold ETFs, they don't buy mining equities, mining ETFs, they don't buy silver. 13:05 So that's why some of these other parts of the sector are still relatively, you know, lagging or, or aren't receiving a ton of interest. I mean, just go and look at the, the flows into and out of 13:19 both, you know, something like, you know, the gold mining... The go- the gold bullion ETFs and the mining ETFs, right? I mean, GDX, the biggest gold mining ETF, has absolutely hemorrhaged capital this year. 13:31 It's, it's had... I think it's lost 15 to 20% of its shares outstanding this year to outflows, right? And this is with the price going up, you know, whatever it is, up now 30% on the year or something like that. So 13:45 I dare say at, at market tops, you're not gonna be seeing steady, sustained outflows, right? You're gonna, you're gonna be seeing, you're gonna be seeing the opposite. You're gonna be seeing money flying in. 13:57 Um, on top of that, I mean, in, in, on the equity space, you know, I mean, financing activity, IPOs, you know, all that sort of activity is still relatively low. 14:12 I mean, I think 2024, I think I was reading the other day, was like the worst year for IPO activity on the ASX on record or something like that. Um, you know, like it's... 14:23 And obviously that's beyond just the gold space, but it's, it's generally been quite a hard environment, particularly at the s- smaller end of town. 14:29 Like, when, when you get to sort of mid and the end of bull markets, you have just rampant speculative activity, small caps flying, money just gushing in. Like, 2021 was a bit like that, right? 14:41 When the sort of everything bubble, when... I think there was a counter to last year. There was record IPO activity on the ASX, you know, and it was just money flying around everywhere. You know, I, I had clients 14:54 just keep, um, closing up shop with me because they, they were only up 100% on the year when they were making 300% over somewhere else. You know what I mean? Like that sort of stuff. 15:03 There, there was definitely more of that sort of a vibe. Um, we are completely at the opposite end of that today, despite where gold is, despite the mining equities starting to move. 15:12 It, it just feels very, very different today from my perspective with a North American-centric clientele. Are, are you excited about sort of silver in that precious space? 15:22 Are you, you one of the people that still think that has value as a precious? Yeah. I mean, people are starting to look at it as, you know, gold's run, they've missed the boat. 15:32 Silver hasn't really run as much yet, you know. Is it gonna be the next... You know, it's gonna be the n- the way to play the game that hasn't moved yet. I definitely am a silver bull. 15:42 I'm, I've kind of been a reluctant [chuckles] silver bull over the years. Um, you know, the, some of the, the people involved in the silver space can get a bit annoying sometimes. 15:51 But I, I actually do think that the silver space looks quite interesting. You know, we're staring down the barrel of what looks like it's gonna be the fifth year in a row of supply deficits. 16:03 Um, it, it plays that kind of dual role as a precious metal and an industrial commodity, right? So it's kinda hard to pick. Um, you know, but... 16:13 And as I said, you know, the main buying, the main thing driving gold right now is central bank buying, which they, you know, they don't touch silver. So it's hard to know exactly when it's gonna go. 16:23 But from a, from a more traditional commodity supply-demand standpoint, things look quite interesting. Um, technically, you know, I, I like to use technicals as part of my timing. It's not perfect. 16:35 It's not the be-all and end-all, but it can be useful. You know, looking at a silver chart, for me, it looks like it's been... It's sitting there ready to go, and, and we all know when silver goes, it tends to go, 16:48 go pretty hard and it tends to be a pretty fun ride. So I, I like silver. I think it's worth owning silver. Um, finding quality mining equities can be a little bit tougher in the silver space. 16:59 There aren't that many, but, you know, we have a, a handful here that we quite like, that we think are gonna do quite well. Um, so yeah, I, I do like silver. I do. 17:09 I, I own more gold 'cause I find it easier to find things I like. Um, but I think silver as a commodity, it's, is 2025 gonna be the year? I think it could be. Rounding out the, the, the precious sort of s- spectrum, um, 17:25 I, I, I know you've been thinking about platinum for years now, and, uh- [laughs]... it's, it's never quite been the right year to buy. [laughs] Tell me about it. [laughs] 17 years in the making. 17:36 I bet its technical chart kept looking like it had bottomed out over and over and over again. [laughs] Is the day coming closer? Poor old platinum, eh? 17:44 [laughs] I mean, find me another commodity that hasn't had a s- had a, even anything even resembling a bull market for that length of time. You know, it's, I think 2008 it topped, right, with the GFC. Um, 17:56 look, I like it. I, uh, I personally own it, to be honest. Um, just the metal. Um, uh, I think it's like silver on steroids. I mean, if you like silver, I think for similar reasons, right? 18:07 They're both sort of quasi-precious, almost industrial metals these days. 18:13 Um, it's kind of been left for dead on the, you know, this narrative that demand was gonna evaporate 'cause we're all gonna be driving EVs and, you know. 18:23 In reality-You know, the, the death of the at least the hybrid car has been greatly over-exaggerated, right? And in fact, that's been a- one of the strongest growth segments, um, which they... 18:37 You know, hybrids tend to use more PGEs than traditional combustion engines. So there's, there's a nice, there's a nice combination of fundamentals that make platinum continue to look interesting. 18:48 I might, I might be bald by the time, uh, it finally moves. I don't know. But you look at that chart, um, and gosh, when that thing goes, it, it's, it's gonna be one of those... 19:01 Well, well, I shouldn't say it's going to be. In my opinion, based on seeing setups like this, when it, when these sort of setups finally go, they tend to go pretty fast and pretty hard. Um, 19:11 and I don't know where the supply is gonna come from, um, to meet demand from higher prices. 19:16 It's one of those ones where it's had such a long period in the, in the doldrums that it, uh, yeah, it's, it's hard for me to see where it's gonna come from. So I continue to like platinum. 19:27 I continue to grind my teeth here waiting for it to move. But I do think sometime in the next couple of years, something's gonna happen there. 19:34 Old bloody CrossBoundary Energy might be an investment for Broomie to make in t- waiting for platinum. Like, if this platinum's gonna stay down there, maybe this could be an alternative. 19:45 Like, the Norwegian Investment Fund, they're... I don't know if, w- if they're in platinum or not, but they're in CBE. 40 million buckaroos into that, probably on the back of the Kamau Kukula 19:57 Baseline Renewables project that yous discussed last week. Unbelievable. Mate, CBE, I think their people are gonna be lining up to hand over cash. [laughs] It's phenomenal, mate. 20:07 Yeah, the, the likes of Norges, um, tipping into CBE just goes to show how, um... what a force this, this company is when it comes to- Mate-... providing energy to power the mines we need, mate... 20:15 mate, what a vote of confidence. And mate, when we're... That energy you speak of, this is like build, own, operate hybrid power stations all across the world. Check out this bloke in red circled. You won't forget him. 20:29 That is Tim Taylor. He's the Australian man to talk to, to bloody get CBE power in your mine site. Absolute world-class leaders. Would you call him the tool man? T- Tim "The Tool Man" Taylor. 20:42 [laughs] He has the tools to give you the power. Ah, love it. Right, let's get back into Sam Broome. Put your money into CBE, Sprott. 20:49 I, I don't think we can talk about platinum or, or PGM's in general without touching on the, the geopolitics. W- what do you make of... 20:57 I think when I h- I last heard you speak about South Africa, they were sort of on the up. They were coming into an election. 21:03 Um, so y- yeah, I mean, South Africa and then broadly Zimbabwe and, and Russia is a bit of a, um, a, a dark horse in there, perhaps more with, with palladium, but what do you make of the, the setups in those countries? 21:17 Uh, So- South Africa, I mean, obviously South Africa's like, what? 80 something percent of supply. It's huge. It's basically the whole, the whole market. 21:25 Um, look, frankly, South Africa's probably gotten moderately better. 21:29 It's, it, it probably is improving, you know, and sometimes there's money to be made when things go from as bad as they can get to, to just sl- you know, slightly bad. 21:39 Um, so I, I still don't think you're gonna see huge amounts of investment flow into South Africa. Um, so I, I don't think you're gonna see massive r- supply responses from CapEx getting spent in South Africa. 21:52 I just don't... I just can't see that happening in the, in the near term, say the next three to five years. Um, it's just that, uh... You know, I just, I just can't see it. I mean, then you go to... 22:04 Next down the list is Zimbabwe and, uh, and Russia, right? And they're even less likely to receive capital investment to increase supply. So, you know, that, that's part of the bull- bullish 22:17 mid to long-term story for platinum. 22:19 There certainly, there certainly is, like, a bunch of money to be made when you, when you, you bet on the changing political regime before everyone else has kind of factored in what that could really look like. 22:30 Because effectively, you... If the risk appetite changes or the, um, you know, the discount rate is lowered because, because of a, a regime change, that's, that's a big, big difference to the valuations of equities. 22:41 Just look what ha- Like, if you would've bought Argentinian stocks, um, or, or equities on the announcement of Milei becoming president or even, or even a week later, um, before the rest of the world had kind of figured out what that could actually, you know, mean, mean for the change in, in, um, in, in capital for that, for that jurisdiction, you would've made plenty of money. 22:59 Yeah. No, ab- absolutely. I mean, you c- you can argue there are other places, like Colombia might be on the cusp of that with the elections there going on. Um, you know, Ecuador just had an interesting election result. 23:11 Um, you know, even, even Brazil- Interesting... might improve. So, yeah- What are you, what are you, what are you seeing there that, that gets you interested in those, uh, South American jurisdictions? Um- Yeah... 23:20 uh, there's just, there's a shift towards the right. You know, a more business friendly, potentially mining friendly, um, administrations. Um, so it's, it's a general trend around the world, right? 23:33 I mean, Trump, you know, it's the Trump kind of syndrome, right? There's been a lot of, um, left-leaning governments in power through much of Latin America for the last five to eight years. 23:46 Um, and you know, the pendulum swings, and it's swinging back the other way in a lot of parts of Latin America. So Milei, obviously in Argentina is the example you guys brought up, but 23:57 it's, it's happening in a few places. Um, you know, Latin... If I'm gonna talk jurisdictions that 24:02 might be interesting, um, for that kind of dynamic, looking at places potentially opening up, the, the, the whole of Latin America looks, looks, is looking quite interesting on that front. 24:14 Did, did you sort of catch, we spoke about, um, not too long ago comments from, from Scott Bessent and the US in general being pretty pro Latin America and wanting to get on side, and Latin America not see what happened to Africa with regards to Chinese influence happen-In, in Latin America as well. 24:33 Did you catch sort of that? I, I didn't, I didn't catch that interview, um, but I have heard it. 24:40 I mean, it, it seems like the current administration wants to create, or at least a sort of lite version of a America's sort of trading block for key critical te- uh, you know, critical, um, materials, commodities, things like that. 24:55 Um, you know, obviously the big winners from the, the tr- the recent tariff sort of Canada and Mexico, for example, right? That kind of avoided the worst of the tariffs. 25:05 Um, so I, I didn't see that, but it, it does fit with the messaging and the, the sort of reading between the lines that's coming out of this and, and the, the, the members of the Trump administration over here. 25:20 On the, on the flip side, sometimes a, a government can go from being, um, you know, relatively pro-business to much less pro-business. 25:28 And, uh, one place I'm observing that kind of really play out in recent history is, is Indonesia right now. 25:36 The, the new administration that's coming there has juiced up or proposing to juice up the, the, uh, the royalties and effective tax rates on, on, um, a lot of the, you know, the, the nickel producers in that region. 25:46 As a, as a contrarian at heart, are you getting very interested in the nickel space once again? You know, that's a very interesting question. We spoke a little bit about nickel just- this today on that sort of a front. 25:57 Um, I, I've kind of been a big nickel fanboy for forever. Um, you know, nickel cobalt, when I first started at Sprott was kind of... 26:08 I had a little hunch that it was gonna be a, have a real run back, I guess would've been 2016. 26:14 Um, and so I've been kind of following the space relatively closely since then, and there's obviously been some big ups and downs. I mean, In- Indonesia, I... You guys probably know more about that in, in Perth there. 26:24 You know, Stone's over from, from Indonesia from us. Um, so... But o- obviously it's hugely important to the nickel market given what, I don't know, what percentage of global nickel supply is Indonesia these days. 26:38 Um, the, the nickel market for me has always been one of those ones that because it's so concentrated in Indo, all it's gonna take is, is a, like you said, a moderately... 26:48 moderate deterioration in conditions there for it to have quite an outsize impact. I, I did notice in my nickel portfolio last night on the ASX a bunch of stuff s- s- you know, um, moving around. 27:01 Um, so I don't know if that was to do with an announcement in Indonesia I might have missed. Uh, maybe you guys can tell me. Yeah. But, uh- Not, not... I, I don't think there was one overnight, but, um, about a... 27:11 I wanna say best part of a month ago, uh, there was, there was like a pro- a proposal for... that, that co- for... 27:18 coming out from the administration, which has only been in power for about a, a year, and the proposal was to, to change the effective royalty rate on like various intermediate nic- nickel products all the way kind of up the spectrum. 27:31 Like, insomuch, I think, I think the royalty was going from like 9% to a minimum of like 14%, scaling up to 19% depending on the nickel price. 27:40 Um, so it ki- it kinda just like really, would really effectively r- you know, cut into the profitability of a lot of the companies. 27:45 And, and, and keep in mind a lot of those companies, um, they, they invested and they built in, um, in the industrial park, I forget its full name. Morowali. 27:54 The Morowali Industrial Park, because they, they, they, they had like a 10-year tax holiday or an eight-year tax holiday, but what good is a tax holiday if you don't have any tax to pay because you're not making any profit because the royalty's been jacked up? 28:05 [laughs] Yeah. Well, I mean, even, even the, the Chinese bet, you know, the new supply, the, the HBEL stuff coming out of Indo, I mean, they must be hurting at these nickel prices, right? 28:15 They, they can't be making heck of a lot of money at these prices. And then at... Like you said, I mean, Indonesia's... You know, they don't wanna give this stuff away, right? 28:25 Um, so it's not surprising that we're hearing this. Obviously it's a hugely environmentally destructive method of mining too, so I've... You know, we've been hearing about pushback in country for quite some time about... 28:37 You know, not everyone's a big fan of... in, in Indonesia, what's been going on over there in the nickel space. So, look, I, I don't have any specific insights onto whether there's gonna be any imminent changes there. 28:48 Um, but it is something that I think as... 28:52 if you're a nickel fan, you gotta keep a close eye on because it wouldn't take much to upset the apple cart over there, and all of a sudden the nickel space goes from being probably one of the hated, the, you know, most contrarian hated commodities out there right now. 29:04 Like, that and cobalt and, I dunno, maybe lithium's vying for, vying for the most contrarian setup right now. 29:12 Um, I, I do see more potential in nickel for some sort of disturbance to the market than, than lithium if I was gonna, if I was gonna have a go at picking a bottom commodity. 29:23 There, there, there was another commodity as well, Sam, that you put forward, and I wouldn't put it in the hated basket with those other ones because I think people just don't care about it, but vanadium is one you'd spoken to us about, and you sort of spoke to the, the narrative of a bit of battery demand picking up. 29:39 It's obviously still, uh, an alloy, or used in the steelmaking process as well, but what's the, what's the latest in vanadium world? Yeah. 29:48 I seem to be a masochist and love these sort of either completely, you know, unfollowed or majorly beat up commodities. 29:56 Um, so vanadium piqued my interest sort of mid last year, uh, as I started reading these articles about these sort of massive, um, vanadium redox flow battery complexes supposedly breaking ground in China. Um, 30:14 so since then the vanadium price has... I, I guess it's, uh, the benchmark prices are slightly up over the last month or so, but probably down on when we had that conversation, so it's only gotten worse. Um, 30:27 you know, it's this commodity that was, you know, pentoxide, if we're using, using pentoxide was-You know, north of 30 bucks a pound at the last cycle back in 2018. It's sort of five-ish dollars a pound today. 30:40 So you're, you know, 80, 85% lower than where it was at cycle peaks. Really bombed out. You've got, you know, a number of prominent producers either battling bankruptcy or close to it. 30:54 Um, almost the entire cost curve underwater. Um, you know- How much, how much primary vanadium production is there, or is it largely like a co-product of- Um, there might... 31:05 The, the co-product's probably 70% of the market. Yeah. You know. Um, you know, that's, that's the production that comes as part of the steel-making process. It's like the vanadium bearing slag at the end. 31:17 Um, China and Russia dominate that market as, as well, so there is this sort of security of supply angle to that one as well, if anything really goes pear-shaped. 31:27 You know, I keep checking my, you know, export ban news every morning to check to see if, uh- [laughs]... vanadium was, was on that list. Um, but, uh, anyway. 31:39 So it's just that it's just, just ticks a lot of the boxes I look for if I'm really trying to get contrarian and buy something that's really wasted and bottomed out. You can get your... 31:50 You can get completely obliterated playing this game, right? It, it's kind of one of those situations where... A- and... 'Cause there aren't very many ways to play it. 31:57 Um, but it's, it's sort of a complete wipe- wipe out or a 10 bagger from here type setup, right? And, and it's probably 50/50 odds each way. Um, and picking the timing's extremely tough. 32:09 Obviously, the, the main use for vanadium right now is a steel additive. So global economic activity, China property slump, you know, they're all not bullish at the moment. 32:21 Um, although there were steel regulations, new steel regulations in China that came into effect last year, which in theory should, you know, increase vanadium consumption by sort of 10% to 15% if all else being equal. 32:35 Um, I think steel demand is going down at the moment, so that's probably offsetting any of those potential gains. 32:41 But the, the real step change catalyst is the sheer quantity of these vanadium redox flow batteries that are supposedly, like, in construction or very close to it. Like, these aren't in permitting phase. 32:53 These are getting built, you know, or very close to breaking ground. The, the, the number, as I've seen quoted are so large that I, I, I don't... I can't believe them. 33:05 There's just not enough vanadium to, to suit them, which does make me question the thesis, right? 33:10 When something sounds too good to be true or, or the numbers look too big relative to the markets involved, it does make you pause a little bit. Um, but even if a fraction of them are true, I mean, it's gonna, 33:22 you know, it's gonna drive a material. You know, it's gonna take VRF demand from sort of sub 10% to, you know, 20, 30, 40% of total vanadium demand within the next couple of years. So... 33:35 And that's under sort of lowest case discounting scenario. So I think it's interesting. Very hard to play. Not a lot of ways to play it. Um, highly speculative, but I... The contrarian in me couldn't help it, so- 33:50 I'm interested now... it's one I've been following. I think I'm gonna have to do some homework on that myself. There's, uh... Yeah, there's no doubt. 33:55 There, there's a, there's a type of business in, in our, in our world, Sam, that are just remarkable businesses. 34:02 Um, kinda, kind of hard to replicate, hard to emulate, but royalty businesses are just, like, beautiful businesses. We, we don't have many listed on our wonderful exchange, but over in North America, there's many. Um, 34:16 what do you, what do you make of the, the, uh, the royalty players at the moment and kind of, you know, their, their, their, 34:24 uh, appeal to, to investors, you know, amid any kind of market moves versus, versus the equities? Great question. I, I love the royalty business model. Um, I'm sur- I'm surprised it's not- Spot- Spot's got one... 34:40 as popular in Aussie. [laughs] We... Yeah, I guess we do. Private, private, uh, yeah, private royalty fund there. Um, I, I mean, it's probably partly a function of the tough markets we've had. You know, a lot... 34:54 Most of the last 10 years has been pretty tough going in the mining equity space, um, particularly the precious metals equity space, which is where we do, do a lot of our business. 35:03 Through that, the better run royalty companies have generated by far the, the best returns on average. 35:10 Um, a lot of that is you get, you get all the sort of optionality to the commodity price without all the risk, the mining risk, you know, inflation risk, margin compression risk, all of that sort of risk that goes with the mining equities. 35:27 On the flip side, you, you know, you can argue they're not quite as leveraged into... in a full-blown bull market experience. Um, you know, you, you look now, for example, where gold's just gone from, 35:39 you know, 2,000 to 3,200 bucks at an ounce. On, on paper, a lot of the mining equities are gonna have a lot more torque in terms of, you know, earnings growth, free cash flow growth per ounce of production. 35:53 You know, you, you look at some of these big royalty companies, right, and they're $30 to $50 billion companies doing, you know, $1 to $2 billion of revenue a year, and they've got, like, 19 employees, right? 36:04 They're just, they're just capital light businesses in a capital heavy industry. Um, which as a, as a business is a... To me, is a really good... It's a really good business model. 36:18 You know, there's, there's kind of a saying that you, you know, you, um... What is it? You, you date the royal... Uh, you date the mining companies, but you marry the royalty companies, right? It's kinda like... 36:27 They're kinda more... They're great sort of long-term hold vehicles or, or much more applicable to that kind of approach than, say, trading your way in and out of cycles in gold or in the, in the mining equities. 36:40 Um-So I like them. They're kind of like core parts of my client portfolio. They're ones I tend to touch less. I'm less tempted to trade and sell. I... 36:49 You know, you look at, you know, some of the larger cap North American-listed, uh, precious metals royalty companies outperform, you know, the Nasdaq, um, during... from 2012 to till now, right? 37:04 Most of which was a bear market for, for gold up until the last couple of years, or at least a, a flat market. 37:09 So they've got re- generally got very high, you know, return on equity, things like that, return on capital invested. Um, they're, they also have a lot of embedded optionality to things like exploration success, right? 37:23 You'll, you'll probably hear Pierre Lassonde talk about Franco's founding royalty and what he paid and how much it's paid back since, given the sheer quantity of exploration 37:35 success they had that then turned into future ounces, right, they didn't pay a cent for. So when done right, I think the royalty, royalty business model is really, really good. 37:45 I will say today it's kind of been found out or the market has bid it up to much higher multiples than the mining equities. So on paper, the pushback I usually get is great, but they're very expensive. 37:59 I'd push back on that a little bit. I, I, I don't think markets are stupid. Um, and I think they bid it up for a reason. I don't think the, the bidder on royalty companies are ever gonna be cheap. 38:08 Um, I think they're always gonna trade at a higher multiple. But if you're bargain hunting, they're not the absolute most bargain place you could probably look right now. Mm. Yeah, they are- Why, why, why, why do you... 38:21 I'm curious for you guys, why do you think it's, they're completely absent from the ASX? Is there a cultural reason there? Is it... What's the- I, I don't-... sort of thinking there? 38:29 I don't personally think it's a cultural reason so much as just a, a function of the success of the American ones. Like, they, they happen to be listed there. Like, we do have Deterra and that, that trades well. 38:42 People, people love it. Generalist investors will flock to it for, for iron ore exposure if it sort of fits their, their parameters and stuff. 38:49 So in, in part, I think it's a, a kind of quirk of history that Wheaton and Franco just happened to be there. We, we didn't have the oil and gas analogues either to- Yeah... to, for, for the invest- No... 39:01 the early investors to... And it... 39:03 And because th- there are these, like, beautiful dynamics of the royalty business is that it's, like, it's quite hard to compete with the existing royalty business who's already doing well because they have the lower cost of capital. 39:13 Yeah. So capital kind of- Yeah... goes that way. And, and the other part too is, like, our... 39:17 I think, I think that the ASX has for- much more forthcoming equity capital markets, so even royalty financing vehicles have a hard go here because companies are, are a lot more apprehensive about, you know, royalty finance versus equity finance if the equity's there on, on the table for obvious reasons. 39:32 I do know a couple of people in these parts that have made a bit of money from royalties. Totally. I, I... Yeah, that, that, and that's the irony too. Like- Mm... 39:38 our billionaires, like Gina, Clive, Bennett, it's like they, you know, they're... That's, that's royalties that have made them. Kept them- Yeah... kept them private and kept the cash flow flowing to them. 39:48 Oh, if you get lucky to get in- involved in the right royalty space, I mean, they're, they're magic assets, you know. Yeah. Um, as long as you pay the right amount for them or, or you get them at an early stage, so. 39:59 Yeah. Arguably the- Yeah. I'm a big fan... best kept secret model. La- Yep... last sort of question that came to mind. 40:05 With, with all the stuff that is happening in, in the States, are you a bit more bullish about mining projects in America? 40:11 Or do you think the, uh, the red tape and where the States is at is, like, that ship sailed a long time ago? You know, I think you can afford to be a little bit more bullish here. 40:23 I mean, the US was tough, has been tough for most of my career. I mean, people always talk about, you know, jurisdictional risk in places like West Africa and, you know, Latin America and places like that. 40:35 In our experience, in terms of realized risk, like, I've probably got bitten more by US-based projects getting the permitting kiboshed or something like that than I have my assets taken off me in West Africa, right? So 40:51 my personal view was that, and possibly still is, the US has a lot more risk than people gave it credit for. 41:01 Um, I will say, you know, under this administration, it does seem like the permitting process is gonna get much more streamlined. 41:08 Um, so I, I do think it's, I do think it's worth dusting off your, your favorite US assets. There's clearly gonna be a push for domestic production of a whole range of different critical materials. 41:20 Um, so if you were gonna buy assets or companies in the US, it's better today than it has been any time in my time in my career, arguably. And it's probably not just, uh, it's not just the US either. 41:33 I mean, Canada's now looks like it's gonna get serious. 41:36 They're rolling back red tape and reducing the sort of duplicate components of its permitting system, you know, now that it's kind of had a bit of a shakeup too, that things aren't always gonna be hunky dory with their neighbor. 41:47 So I do think permitting projects in North America in general just got a little bit better in the last, call it, six months or, or even less, whatever it is, five months, so. Last one from me, Sam. 42:03 You transitioned from, uh, from geo to, to portfolio manager. What's one thing you, you didn't appreciate as a geo that you, you kind of had to, had to come to terms with when you became a market animal? 42:16 Gosh, you know, market animal ma- uh, management quality is so important, right? When you're a geo, you sort of just look at the rocks- Mm... and, and think, you know, that it's the be-all and end-all. 42:29 Um, once you start managing money, you realize that crappy management will do a really good job of screwing up great rocks for you if you're not careful. 42:37 Um, so, you know, to the point where now I'd take an average deposit with a, with a A+ crack team, um, over the other way around, to be honest. 42:48 Uh, I've, I've learned that lesson the hard way a couple of times in my career. So, you know, that, that's, that's probably the big one, and it comes down to a whole bunch of things from, you know, capital management to, 43:00 you know, the whole range of factors involved. But I'd probably put that one easily as my biggest, biggest learning lesson now being on the capital market side. 43:08 I think that's a, uh, a fantastic point to leave the conversation on. Thank you so much, Sam Broome, for joining us on Money of Mine. Cheers, guys. Appreciate it. Glad to be on. Thank you, mate. So sensational. 43:20 Thank you, Samuel Broome, or if it's Samuel. Is it? I reckon it'll be Samuel. I reckon. Yeah, let's run with that. And let's run with, uh, going to the JRX conference, May 20 to 22nd. Make sure you use the bloody code. 43:34 You get a discount. I'm going. I can't wait. It's the center of tech and innovation, and there's some freaking good keynote speakers gonna be there, mate. Get, get our tickets. Cannot wait. Get your tickets. 43:44 Link's in the show notes. So our great partners also, MMS, Grounded, Samba Ground Support, CR Insurance, KDrill, WA Water Boards. Go Jaro James. Quattro, KCA, Black Diamond Drilling Services. 43:56 And mentioned in the show, Cross Boundary Energy. Hoorooroo. Hoorooroo. Hoorooroo. 44:00 [upbeat music] The information contained in this episode of Money of Mine is of general nature only and does not take into account the objectives, financial situation, or needs of any particular person. 44:11 Before making any investment decision, you should consult with your financial advisor and consider how appropriate the advice is to your objectives, financial situation, and needs.